Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

RSB96

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jan 23, 2021
422
1,914
Spain
As an iPad user since the first generation and an iPadPro user since 2017 as a laptop, I want to discuss my impressions after a week of use with the Samsung Galaxy Tab S9+.

Design.

We have a fairly landscape design with a 16:10 format, with 12.4" AMOLED with a resolution of 1752 x 2800 pixels and 120hz. The frames are quite reduced, similar to what we see in other competing tablets.

VzIOnpY.jpeg

YQWld2e.jpeg

jHF5bnJ.jpeg

ufE6DjM.jpeg


The device is very thin, 5.7mm, and is light, 586gr, so using it in the hand is much more comfortable despite the size of the screen. Compared to my 12.9" iPad Pro, the Samsung is much more comfortable to use in the hand, it is lighter and thinner, although it does not feel fragile, as some iPads do.

fmBoq2T.jpeg

D2XwSyr.jpeg


It feels solid and robust, which surprised me positively. The feel of the buttons is quite solid.

On the sides we have 4 AKG speakers, the USB-C, the microphones and the 3-pin keyboard connector, similar to the iPad. On the back we have two cameras and a flash and a hole for the Spen, where it charges. The Spen can also be placed horizontally on the right side, it is magnetically attached, although it does not charge, but it is more handy when used with a keyboard.

Overall it is a tablet with a very good build quality, according to its price. It is very light and thin, making it much more comfortable to hold in the hand than other alternatives. However, perhaps out of habit, I find the iPad's squarer proportion more comfortable for productivity, although for consuming content the Samsung's screen is better.

The screen has good definition and resolution, with fairly vivid and contrasting colors, without becoming overly saturated. Brightness is good and glare is not excessive. The miniLED screen of the iPad Pro is perhaps a little better in terms of color calibration and reflections, but the Samsung, being AMOLED has better blacks and contrast.

The AKG sound is good, it has equalizer and different sound modes to adapt it to your taste. However, I consider the iPad's audio to be more loud and enveloping.

Software.

The tablet has OneUI 6.0 and Android 14, at the time of writing this still did not have the update to OneUI 6.1 with Galaxy AI features.

I've been using a Google Pixel 8 Pro as a second phone for a while, whose PixelOS layer I find very nice and aesthetic and the truth is that when you first set up a Samsung product you are overwhelmed by the amount of options, settings and customization.

It has a normal mode and a Dex mode, which makes the tablet practically a computer apparently. It has a multi-window mode that allows up to three simultaneous apps, it has gestures to switch apps quickly, the dock can be hidden or not, and with the Dex mode, you can have multiple windows. Undoubtedly, in this sense, the Samsung is a step above the iPad and iPadOS, since the Stage Manager is very complex to use on the device itself, being more usable when you answer the iPad to a monitor and SplitView and SlideOver options, being very good, are clearly more limited than on the Samsung.

rGq9AAA.jpeg

xjti6fO.jpeg

RV581iV.jpeg

6mmwaEl.jpeg


When it comes to the quality of apps, iPadOS is ahead. This is something that is already noticeable on mobiles, but on tablets it is more evident. In the end all apps are scaled from the phone and even Twitter (X), on the iPadOS is adapted to the larger interface of the device, while on Android, it is the same as on the phone, but larger.

On the Galaxy Tab S9+ it comes with different apps like Lumafusion, Good Notes and Clip Studio, good apps for video editing, note taking and drawing. However, Procreate or Pixelmator Photo on the iPad are far superior apps to Lightroom (which needs subscription instead of one-time payment like Pixelmator) or Clip Studio. .

Regarding the Spen, it comes with the tablet (not the charger), is small and light, has a customizable button and for writing I like it better than Apple's Apple Pencil. However, for drawing, the Apple Pencil is better than the Spen, thanks to the pencil itself that allows you to tilt it to make shadows, for example, and the quality of the Procreate app, which is excellent.

dDJfFGz.jpeg


The Spen is loaded at the back and can be fixed at the top right when in landscape mode.

The tablet has a fairly fast fingerprint sensor and facial recognition as well.

I like Samsung's security suite, Knox, having many features that Apple incorporates, which I think is very positive for the consumer.

The autonomy of the tablet is correct, around 8-10 hours. With the 45W charger it charges in just over an hour, much faster than the 12.9" iPad Pro which with the 35W charger takes almost two hours to charge.

I also bought the keyboard (without trackpad) for it which looks like the iPad Pro's Smart Keyboard Folio. The feel of the case is similar, silicone type, but the keyboard has traditional keys and does not have the keyboard "built in" to the case, so the feel of the keys is better on the Samsung. However, when you close the tablet, it is not completely "glued" and moves a little. The case has an opening at the top to store the Spen without having to remove the case. It doesn't make it much heavier or fatter, making it quite comfortable to travel with. Like the Apple cases, they stain fairly easily.

