Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Stanjensen

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Aug 25, 2009
15
0
As I travel in Canada and the US I have a phone with Rogers and one with ATT.

My Rogers speed is way faster than ATT.

Rogers is 3.1 mg and ATT is almost 10% of that.

Is this normal?
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0635.jpg
    IMG_0635.jpg
    34.7 KB · Views: 115
I am such a iPhone fan, Mac is the closest thing to a Cult that I support..

HOWEVER I do have to keep a verizon phone for a back up for my ATT, as there are times I have to be available... how sad is that?

ALSO for only $20 per month, there is no roaming anywhere in Canada or the US. If only ATT or Rogers could do that.
 
I admit 3.1 Mbps is impressive, I often see speeds here in FL in the 2.2 range, as high as 2.33, obviously not as good as Rogers, but not so bad really, plus if I'm not mistaken, isn't Rogers using the upgraded 7.2 network, while AT&T is not quite there?
 
I usually get around 1.5Mbs which is good enough for what I do. BTW your upload speed seems really slow. mine is almost always at least 400Kbs or more on 3g
 
11911780.png
490519532.png


I'm okay with my speed on AT&T. They are definitely inconsistent though, from one place to another.

I do consistently get faster speeds on my Aircard with my MacBook pro than I do on my iPhone though, so there is definitely something different about the iPhone hardware.
 
This is from the Swiss Chalet in Niagara Falls (Canadian side) on Rogers, got bored waiting for my food. I saved it cause it was the fastest I've seen. Home in NB I usually get around 2.9-3.1 constant.
 

Attachments

  • 23388099.jpg
    23388099.jpg
    56.2 KB · Views: 72
Didn't Rogers implement the 7.2Mbps HSDPA so you Canadians should be seeing much better speeds than the Death Star.

Canadian cellco Rogers has announced that it has completed the national rollout of its 3.5G HSDPA mobile network, which now covers around 75% of the population including the country's 25 largest markets, and provides maximum (theoretical) download speeds of 7.2Mbps for handset and computer users. According to TeleGeography’s GlobalComms database, Rogers launched commercial HSDPA services with maximum download speeds of 3.6Mbps in November 2006, and by December 2007 the 3.5G network covered a total of 28 cities and approximately 60% of the population.
 
I used to view Rogers as the worst phone company, they have really gone out of their way to please the iPhone users...
 
Where the speed worked nice was at a Church Camp that did not have internet access. I tethered to my MB Air, and sent the signal out via the airport, and several were able to get their email etc..

Sending data was a problem, but they were all aware only to send text. I have not come close to the 6 gigs allowed..

Rogers also let me upgrade to the GS after only being on one year.

I used to detest Rogers.
 
My parents live in Montreal so I got a Rogers PAYG sim card for when I visit. Unfortunately there's no plan that allows data, I wish it did because I'd like to compare the speed to AT&T in (notoriously slow) NYC. At least I had free wifi at Second Cup ala Starbucks, and actually saw the MMS button. :p
 
$199.00 Canadian with a $50 rebate from apple. (But have not seen that promised form yet)

PLUS my contract was extended another year, so now it is back to two years left on it.
 
$199.00 Canadian with a $50 rebate from apple. (But have not seen that promised form yet)

PLUS my contract was extended another year, so now it is back to two years left on it.

You only had to pay $199 and the add the year you've already used up? Man, that's a pretty great deal.

I assume you sold your 3G and made up the difference?
 
I admit 3.1 Mbps is impressive, I often see speeds here in FL in the 2.2 range, as high as 2.33, obviously not as good as Rogers, but not so bad really, plus if I'm not mistaken, isn't Rogers using the upgraded 7.2 network, while AT&T is not quite there?

Yes, roger had upgraded to 7.2 network a year ago.
 
You only had to pay $199 and the add the year you've already used up? Man, that's a pretty great deal.

I assume you sold your 3G and made up the difference?


Have not sold my White 16 gig G3 iPhone, but am open to offers.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.