Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

mikey8811

macrumors regular
Original poster
Mar 23, 2019
123
21
Hi

Just a cautionary warning for folk moving on from an old Mac using Snow Leopard or earlier to a new one on Mojave. The same may apply to later Mac OS too.

I did the above on a new iMac, 3 weeks ago via Migration Assistant. Everything occurred without much ado and was successful. The shared folder locations migrated too and I was able to access the data.

However, I then discovered that I could no longer edit the sharing permissions nor delete shared folders in the Sharing section of System Preferences. I posted about the issue here:

https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/unable-to-edit-or-remove-shared-folders-on-new-imac.2180484/

Calling Apple Care did not really do much - they were essentially clueless. I am in Asia and the service people are not technically competent. They have to pass the case on to their site engineers in a somewhat inefficient manner. You cannot deal directly with a site engineer and they take 2 days to respond to to the service staff at Apple Care handling the case. My suspicion is that the site engineers also do not know much and worse still do not understand basic English. After much to and fro for 3 weeks, they reverted to say it was an issue with the migration screwing up the Open Directory. They themselves did not know what to do and basically asked me to reset the iMac to factory settings and set it up again from scratch - not like that was something I could not think of doing myself. That was the shocking thing - they were unable to give a definitive answer or a solution. They were just suggesting I try things out just as you would do on your own. Why are we paying for support from people who have really no expertise to speak of?

The service attendant had extended my return period on the iMac and I will be returning it. I really do not think it is my job to help Apple troubleshoot their software bugs, especially not when i paid good money for a new computer - and from what I have seen too much at that.

I basically wasted 3 weeks setting up a computer and installing software. I hope Apple service is better elsewhere in the world because it really seems to me that they have no clue as to what they are doing. My prior experience with Apple support up till now has been different although the last time of my contact with them was a long while ago. It does seem that they make software with too many glitches now and the support people are not really up to scratch to help you fix the issues. The whole ease of Migration Assistant is hyped up on the Apple website but the truth of my experience could not be more different. The only thing I migrated was System & Network settings. I created everything else from scratch and am still facing issues.

It's a shame my new Mac experience ended up this way. I'll sit it out for a while and think about getting something else.

So whatever you do, please do NOT use migration assistant to migrate System and Network settings because Apple will not be able to help and you will end up with a Mac where you are unable to change or edit sharing folders for good.
 
Last edited:

mikehalloran

macrumors 68020
Oct 14, 2018
2,239
666
The Sillie Con Valley
Shame you waited eight operating systems to update.
Yea, that.
I really do not think it is my job to help Apple troubleshoot their software bugs, especially not when i paid good money for a new computer -
What bugs? You've given no info to support that.

You missed two important watersheds for the Mac OS. The first was OS 10.8.2; the other was 10.11. Way too many things were changed under the hood too many years ago.

If it was System Settings only, I don't see that there would have been much of a problem—if any. It's everything else, especially Application support files. Many are now inaccessible to you and need to be cleaned out by disabling SIP first. In addition, there are files and apps that will crash the Mac on a regular basis if not thoroughly cleaned out.

You could start from scratch and do a clean install but there's a problem with that. There are still applications that work over Mojave but the installers stopped working years ago. For example, the Office 2008 installer last worked over Yosemite but, thanks to Migration Assistant, I can use it on my iMac Pro.

I don't envy what you're going through at all.
 

mikey8811

macrumors regular
Original poster
Mar 23, 2019
123
21
Shame you waited eight operating systems to update.

No difference as it turns out. Read the lengthy posts on the Apple forums

https://discussions.apple.com/thread/8574987?answerId=250746908022#250746908022

Same issues with migration from much later OS'

What bugs? You've given no info to support that.

Apple's engineering team themselves admitted the bugs. As per their message:

"When you used the migration assistant to migrate the use, you have bought the old Open Directory to the new computer and it seems to have issues.

Removing / replacing the Open Directory is not recommended.