It only has a 60° position unlike the full keyboard case which has a Surface style stand or the iPad Smart Keyboard Folio which has two positions.

Hardware.

It has the Qualcomm Snapdragon 8 Gen 2, 12GB of RAM and 512GB in this case, expandable by microSD up to 1TB.

It has enough power to do anything, although it is true that the iPad Pro with the M2 or even the Air with the M1 is better, since they have "computer" processors. The problem with the iPad is that this power is not accompanied by a software that makes the most of it, something that Android allows, especially in relation to everything related to multitasking, background tasks, etc..

You won't have any complaints in this regard and everything you do will be done very quickly, even complex tasks that use AI.

Conclusions.

After a week of using it as my main tablet, I honestly like it a lot. It has much better stuff than the iPad and the iPad has better stuff than the Galaxy.

In terms of apps, for me the iPad has the upper hand, it has many dedicated apps for the iPad, especially for illustration (Procreate) and photo and video editing (Pixelmator Photo, Logic Pro). Then more common apps, such as X/Twitter are better optimized for the device's larger screen size.

As for multitasking, OneUI is way ahead of Apple, both in the "normal" version and in the Dex version. For my taste, SplitView and SlideOver are quite intuitive and easy to use, but Samsung's multiview is far superior, much more customizable and the gestures, once you get the hang of it, work very well.

The Office suite on both is similar. Aesthetically somewhat more neat on iPadOS, but the functionalities are exactly the same, so in the end we have a limited Office suite.

The fact that it is light and comfortable to hold in the hand and the fact that it is well built and feels solid in the hand makes it comfortable to use in touch mode, more so than the 12.9" iPad Pro.

As for the screen format if it's true that I like Apple's square format better, especially when you're using it for productivity. For viewing content, the Samsung is better.

Finally there is the price.

Currently the version I have, the 5G, 512GB and 12GB of RAM, plus the keyboard costs 1300€.

If we compare it to the iPad Pro 12.9 5G 512GB with Apple Pencil and Smart Keyboard Folio (not the Magic Keyboard, which is even more expensive) it costs 2427€.

Is it worth the difference? If for you the ecosystem and the specific applications are paramount, surely yes, but objectively the difference, for a basic office use (internet, documents, video, social networks), is not worth it. The Samsung device is excellent, has a good screen, good audio, a fairly powerful security suite, and excellent performance.
 

weeesss

macrumors 6502
Oct 24, 2017
349
187
I just replaced an S8 with the S9 plus. The 8 was my son’s and I acquired it from him once he got an IPP. I myself have an M2 11” IPP and truly prefer the iOS ecosystem having all Apple hardware, but I have to say the screen on the 9+ is truly amazing, the sound is great and the machine is very fast. An impressive machine for less than a 9th gen iPad after trade-in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: phobic99 and RSB96

vine-boating

macrumors 68020
Aug 10, 2017
2,229
572
Bump
I am thinking of getting the S9 plus. I need a tablet for my law studies and just watching movies.
I was going to get an ipad but I can get a lot of discount with the Samsung which means it will be much cheaper.

A couple of months on, how are you finding it? One of thr major benefits of the ipad is the note taking apps that are available on ios with notability and Good notes. I know good notes is now on android, but I've heard its not as good as on ios.
 

jimimac71

Cancelled
Sep 21, 2019
642
314
Very well done. Guess writing reviews is nothing new.
I have 2 Samsung tablets. Both are long in the tooth, even the one from 2021.
My Galaxy Tab A from 2019 is my favorite even though it is on Android 11.
With only 3 GB RAM it is better that way.
My Galaxy Tab A7 lite is from 2021 and already out of date.
I'm afraid to convert the cost to US dollars for the Tab S9+.
If I have to ask, I can't afford it.
What I really want are desktop/laptop style browsers.
Guess that points me in the direction of Chromebook.
Nice to see if you spend enough money for either Apple or Samsung you get a flash on the back camera.
I know a slate is huge as a camera, and bulky, but I am one without a smart phone.
It looks like a Mail app I've never seen on both tablets.
Please do tell what it is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RSB96

RSB96

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jan 23, 2021
422
1,914
Spain
Very well done. Guess writing reviews is nothing new.
I have 2 Samsung tablets. Both are long in the tooth, even the one from 2021.
My Galaxy Tab A from 2019 is my favorite even though it is on Android 11.
With only 3 GB RAM it is better that way.
My Galaxy Tab A7 lite is from 2021 and already out of date.
I'm afraid to convert the cost to US dollars for the Tab S9+.
If I have to ask, I can't afford it.
What I really want are desktop/laptop style browsers.
Guess that points me in the direction of Chromebook.
Nice to see if you spend enough money for either Apple or Samsung you get a flash on the back camera.
I know a slate is huge as a camera, and bulky, but I am one without a smart phone.
It looks like a Mail app I've never seen on both tablets.
Please do tell what it is.

