Regular iPod interface on iPhone: Would anybody use it?

[mrat93]

Okay, I am NOT a programmer, developer or anything of the sort. I just made these mockups in MS paint out of sheer boredom to see how the regular iPod interface would look on iPhone/iPod Touch. What do you think (not on quality, just the concept.)? Do you think anybody would use it if Apple created this option?

 

[72930]

Concepts before the iPhone announcements were similar to this, they look nowhere near as good as the real UI. Apparently Apple tried a virtual click-wheel during development.

 

[Michael CM1]

As someone who still owns one of those 5G iPods, NOOOOO!!! After testing out just the flicking down a list of all the songs on the iPhone, I can't imagine wanting that interface option. I equate it to the evils of the Classic environment I have to put up with at work because we're too cheap to upgrade a couple of apps to OS X. Remember the days before scroll wheels?

 

[The Menacer]

I'd TOTALLY use the a virtual clickwheel. Sometimes the touch interface just seems cumbersome and bulky.