Erasing and reinstalling macOS clean, setting up all users manually and using Time Machine application (definitely not any assistants) to recover just the user data (nothing else) is the Site Support engineers recommendation."

In other words, Migration Assistant or any other assistant will not work! Their words not mine.

This is consistent with all the posts in the Apple forum I linked. Many were migrations from recent OS.

See Apple's own link on using Migration Assistant

https://support.apple.com/en-my/HT204350

with the emphasis

"Make sure that your old Mac is using OS X Snow Leopard v10.6.8 or later."

These are the steps I followed to the point. I even called up Apple support before doing it to have them walk me through the steps.

That they still did not bother to change the page or put a warning on it is pretty negligent and is false advertising.

If it was System Settings only, I don't see that there would have been much of a problem—if any.

It was systems and network settings only plus one standard user with read and write sharing permissions. That was literally all I migrated. No applications, nothing else. it was as close to a clean install as I could think of while preserving my sharing settings which were all i wanted to preserve.

If that isn't a bug i do not know what is

Packed up the 2019 iMac today. Can't say I am sorry to see it go, given the pain and hassle.

Rebooted the old MacBook running Snow Leopard - ran without a glitch. None of the USB drives unmounting by themselves shenanigans like the 2019 iMac. Most importantly, network file sharing works. Jeez, sometimes upgrading is overrated! Apple used to make gear that works ;)
 
Last edited:

mikehalloran

macrumors 68020
Oct 14, 2018
2,239
666
The Sillie Con Valley
Read the lengthy posts on the Apple forums
You were given good advice on that thread and by Apple Support but you state that you will return the computer instead.

Yet this rant continues.

"When you used the migration assistant to migrate the use, you have bought the old Open Directory to the new computer and it seems to have issues.
That isn't anyone admitting a bug. Sorry. It just isn't and no amount of insisting changes this.

You reject doing a clean install because you've "spent three weeks on this". A clean install won't take nearly that long and I know a few tricks to shorten the time.

Oh well.
 

mikey8811

macrumors regular
Original poster
Mar 23, 2019
123
21
You were given good advice on that thread and by Apple Support but you state that you will return the computer instead.

Yet this rant continues.

Of course I would opt to return the computer and get my cash back. Why wouldn't I when a brand new computer malfunctions when I have performed the installation as instructed by the manufacturer.

This ain't a rant. It is to caution folk against following the steps on Migration Assistant and doing a clean install instead as the title says, in spite of what Apple tells you on their website.

That isn't anyone admitting a bug. Sorry. It just isn't and no amount of insisting changes this.

Again, here we have to disagree. If it isn't a bug why would following the officially sanctioned steps lead to a malfunctioning that the Apple site engineers themselves cannot fix.

The users on the Apple forum have indeed good suggestions, primarily in 2019, do NOT use Mac OS as a file server.

I am not bothering with a clean install because I won't bother with buying a Mac again unless the issues I encountered get fixed.

FYI it was the Apple engineers and so called support who dragged out the debacle for 3 weeks expressedly so I would not return the computer until I insisted.

Your experience with Apple may be the bees knees but sad to say, it wasn't the case for me nor others on the Apple forum who used Mojave as a file server. I am just letting people know so they can avoid what I went through. They can decide for themselves.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Fishrrman

macrumors Penryn
Feb 20, 2009
29,289
13,396
mikey wrote:
"I am not bothering with a clean install because I won't bother with buying a Mac again unless the issues I encountered get fixed."

Fearless prediction:
They're not going to "get fixed" for a version of the OS "that far back".

Enjoy your new Windows machine ;)
 

mikey8811

macrumors regular
Original poster
Mar 23, 2019
123
21
Enjoy your new Windows machine ;)

Thanks, will do. Just ordered a Dell today.

If you have read the Apple thread, it affects all recent Mac OS too not just mine which admittedly goes far back.