On the iPad I use the native Mail app and on the Samsung I use the Outlook app (which is my primary mail). The cameras are normal. One of the things that bothered me the most on the iPad Air is the lack of flash, while the iPad mini has it.

Bump
I am thinking of getting the S9 plus. I need a tablet for my law studies and just watching movies.
I was going to get an ipad but I can get a lot of discount with the Samsung which means it will be much cheaper.

A couple of months on, how are you finding it? One of thr major benefits of the ipad is the note taking apps that are available on ios with notability and Good notes. I know good notes is now on android, but I've heard its not as good as on ios.

If you want the best apps for class, the iPad is still much better. I still think the consistency and homogeneity of the system on iOS/iPadOS is far superior.

I've been using the Google Photos app on the Samsung today and horizontally it doesn't rotate, which I think is a pretty big mistake.

Apart from those details, the tablet works very well and the new AI features are very interesting, allowing you to summarize web pages, the notes app is very advanced and has many useful features... it can be very interesting for class as well.

I'm mainly using the iPad Pro and I still like it better because I'm more used to it, but the Samsung is a very good device.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DeepIn2U and DaPhox

jimimac71

Cancelled
Sep 21, 2019
642
314
The mail app I'm looking at is all the way to the right on the iPad, right of the X app.
Android has more apps that don't rotate.
It also gives me more issues with an app not being compatible with my device.
My banking app is not compatible with any of my Android tablets.
It is funky like an iPhone app on my iPad, but works.
The keyboard is an iPhone keyboard.
If I were going to go all tablet, I need a way to import/export bookmarks.
Only DuckDuckGo does that but is still in Beta and pretty lackluster.
My iPad is mostly a better device. It is the 7th Gen. (2019) and I got it refurbished.
It is 32 GB and I've had to remove many apps to keep it going.
Running 17.5.2 Public Beta. Has never slowed down.
Rumors are I will not have access to iPad OS 18.
There might be a legitimate reason, or Tim needs a new yacht.
Apple is better at support on low end tablets.
I'm cheap because I have to be.
My iPad is the last one to offer 32 GB.
Five years later, they should not be offering 64 GB.
 

RSB96

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jan 23, 2021
422
1,914
Spain
Ah, that's Telegram, the messaging app I use the most, since I hate WhatsApp (in Europe iMessage has hardly any presence).

Yes, my bank's app is not available on the Samsung tablet either, although on the iPad I prefer to enter from the browser for convenience, like instagram, for example.

I suppose it's possible that all the AI features that iOS 18 is going to implement will be the biggest barrier to those iPads, especially since it's rumored that much of it will run on the device itself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DeepIn2U

vine-boating

macrumors 68020
Aug 10, 2017
2,229
572
On the iPad I use the native Mail app and on the Samsung I use the Outlook app (which is my primary mail). The cameras are normal. One of the things that bothered me the most on the iPad Air is the lack of flash, while the iPad mini has it.



If you want the best apps for class, the iPad is still much better. I still think the consistency and homogeneity of the system on iOS/iPadOS is far superior.

I've been using the Google Photos app on the Samsung today and horizontally it doesn't rotate, which I think is a pretty big mistake.

Apart from those details, the tablet works very well and the new AI features are very interesting, allowing you to summarize web pages, the notes app is very advanced and has many useful features... it can be very interesting for class as well.

I'm mainly using the iPad Pro and I still like it better because I'm more used to it, but the Samsung is a very good device.
Do you use a screen protector or case with your Galaxy tab?
 

Carrotstick

Suspended
Mar 25, 2024
230
418
As an iPad user since the first generation and an iPadPro user since 2017 as a laptop, I want to discuss my impressions after a week of use with the Samsung Galaxy Tab S9+.

Design.

We have a fairly landscape design with a 16:10 format, with 12.4" AMOLED with a resolution of 1752 x 2800 pixels and 120hz. The frames are quite reduced, similar to what we see in other competing tablets.

VzIOnpY.jpeg

YQWld2e.jpeg

jHF5bnJ.jpeg

ufE6DjM.jpeg


The device is very thin, 5.7mm, and is light, 586gr, so using it in the hand is much more comfortable despite the size of the screen. Compared to my 12.9" iPad Pro, the Samsung is much more comfortable to use in the hand, it is lighter and thinner, although it does not feel fragile, as some iPads do.

fmBoq2T.jpeg

D2XwSyr.jpeg


It feels solid and robust, which surprised me positively. The feel of the buttons is quite solid.

On the sides we have 4 AKG speakers, the USB-C, the microphones and the 3-pin keyboard connector, similar to the iPad. On the back we have two cameras and a flash and a hole for the Spen, where it charges. The Spen can also be placed horizontally on the right side, it is magnetically attached, although it does not charge, but it is more handy when used with a keyboard.

