That's actually the most salient point. --Namely, whether they are specifically and willfully ENCOURAGING piracy. This is similar to SingingFish.com and WebJay.com. Both of these websites acquired, yet no longer offer public services (WebJay as of the end of last month).If SeekPod is going out of their way to list artists like "John Legend" or "Madonna", and indexing everything in categories, etc... sounds like its an open and shut case, and a far cry from them making an effort to have users NOT link to unauthorized songs. I really think the DMCA take-down notice approach only goes SO far, and if something is willfull, I'd imagine they'd go from cease-and-desist to lawsuit real quick.
Just my thought.
~ CB