Pool: Blind test - Choose your favorite display

[Coffee_Time]

Hello!
I want to do a little experiment - as the title says - choose your favorite display and feel free to comment below. Later I'll unveil full photo to see what phones are.
Let's go!

 

[nfl46]

Is nightmode/night shift or whatever each company call it for their device on for the phone on the left?

I have a pretty good idea which phones these are.

 

[Coffee_Time]

Is nightmode/night shift or whatever each company call it for their device on for the phone on the left?

I have a pretty good idea which phones these are.

Both phones blue light filter enabled, brightness at max, blue light toggle set to best match withe color.

 

[mollyc]

Why don’t you put the same screen on both phones for a better comparison? And avoid the glare.

 

[Coffee_Time]

Why don’t you put the same screen on both phones for a better comparison? And avoid the glare.

It's the same color white on both screens. The displays are different and reproduce it diffrent.
[doublepost=1555588550][/doublepost]Also here is the diffrence between the display's white and the camera sensor that cannot capture that white.

 

[HolyGrail]

Objective tests should always have equaled samples of what is being tested. Both phones should display the same content otherwise, you will just have inaccurate results.

 

[noobinator]

This isn't easy to do through a picture of screens. It's pretty worthless.

 

[Coffee_Time]

This isn't easy to do through a picture of screens. It's pretty worthless.

I agree 100%!
But let's analize the picture.
I will try to have both phones on same screen. I'll update tomorrow...

 

[Coffee_Time]

Real photos...
Same white background. Displays outputs them diffrent... Both on full brightness, both with blue filter enabled in a way that best match the white background on those plastic stands. Photos done with mate 20 pro ...
Someone says why aren't displaying the same page ... but those backrounds apps like chrome and play store are pure white... I think the phone with play store would been better on whites if had the same google chrome white background...

Now, which white do you preffer?

 

[mollyc]

You aren't controlling for any variables here. You need to put the SAME screen on EACH phone at the SAME time. Then from photo to photo, show each with the same lighting.

You have different screens on different photos, the phones switched sides between photos, and different lighting in each photo.

To do any sort of comparison, only ONE thing should be different between the two items. In this case, the variable item is the phone itself. EVERYTHING else should be exactly the same.

 

[noobinator]

You aren't controlling for any variables here. You need to put the SAME screen on EACH phone at the SAME time. Then from photo to photo, show each with the same lighting.

You have different screens on different photos, the phones switched sides between photos, and different lighting in each photo.

To do any sort of comparison, only ONE thing should be different between the two items. In this case, the variable item is the phone itself. EVERYTHING else should be exactly the same.

Not to mention there's some serious glare going on here which can affect lighting very differently, even things that are inches apart.

 

[mollyc]

Not to mention there's some serious glare going on here which can affect lighting very differently, even things that are inches apart.

And also the giant light up 30 in the second photo.