Overall it is a tablet with a very good build quality, according to its price. It is very light and thin, making it much more comfortable to hold in the hand than other alternatives. However, perhaps out of habit, I find the iPad's squarer proportion more comfortable for productivity, although for consuming content the Samsung's screen is better.

The screen has good definition and resolution, with fairly vivid and contrasting colors, without becoming overly saturated. Brightness is good and glare is not excessive. The miniLED screen of the iPad Pro is perhaps a little better in terms of color calibration and reflections, but the Samsung, being AMOLED has better blacks and contrast.

The AKG sound is good, it has equalizer and different sound modes to adapt it to your taste. However, I consider the iPad's audio to be more loud and enveloping.

Software.

The tablet has OneUI 6.0 and Android 14, at the time of writing this still did not have the update to OneUI 6.1 with Galaxy AI features.

I've been using a Google Pixel 8 Pro as a second phone for a while, whose PixelOS layer I find very nice and aesthetic and the truth is that when you first set up a Samsung product you are overwhelmed by the amount of options, settings and customization.

It has a normal mode and a Dex mode, which makes the tablet practically a computer apparently. It has a multi-window mode that allows up to three simultaneous apps, it has gestures to switch apps quickly, the dock can be hidden or not, and with the Dex mode, you can have multiple windows. Undoubtedly, in this sense, the Samsung is a step above the iPad and iPadOS, since the Stage Manager is very complex to use on the device itself, being more usable when you answer the iPad to a monitor and SplitView and SlideOver options, being very good, are clearly more limited than on the Samsung.

rGq9AAA.jpeg

xjti6fO.jpeg

RV581iV.jpeg

6mmwaEl.jpeg


When it comes to the quality of apps, iPadOS is ahead. This is something that is already noticeable on mobiles, but on tablets it is more evident. In the end all apps are scaled from the phone and even Twitter (X), on the iPadOS is adapted to the larger interface of the device, while on Android, it is the same as on the phone, but larger.

On the Galaxy Tab S9+ it comes with different apps like Lumafusion, Good Notes and Clip Studio, good apps for video editing, note taking and drawing. However, Procreate or Pixelmator Photo on the iPad are far superior apps to Lightroom (which needs subscription instead of one-time payment like Pixelmator) or Clip Studio. .

Regarding the Spen, it comes with the tablet (not the charger), is small and light, has a customizable button and for writing I like it better than Apple's Apple Pencil. However, for drawing, the Apple Pencil is better than the Spen, thanks to the pencil itself that allows you to tilt it to make shadows, for example, and the quality of the Procreate app, which is excellent.

dDJfFGz.jpeg


The Spen is loaded at the back and can be fixed at the top right when in landscape mode.

The tablet has a fairly fast fingerprint sensor and facial recognition as well.

I like Samsung's security suite, Knox, having many features that Apple incorporates, which I think is very positive for the consumer.

The autonomy of the tablet is correct, around 8-10 hours. With the 45W charger it charges in just over an hour, much faster than the 12.9" iPad Pro which with the 35W charger takes almost two hours to charge.

I also bought the keyboard (without trackpad) for it which looks like the iPad Pro's Smart Keyboard Folio. The feel of the case is similar, silicone type, but the keyboard has traditional keys and does not have the keyboard "built in" to the case, so the feel of the keys is better on the Samsung. However, when you close the tablet, it is not completely "glued" and moves a little. The case has an opening at the top to store the Spen without having to remove the case. It doesn't make it much heavier or fatter, making it quite comfortable to travel with. Like the Apple cases, they stain fairly easily.

It only has a 60° position unlike the full keyboard case which has a Surface style stand or the iPad Smart Keyboard Folio which has two positions.

Hardware.

It has the Qualcomm Snapdragon 8 Gen 2, 12GB of RAM and 512GB in this case, expandable by microSD up to 1TB.

It has enough power to do anything, although it is true that the iPad Pro with the M2 or even the Air with the M1 is better, since they have "computer" processors. The problem with the iPad is that this power is not accompanied by a software that makes the most of it, something that Android allows, especially in relation to everything related to multitasking, background tasks, etc..

You won't have any complaints in this regard and everything you do will be done very quickly, even complex tasks that use AI.

Conclusions.

After a week of using it as my main tablet, I honestly like it a lot. It has much better stuff than the iPad and the iPad has better stuff than the Galaxy.

In terms of apps, for me the iPad has the upper hand, it has many dedicated apps for the iPad, especially for illustration (Procreate) and photo and video editing (Pixelmator Photo, Logic Pro). Then more common apps, such as X/Twitter are better optimized for the device's larger screen size.

As for multitasking, OneUI is way ahead of Apple, both in the "normal" version and in the Dex version. For my taste, SplitView and SlideOver are quite intuitive and easy to use, but Samsung's multiview is far superior, much more customizable and the gestures, once you get the hang of it, work very well.

