Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

KLWN

macrumors member
Original poster
Apr 1, 2015
32
0
Hi guys,

im currently looking for new RAM for my Mac Pro 5.1 (Six Core). I found this RAM modules but im not sure if they work with my Mac.


What do you guys think?


best regards,
Alex
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
Had memory related issues with 5,1's and 3x8GB sticks in the past on client's workstations. The machines performed more reliably with 2x8GB sticks or 4x8GB sticks. Ended up taking one stick out one machine, added it to the other and there were less memory-related crash issues when rendering video. None were showing as bad sticks, but sometimes they do not...

This absolutely could have been an isolated incident, but when upgrading or configuring, it's just a recommendation. 3x16GB on a 3.33 works great.
 
^^^^Hard to believe that a 5,1 would work better with four sticks than three? The fourth slot is electrically tied to the third slot. If the third memory slot is left MT, a stick in the 4th slot will not be recognized.

From personal experience, I have a dual CPU 5,1 with 6 of the eight slots populated and no RAM issues with quality DMS RAM.

Lou
 
^^^^Hard to believe that a 5,1 would work better with four sticks than three? The fourth slot is electrically tied to the third slot. If the third memory slot is left MT, a stick in the 4th slot will not be recognized.

From personal experience, I have a dual CPU 5,1 with 6 of the eight slots populated and no RAM issues with quality DMS RAM.

Lou

I'm with Lou on that one. Prior to the CPU upgrade I had all 8 slots loaded. Post CPU upgrade I picked up 3 8GB's from DMS to do the triple channel thing. In benchmarking my renders between the two flavors of ram, I see a 13% decrease in render times, and nearly a 18% decrease in bake times by going to triple channel RAM. The cost delta is marginal.
 
^^^^You can, it will fit and work just fine. But you will not see the RAM speed of the nMP (1866MHz).

Lou
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.