Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

iPod Should I spring for an iPod classic now, or continue to wait for a 32 GB iPod touch?

N

norcalstadium

macrumors member
Original poster
Jun 4, 2007
80
0
So, I've been waiting to get a new iPod (and in particular, an iPod touch) for awhile now, as my 3rd Generation iPod has been unusable for about a year.
But, I have 19 GB's of music, and I want to carry all of my music in my iPod.
So my two options are as follows: to continue to wait for larger capacity iPod touch or to just purchase an iPod classic.
What do you think I should do?

Also, it's important to note that no matter what, I will be purchasing an iPod before the end of May because I will be traveling intercontinentally all through June.
 
norcalstadium said:
So, I've been waiting to get a new iPod (and in particular, an iPod touch) for awhile now, as my 3rd Generation iPod has been unusable for about a year.
But, I have 19 GB's of music, and I want to carry all of my music in my iPod.
So my two options are as follows: to continue to wait for larger capacity iPod touch or to just purchase an iPod classic.
What do you think I should do?

Also, it's important to note that no matter what, I will be purchasing an iPod before the end of May because I will be traveling intercontinentally all through June.
Click to expand...

OK - if it were me, and I had my heart set on a Touch, then I wouldn't be considering a Classic. You will regret your decision to compromise. However I would say that you may end up waiting for longer than you hoped for a 32GB Touch.

Again, if it were me, I would wait as long as possible in the hope that a 32GB Touch is released (although there is absolutely no guarantee that it will be), and if it isn't get the 16GB instead. You may feel that you want to take all 19GB of music with you, but i'll bet you could lose a few GB without even noticing.

At the end of the daym, though, the choice is yours. These are just my thoughts.
 
I love my 160 GB iPod classic. It's an awesome device.

However, I also have an iPhone, so I don't feel touch deprived.
 
I think the "touch/iphone" concept is a horrid design for a music player. I hardly look at my classic to operate it. I like buttons I can press and controls that I don't need to look at to use. Touch is awesome for video, pic, and wifi, etc... but for music...no. Save some money and get a classic. You'll be happy you did.
 
I doubt there will be a 32 gig iPod touch before May, i would just buy a 16 gig, especially seen as how you now get the 5 apps with it
 
yea i would go with a 16 gig.... the 32 gig will be so expensive by then, you will might as well get a computer.
 
Get a classic if you need it for music. I have an iphone which I never use for music. I prefer the classic and don't like to choose my music. I have been away for the last 10 days travelling and my ipod classic has been a life saver. I have my 16gb of music and a further 25gb of movies and video as well as 1 gb of photos of my baby daughter. I purposely went and brought a classic before leaving on the monday. Watching a film now and typing this on my BB.
 
Well, according to a recent article on Macrumors, the Flash Drive used in the iPod Touch has dropped down 75% in price, and Macrumors expects this to decrease the iPod Touch. That would probably be your best bet for this year for them to release a new 32GB Touch (Worst case you can get a 16GB for a cheaper price)

Personally, I'd settle for the 16GB Touch if you aren't intent on buying videos. Personally, i'm going to get an iPod Touch, despite having 80GB of Music +Vids (I might hold out for the 32GB Touch or opt for the 160GB Classic)
 
But the recent rate of iPod revisions and updates suggest that we won't see new iPods until September or so...

It doesn't sound like you're willing to wait that long, right? Apple can always spring a surprise or two, but I almost certainly see no new models before June.
 
I have a lot of music videos as well as albums on my iPod Classic (over 45GB worth) so even the 32GB iPod Touch wouldn't be enough for me. I like to carry all my music with me.
 
bluebomberman said:
But the recent rate of iPod revisions and updates suggest that we won't see new iPods until September or so...

It doesn't sound like you're willing to wait that long, right? Apple can always spring a surprise or two, but I almost certainly see no new models before June.
Click to expand...

Ha well thats a bummer....
 
bluebomberman said:
But the recent rate of iPod revisions and updates suggest that we won't see new iPods until September or so...

It doesn't sound like you're willing to wait that long, right? Apple can always spring a surprise or two, but I almost certainly see no new models before June.
Click to expand...

acearchie said:
Ha well thats a bummer....
Click to expand...

Well, I guess you guys will have to come over and take away my crystal ball. :p

But daaaamn the higher-capacity models are expensive. The iPod classic might be a better deal now just for its lower price point.
 
I say wait for a 32gb iPod Touch, but god knows when one of those will come along. Long wait. Hopefully it will bring a 16gb iPhone along with it.. Who knows... just have to wait and see.


Oh. Ermm. Yeah.
 
Hey, can you ask if they'll be releasing the 160GB Apple TV for 300 in the apple TV thread for me :D

I'm buying the new iPod Touch asap
 
hahaha wow talk about opportune timing. right when I heard about the 32 GB iPod touch, I thought about this thread lol
 
So are you going to get the new 32gb Touch?

I was waiting for that myself, but decided to go with the 80gb Classic. I recycled my old one and bought the Classic on Black Friday, so it was only $200. $500 seems a bit steep for a new Touch.
 
Is there an advantage to waiting till the end of May?

Yeah, $500 does seem a bit steep. So, I wonder if there's an advantage to waiting a few months. Is there potential for a price drop?
After all, since I've waited this long, I can surely wait a couple of months more (if it will be advantageous to do so).
 
Having used my first iPod ever for the past few months, an 80 gig Classic, I can say that I'm super satisfied that I made the right decision not to get an iTouch, but not just because the storage space is so much bigger (which it is, and which still isn't enough).

More importantly I'm really happy with what the iPod Classic does NOT have. The iTouch is great because it lets you always be on the internet.
The iTouch is bad because it lets you always be on the internet.

Think about it. When I have easy web access it's a huge distraction and makes me procrastinate like crazy (such as right now). If I had the net in my pocket it'd be a constant temptation to procrastinate. I want my music player to be an escape, or I want it to help me focus, or help me unwind, or whatever. I realize now that having net access on my music player would be a huge mistake that would prevent me from really enjoying my music.
 
norcalstadium said:
Yeah, $500 does seem a bit steep. So, I wonder if there's an advantage to waiting a few months. Is there potential for a price drop?
After all, since I've waited this long, I can surely wait a couple of months more (if it will be advantageous to do so).
Click to expand...

as time goes on you may be able to find one from a third party retailer for around 460. I know that happened with the 16gb and 8 gb.

Also keep an eye out for rebates and stuff, I know target was selling a 16gb with a $40 gift card, which is essentially as good as cash where I live.
 
I say keep an eye on Amazon pricing, for the new model.

Otherwise, just go for it, unless it's too expensive for you. It will be a great device, and they won't update pricing until they update the iPod line, which I expect would be in the fall, for the holiday season.

Also, I don't see any revolutionary changes to iPods this year. Just capacity, pricing, colors, etc. but I hope I'm wrong!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back