The Office suite on both is similar. Aesthetically somewhat more neat on iPadOS, but the functionalities are exactly the same, so in the end we have a limited Office suite.

The fact that it is light and comfortable to hold in the hand and the fact that it is well built and feels solid in the hand makes it comfortable to use in touch mode, more so than the 12.9" iPad Pro.

As for the screen format if it's true that I like Apple's square format better, especially when you're using it for productivity. For viewing content, the Samsung is better.

Finally there is the price.

Currently the version I have, the 5G, 512GB and 12GB of RAM, plus the keyboard costs 1300€.

If we compare it to the iPad Pro 12.9 5G 512GB with Apple Pencil and Smart Keyboard Folio (not the Magic Keyboard, which is even more expensive) it costs 2427€.

Is it worth the difference? If for you the ecosystem and the specific applications are paramount, surely yes, but objectively the difference, for a basic office use (internet, documents, video, social networks), is not worth it. The Samsung device is excellent, has a good screen, good audio, a fairly powerful security suite, and excellent performance.
It would be interesting to the see the iPad Pros 2024 upgrades. The 2022 iPad Pros didn’t bring anything majorly new.
 

RSB96

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jan 23, 2021
422
1,914
Spain
Do you use a screen protector or case with your Galaxy tab?
I don't use screen protectors, neither on the iPad nor on the Samsung.

I bought the official Samsung case, with the keyboard, but without trackpad. It is a very similar material to that of the iPad, perhaps a bit dirtier still. It has a hole in the back to store the pencil, so it's not bad.
 

Sensamic

macrumors 68040
Mar 26, 2010
3,072
689
As an iPad user since the first generation and an iPadPro user since 2017 as a laptop, I want to discuss my impressions after a week of use with the Samsung Galaxy Tab S9+.

Design.

We have a fairly landscape design with a 16:10 format, with 12.4" AMOLED with a resolution of 1752 x 2800 pixels and 120hz. The frames are quite reduced, similar to what we see in other competing tablets.

VzIOnpY.jpeg

YQWld2e.jpeg

jHF5bnJ.jpeg

ufE6DjM.jpeg


The device is very thin, 5.7mm, and is light, 586gr, so using it in the hand is much more comfortable despite the size of the screen. Compared to my 12.9" iPad Pro, the Samsung is much more comfortable to use in the hand, it is lighter and thinner, although it does not feel fragile, as some iPads do.

fmBoq2T.jpeg

D2XwSyr.jpeg


It feels solid and robust, which surprised me positively. The feel of the buttons is quite solid.

On the sides we have 4 AKG speakers, the USB-C, the microphones and the 3-pin keyboard connector, similar to the iPad. On the back we have two cameras and a flash and a hole for the Spen, where it charges. The Spen can also be placed horizontally on the right side, it is magnetically attached, although it does not charge, but it is more handy when used with a keyboard.

Overall it is a tablet with a very good build quality, according to its price. It is very light and thin, making it much more comfortable to hold in the hand than other alternatives. However, perhaps out of habit, I find the iPad's squarer proportion more comfortable for productivity, although for consuming content the Samsung's screen is better.

The screen has good definition and resolution, with fairly vivid and contrasting colors, without becoming overly saturated. Brightness is good and glare is not excessive. The miniLED screen of the iPad Pro is perhaps a little better in terms of color calibration and reflections, but the Samsung, being AMOLED has better blacks and contrast.

The AKG sound is good, it has equalizer and different sound modes to adapt it to your taste. However, I consider the iPad's audio to be more loud and enveloping.

Software.

The tablet has OneUI 6.0 and Android 14, at the time of writing this still did not have the update to OneUI 6.1 with Galaxy AI features.

I've been using a Google Pixel 8 Pro as a second phone for a while, whose PixelOS layer I find very nice and aesthetic and the truth is that when you first set up a Samsung product you are overwhelmed by the amount of options, settings and customization.

It has a normal mode and a Dex mode, which makes the tablet practically a computer apparently. It has a multi-window mode that allows up to three simultaneous apps, it has gestures to switch apps quickly, the dock can be hidden or not, and with the Dex mode, you can have multiple windows. Undoubtedly, in this sense, the Samsung is a step above the iPad and iPadOS, since the Stage Manager is very complex to use on the device itself, being more usable when you answer the iPad to a monitor and SplitView and SlideOver options, being very good, are clearly more limited than on the Samsung.

rGq9AAA.jpeg

xjti6fO.jpeg

RV581iV.jpeg

6mmwaEl.jpeg


When it comes to the quality of apps, iPadOS is ahead. This is something that is already noticeable on mobiles, but on tablets it is more evident. In the end all apps are scaled from the phone and even Twitter (X), on the iPadOS is adapted to the larger interface of the device, while on Android, it is the same as on the phone, but larger.