Most folk there who do any kind of serious file sharing are switching to Windows.
 

retta283

Suspended
Jun 8, 2018
3,180
3,482
Coming from Snow Leopard I can imagine Mojave is quite the disappointment if you're a desktop user. I've been using a Windows computer for a little bit as a secondary machine, and it's not been too bad.
 

fisherking

macrumors G4
Jul 16, 2010
11,257
5,568
ny somewhere
Coming from Snow Leopard I can imagine Mojave is quite the disappointment if you're a desktop user. I've been using a Windows computer for a little bit as a secondary machine, and it's not been too bad.

why would that be? SL was a great moment in mac os history, but mojave, and it's parity with the era we now live in, is pretty great; am not (personally) having any issues, and my apps, and my macs in general, are running fast, and stable.

isn't that the point? i mean... why do people romanticize the past? is it just fear of moving forward? (am asking, seriously, as i don't get it).
 

retta283

Suspended
Jun 8, 2018
3,180
3,482
why would that be? SL was a great moment in mac os history, but mojave, and it's parity with the era we now live in, is pretty great; am not (personally) having any issues, and my apps, and my macs in general, are running fast, and stable.

isn't that the point? i mean... why do people romanticize the past? is it just fear of moving forward? (am asking, seriously, as i don't get it).
Loss of iSync, heavy tweaking to Disk Utility and AirPort Utility, changes to finder functions, spotlight became slower, changes to group management, loss of Front Row and QuickTime 7, not compatible with iPhoto or Aperture, some window peeking features have gotten worse, and finally, the complete destruction of Mac OS X Server. The current server app is a complete joke. No real server features. I'm sure I missed some.

I still think macOS is the best OS (I hate Apple's current laptops though and won't buy them until the keyboard/throttling is fixed) but it has fallen from its peak with SL.
 

fisherking

macrumors G4
Jul 16, 2010
11,257
5,568
ny somewhere
Loss of iSync, heavy tweaking to Disk Utility and AirPort Utility, changes to finder functions, spotlight became slower, changes to group management, loss of Front Row and QuickTime 7, not compatible with iPhoto or Aperture, some window peeking features have gotten worse, and finally, the complete destruction of Mac OS X Server. The current server app is a complete joke. No real server features. I'm sure I missed some.

I still think macOS is the best OS (I hate Apple's current laptops though and won't buy them until the keyboard/throttling is fixed) but it has fallen from its peak with SL.

some of us find these things improved; photos over iphoto, new finder options. QT7 still works (i've used it since the 1800s).. but won't with the next OS.

SL was great... in it's day. i would never want to go back tho.
 

mikey8811

macrumors regular
Original poster
Mar 23, 2019
123
21
Loss of iSync, heavy tweaking to Disk Utility and AirPort Utility, changes to finder functions, spotlight became slower, changes to group management, loss of Front Row and QuickTime 7, not compatible with iPhoto or Aperture, some window peeking features have gotten worse, and finally, the complete destruction of Mac OS X Server. The current server app is a complete joke. No real server features. I'm sure I missed some.

You've hit the nail right on the head. For me the immediate issues are the screwing up of Mac OS X Server for anyone running Mac OS as a file server. Really, it is a joke that it is easier to share Windows files with a Mac rather than Mac files with another Mac!

Then the USB 3.1 implementation. External HDD's unmount themselves for no apparent reason. They disappear from Finder but still appear mounted in Disk Utility. You cannot unmount them from Disk Utility or using the diskutil command in Terminal.

A much slower Spotlight and changes to Finder functions come next. Case in point - my old MacBook is a Core 2 Duo machine with 2 Gb of RAM running Snow Leopard. Spotlight indexing of the same external drives (some 8 Tb) was a walk in the park compared to the 2019 iMac with a much faster processor, more RAM and Mojave where it literally took a couple of days to a week.

To be fair what I liked about Mojave were the "hand off" functions with other Apple devices - specifically iCloud syncing of Notes, being able to accept calls on the iMac, etc. But overall, these are superficial attributes - slickness if you will vs the basic functions outlined above that are more important as far as my usage goes. The 5K Retina screen is also nice in spite of the outdated thick bezels.

