Applespider said:
Whoop de doo! While you're welcome to put that up as an assignment for the May vote, I for one, hope that it doesn't win. While I appreciate that Memorial Day means something for those in the US, for the international members it means nothing (Armistice Day on 11 November is more international).
Suggesting that we try to take pictures where the US military fought is pretty condescending, particularly in the current global climate. Since the majority of international members are in the UK and Australia (and the US haven't fought on either of those soils), I'd object strongly to that being the next assignment. Feel free to have a Memorial Day thread but don't expect us all to wave pompoms about it.
Perhaps having a less confrontational 'Memorials' would be a way around it, allowing US members to shoot Memorial Day while those internationally can shoot what is important to them.
Well, I did at least try to include international members in my idea at least.
If you have any other ideas on how my original idea might work for an "international" audience like we have on MR, then offer them.
Memorial Day as a theme was offered since at least here in the US, it might lead to some interesting images. It could even be offered as a secondary theme.
Keep in mind that the theme I suggested is not about the military aspects only. Notice I said:
For those in the US, it might lead to interesting images of excess, fun, remembrance, and the such. For others around the world, I am not sure what we will see.
Maybe I should have been more clear. I see this theme as being one that could be filled with images of parades, Rolling Thunder, cemeteries of those fallen; but also of the picnics, the throngs that go to the beach here in the US, the Memorial Day sales, and the such.
You might want to study US War history. While we might not have fought actual battles on these soils, many US service men and women last set foot on these soils before their untimely deaths. And in some corners of these countries they are still remembered, or should be remembered for their sacrifice.
Given some of the comments made in other threads, I disagree with the glass half empty that you and Abstract seem to have. I mention your two names only because of the comments and moderations you both have mentioned in the "assignments" threads.
My comments have been in trying to make this more open to others. Strict time lines with short notice does not help us develop the craft of photography. Which is what I would hope is the goal of "themes. One to get us out and contribute to a "theme" in a limited time span. And maybe my desire and others to contribute images that fall outside of that time span that might help in "themes".
Having two different threads does not help in getting healthy comments. And adds to the message bloat that is MR. For myself I look forward to "assignments" that are realistic is giving thought to. My "Memorial Day Assignment" gives more than 30 days at this point to give some thought as to how one might approach it.
Both you and Abstract gave comments in another thread that give rise as to whom the threads are truly about. I believe it was you that said that if I wanted more from "assignments", I should go off to a photo forum. Abstract seems to have requested deletion of a thread that had a common image from different points of view. It seems to me that by some standard you both are the voice for photo threads in the Digital Photo Forum.
I am all for rules. They can provide order. But they should not be exclusionary in an open forum like MR. To be honest I never saw a poll as to those that should hold sway over the "assignment" threads.
And with both of your recent comments here and on other threads, I question both of your abilities to be open and fair to those posting in photo threads in the Digital Photo Forum. As it was suggested to me, maybe it is time for you both to seek your own private forum with the rules that you both can live with.
MR has not been so much about rules, as it has been about guidelines. That is what has made MR fun. IMO you both are zapping that fun in a forum that i and many others fought for.