On the Galaxy Tab S9+ it comes with different apps like Lumafusion, Good Notes and Clip Studio, good apps for video editing, note taking and drawing. However, Procreate or Pixelmator Photo on the iPad are far superior apps to Lightroom (which needs subscription instead of one-time payment like Pixelmator) or Clip Studio. .

Regarding the Spen, it comes with the tablet (not the charger), is small and light, has a customizable button and for writing I like it better than Apple's Apple Pencil. However, for drawing, the Apple Pencil is better than the Spen, thanks to the pencil itself that allows you to tilt it to make shadows, for example, and the quality of the Procreate app, which is excellent.

dDJfFGz.jpeg


The Spen is loaded at the back and can be fixed at the top right when in landscape mode.

The tablet has a fairly fast fingerprint sensor and facial recognition as well.

I like Samsung's security suite, Knox, having many features that Apple incorporates, which I think is very positive for the consumer.

The autonomy of the tablet is correct, around 8-10 hours. With the 45W charger it charges in just over an hour, much faster than the 12.9" iPad Pro which with the 35W charger takes almost two hours to charge.

I also bought the keyboard (without trackpad) for it which looks like the iPad Pro's Smart Keyboard Folio. The feel of the case is similar, silicone type, but the keyboard has traditional keys and does not have the keyboard "built in" to the case, so the feel of the keys is better on the Samsung. However, when you close the tablet, it is not completely "glued" and moves a little. The case has an opening at the top to store the Spen without having to remove the case. It doesn't make it much heavier or fatter, making it quite comfortable to travel with. Like the Apple cases, they stain fairly easily.

It only has a 60° position unlike the full keyboard case which has a Surface style stand or the iPad Smart Keyboard Folio which has two positions.

Hardware.

It has the Qualcomm Snapdragon 8 Gen 2, 12GB of RAM and 512GB in this case, expandable by microSD up to 1TB.

It has enough power to do anything, although it is true that the iPad Pro with the M2 or even the Air with the M1 is better, since they have "computer" processors. The problem with the iPad is that this power is not accompanied by a software that makes the most of it, something that Android allows, especially in relation to everything related to multitasking, background tasks, etc..

You won't have any complaints in this regard and everything you do will be done very quickly, even complex tasks that use AI.

Conclusions.

After a week of using it as my main tablet, I honestly like it a lot. It has much better stuff than the iPad and the iPad has better stuff than the Galaxy.

In terms of apps, for me the iPad has the upper hand, it has many dedicated apps for the iPad, especially for illustration (Procreate) and photo and video editing (Pixelmator Photo, Logic Pro). Then more common apps, such as X/Twitter are better optimized for the device's larger screen size.

As for multitasking, OneUI is way ahead of Apple, both in the "normal" version and in the Dex version. For my taste, SplitView and SlideOver are quite intuitive and easy to use, but Samsung's multiview is far superior, much more customizable and the gestures, once you get the hang of it, work very well.

The Office suite on both is similar. Aesthetically somewhat more neat on iPadOS, but the functionalities are exactly the same, so in the end we have a limited Office suite.

The fact that it is light and comfortable to hold in the hand and the fact that it is well built and feels solid in the hand makes it comfortable to use in touch mode, more so than the 12.9" iPad Pro.

As for the screen format if it's true that I like Apple's square format better, especially when you're using it for productivity. For viewing content, the Samsung is better.

Finally there is the price.

Currently the version I have, the 5G, 512GB and 12GB of RAM, plus the keyboard costs 1300€.

If we compare it to the iPad Pro 12.9 5G 512GB with Apple Pencil and Smart Keyboard Folio (not the Magic Keyboard, which is even more expensive) it costs 2427€.

Is it worth the difference? If for you the ecosystem and the specific applications are paramount, surely yes, but objectively the difference, for a basic office use (internet, documents, video, social networks), is not worth it. The Samsung device is excellent, has a good screen, good audio, a fairly powerful security suite, and excellent performance.
Great review.

For me, the biggest problem with iPads nowadays is the price and only having 120Hz with the Pros. I don't use the tablet as a laptop replacement, but I do want 120Hz, so I'm spending more than a laptop just to get that one must feature for me.

That's why I went with the Xiaomi Pad 6S Pro. Just 700€ with the keyboard and also has excellent hardware and software (but needs more polish).
 

vine-boating

macrumors 68020
Aug 10, 2017
2,229
572
Great review.

For me, the biggest problem with iPads nowadays is the price and only having 120Hz with the Pros. I don't use the tablet as a laptop replacement, but I do want 120Hz, so I'm spending more than a laptop just to get that one must feature for me.

That's why I went with the Xiaomi Pad 6S Pro. Just 700€ with the keyboard and also has excellent hardware and software (but needs more polish).
Is the Xiaomi better than the Galaxy Tab?
 

vine-boating

macrumors 68020
Aug 10, 2017
2,229
572
I don't use screen protectors, neither on the iPad nor on the Samsung.