Sure, also the iMac starts up faster on SSD but you are paying through your nose for that. I still got the coloured spinning wheel as far as accessing data from external HDD's go. I know some of you will say that won't happen with external SSD's but then most of us do not have unlimited resources. Even those with fatter pockets are seeing the drawbacks of the current Mac's, see the link to the following post by someone with a spec'ed out iMac Pro

https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/imac-pro-mini-solution-for-constant-crashes.2183063/

In contrast, a Windows machine may not be as slick and nice to use but the basic functions do work. If not, it is really easy to troubleshoot online. Much easier than relying on Apple Care support and engineering who from experience are not much help at all. Also, budget wise, Windows machines are much more affordable - the base Dell equivalent is spec'ed with a 512 Gb SSD plus an internal 2 Tb SATA HDD with 16 Gb of RAM, something you would cough out blood for Mac wise. Definitely in my case, the value proposition of an iMac running Mojave is a lot less compelling, especially since it doesn't really work well for my needs!
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: retta283

codernova

macrumors member
May 13, 2019
93
32
Enjoy your new issues in Windows 10. Been using Windows since 3.0 (every version), it has its benefits but it isn't greener grass.

I have Windows, Mac, and Linux machines. Don't expect any of them to be perfect.
 

mikey8811

macrumors regular
Original poster
Mar 23, 2019
123
21
i mean... why do people romanticize the past? is it just fear of moving forward? (am asking, seriously, as i don't get it).

Not romanticising, it's just the tasks I use the Mac for seem to work without a glitch on Snow Leopard and supposedly outdated hardware but not so well on Mojave on a much better spec'ed computer - go figure

Enjoy your new issues in Windows 10. Been using Windows since 3.0 (every version), it has its benefits but it isn't greener grass.

I have Windows, Mac, and Linux machines. Don't expect any of them to be perfect.

No, I don't expect them to be perfect but one would at least expect them to work. The above tasks I mentioned are pretty basic and work on Windows 10 without a glitch. Windows just ain't as slick but then everyone knows that - that's the Mac selling point.
 
Last edited:

fisherking

macrumors G4
Jul 16, 2010
11,257
5,568
ny somewhere
Not romanticising, it's just the tasks I use the Mac for seem to work without a glitch on Snow Leopard and supposedly outdated hardware but not so well on Mojave on a much better spec'ed computer - go figure



No, I don't expect them to be perfect but one would at least expect them to work. The above tasks I mentioned are pretty basic and work on Windows 10 without a glitch. Windows just ain't as slick but then everyone knows that - that's the Mac selling point.

humble reminder; your experience speaks for you, not for everyone. why do people think that the problems they have are always everyone's?
 

mikey8811

macrumors regular
Original poster
Mar 23, 2019
123
21
humble reminder; your experience speaks for you, not for everyone. why do people think that the problems they have are always everyone's?

No, I do not presume to speak for others. No more than any of the folk such as yourself who post here do.

I am only relating my personal experience so that others who are in similar circumstances can avoid the same pitfalls. I have learned much from these boards - including what to avoid, from the experience of others here.

I do apologise if that irks you.
 

fisherking

macrumors G4
Jul 16, 2010
11,257
5,568
ny somewhere
No, I do not presume to speak for others. No more than any of the folk such as yourself who post here do.

I am only relating my personal experience so that others who are in similar circumstances can avoid the same pitfalls. I have learned much from these boards - including what to avoid, from the experience of others here.

I do apologise if that irks you.

no, it's fine, but good you're admitting that your experiences are your own, and not everyone's. too many people on this forum think they speak for all (i have done that myself, to be honest). but i've never posted a thread title that proclaims "the current mac OS breaks this, or ruins that, or shouldn't be installed".

at it's best, this forum is a great place to discuss, and get help. at it's worst, there's a lot of whining, and explaining in absolute terms things that are not, in fact, absolute.
 
  • Like
Reactions: astrorider
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.