I bought the official Samsung case, with the keyboard, but without trackpad. It is a very similar material to that of the iPad, perhaps a bit dirtier still. It has a hole in the back to store the pencil, so it's not bad.
How is the keyboard? Is it similar to the Magic keyboard for the iPad?
 

Sensamic

macrumors 68040
Mar 26, 2010
3,072
689
Is the Xiaomi better than the Galaxy Tab?
Can't talk much about the Tab since I don't own one. I'd say software wise Samsung is better, no doubt. Xiaomi on the other hand gives you more hardware (like storage, 120W charger or 144Hz) for less money, and software is good enough nowadays, but still needs more polish. I also like the screen aspect ratio of the Xiaomi more, but it's not OLED as Samsung. I also prefer OneUI more on my S24+.
 

RSB96

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jan 23, 2021
422
1,914
Spain
Is the Xiaomi better than the Galaxy Tab?

How is the keyboard? Is it similar to the Magic keyboard for the iPad?

In my opinion Samsung is a better option than Xioami, especially for technical service and software. Xioami has better hardware, but the after-sales service is bad and the software is terrible, with many problems that have not been solved for years.

As for the keyboard, I find the iPad's keyboard more reliable. The feel of the keyboard is much more solid and robust on the iPad. On the Samsung there are times when it doesn't recognize uppercase and lowercase well and it gets a little crazy and feels a little frustrating. I also don't like when you are in Word and it changes the word by itself (by autocorrect) and puts anything random.

On the iPad the keyboard is not so erratic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DeepIn2U

vine-boating

macrumors 68020
Aug 10, 2017
2,229
572
In my opinion Samsung is a better option than Xioami, especially for technical service and software. Xioami has better hardware, but the after-sales service is bad and the software is terrible, with many problems that have not been solved for years.

As for the keyboard, I find the iPad's keyboard more reliable. The feel of the keyboard is much more solid and robust on the iPad. On the Samsung there are times when it doesn't recognize uppercase and lowercase well and it gets a little crazy and feels a little frustrating. I also don't like when you are in Word and it changes the word by itself (by autocorrect) and puts anything random.

On the iPad the keyboard is not so erratic.
Thanks
I think I won't buy the keyboard then! I mostly going to use the Samsung to annotate documents and watch movies anyways so I don't think they keyboard is required.
 

RSB96

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jan 23, 2021
422
1,914
Spain
In a few weeks I will compare the iPad Pro 13" M4 vs this Samsung Galaxy Tab S9+.

I am very excited to see Apple Intelligence working, but it will not arrive in Spain until next year so, at the moment, the the AI advantage goes to Samsung.

I have to say that after having been using Android for a couple of months instead of iOS (my Pixel 8 Pro and my Samsung Galaxy Tab S9+), going back to iOS has made me feel "at home" again.

I guess it's because I've been in the Apple ecosystem for almost two decades, but even though I like Android and the products I have are excellent (even if they have defects, no product is perfect), I still miss a greater cohesion between devices.

I guess the Galaxy ecosystem is somewhat above in relation to having Android with another manufacturer and the Samsung tablet, but I do find it lacking in terms of getting the call on the tablet, a universal clipboard, among other features that Apple has had for years.

The "AirDrop" of Android, is quite convincing and is quite fast.

But in the end, I feel more comfortable using my iPad and iPhone. So even though I continue to use both systems, on a day-to-day basis I still find myself more comfortable in Apple's walled garden.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Technerd108

DeepIn2U

macrumors G5
May 30, 2002
13,051
6,984
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Great write up and awesome timing!

My "gen-1" iPad Pro 9.7" (w/logi keyboard case) is getting a little long in the tooth and I've been looking into what's next.

Agreed.

RSB96


your write up review/preview is very methodical and well written, moreover much easier to read than most editors that do this full time.

Ah, that's Telegram, the messaging app I use the most, since I hate WhatsApp (in Europe iMessage has hardly any presence).

Yes, my bank's app is not available on the Samsung tablet either, although on the iPad I prefer to enter from the browser for convenience, like instagram, for example.

I suppose it's possible that all the AI features that iOS 18 is going to implement will be the biggest barrier to those iPads, especially since it's rumored that much of it will run on the device itself.

I'm not certain if your S9 Ultra has OneUI 6.1 installed, yet I'm guessing not as you've not mentioned anything related to AI therein.

Let me put it this way ... Apple's "intelligence" stance is immensely taking the book that Samsung (with their own LLM models) mixed with Google Gemini have already done since February 2024 on the Galaxy S series, Z series devices in full from the S23 to S24 and Z Fold/Z Flip 5 to 4 series for each. Not intrusive and most features are On-Device with Circle to Search and very minimal features going to cloud yet ONLY for that specific instance nothing related to your Device ID is shared.

I love my S23 more than I ever did with any iPhone since 3G to the 13 mini (the 14/15 Pro's didn't impress me one bit and iOS 16-17 soured my experience along with full encryption of their services giving me a one over beyond belief).

In time I'll get the base Tab S9 as the larger models are beyond my needs/use case.

Great review.

For me, the biggest problem with iPads nowadays is the price and only having 120Hz with the Pros. I don't use the tablet as a laptop replacement, but I do want 120Hz, so I'm spending more than a laptop just to get that one must feature for me.

That's why I went with the Xiaomi Pad 6S Pro. Just 700€ with the keyboard and also has excellent hardware and software (but needs more polish).

Tab or even the Galaxy S series with (BT Keyboard, Mouse, and external screen via Multi-Cast or Casting) pretty much works well as a laptop replacement. I do recommend using the Samsung Internet Browser as the base and FireFox as the primary vs Google Chrome (but that's personal preferences on the latter). Samsung Internet Browser performs and runs as a FULL Fledge browser NOT a mobile second-class as the others.

In my opinion Samsung is a better option than Xioami, especially for technical service and software. Xioami has better hardware, but the after-sales service is bad and the software is terrible, with many problems that have not been solved for years.

As for the keyboard, I find the iPad's keyboard more reliable. The feel of the keyboard is much more solid and robust on the iPad. On the Samsung there are times when it doesn't recognize uppercase and lowercase well and it gets a little crazy and feels a little frustrating. I also don't like when you are in Word and it changes the word by itself (by autocorrect) and puts anything random.

On the iPad the keyboard is not so erratic.

Well said on the above points related to Samsung devices. That said there are strange quirks such as their native Mail application. I created several drafts from March to early April. If I open the draft ... I'm prompted to Save or Discard.

Discard ... some drafts are simply deleted and sent to deleted items folder. Some are just saved but UPDATED with the current date with annoys the FRIGGIN HELL Out of me. Discard should be simply Discard the opened edit and revert BACK to the original draft date.

Save - will do what its supposed to do. Save an updated date and/or version of the draft with the current date.
 

RSB96

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Jan 23, 2021
422
1,914
Spain
When I tested the tablet, it didn't have Galaxy AI yet, I think it was introduced in April/May, maybe, I don't remember now.

It is true that the AI I ended up using more the one offered by Google than Samsung, especially in the photo editing section, since the results I got with the Galaxy Tab did not convince me at all.

I really like the Circle to search and it works 95% of the time very well.

In Spain we probably won't have Apple Intelligence until well into the year 2025, so until then I just have to wait and see what the media and users say when they have it in English in the US.

I really like the Galaxy Tab S9 + I have, but it is true that unlike the phone, in which it would cost me less to get rid of the iPhone, in tablet I still prefer the iPad, especially for the specific apps that I usually use, such as Pixelmator Photo or Procreate. I also consider that typical apps like Twitter (X), are better adapted to the large size of the iPad than on Android tablets.

I sold the Dell I had and in a few weeks I will get the Surface Pro X Elite OLED, because I also want to see how Copilot works. This year I will likely replace the Pixel 8 with either the Pixel 9 Pro Fold or the Galaxy Fold 6, which looks like it will have a much improved wrinkle from what was seen in a leaked photo today.

I like to try things that are outside of Apple, even if it is secondary or for more professional use (in Spain, at the corporate level Apple does not have much implementation, except for the iPhone, which the SE is usually the company mobile that usually give you in medium / large companies). It is usual to work with Microsoft's 360 suite or Google's business suite, so it is more comfortable to work with non-Apple devices.

And it's also a way to be aware of what's outside Apple's "walled garden".
 
  • Love
Reactions: DeepIn2U

DeepIn2U

macrumors G5
May 30, 2002
13,051
6,984
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
FYi within the camera app on S23 as well mote than likely the Tab S9, you can swipe from right to left and you "should" see both Pro and Pro RAW modes when in the viewfinder. Or it needs to be enabled in the camera app settings button for it to be present in view finder.
 

Carrotstick

Suspended
Mar 25, 2024
230
418
In time this will be device. iPhone 15 (going to keep till it dies), Tab S9 and I will be upgrading my desktop to Intel’s Arrow Lake CPUs later this year.

I am done with buying new Apple products and software.
 

DeepSix

macrumors 6502a
Feb 4, 2022
847
934
The multi-tasking is just leagues better on the Samsung tabs than on iOS. It's very good and I find Im always having two apps open at the same time. It makes for a completely new experience on Galaxy Tabs and to be honest Im not sure how I could go back to ipad OS.

And so nice to see true mouse support and functionality on the Galaxy Tabs. Works just like on a real computer. I will never ever attempt to use any mouse on ipad OS ever. There is no going back.
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: crazynewf7
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.