great threadI'm in a similar boat. First, I am a long-time computer designer/geek + amateur photographer by all meansand have never owned a digital camera!
Here is my current rig:
1972 Olympus OM-1 with 50mm 1.8 lens (its my dadsI'm only 24). My largest complaint with digital cameras is edge detail/banding (I can spot it pretty far away) and highlight detail.
I think the canon 5D does great in its
resolve detail
I have been conducting numerous research on "digital vs. film" and first, I love grain. If done right, it adds emotion & art, IMO. Anyway, to invest in digital, I want:
FF, since I have used this from the beginning
8+ MP (since it is argued 35mm is around 10+ MP at 400 ISO)
rugged body
edge detail, yet no banding
decent dynamic range in contrast
a lens with f1.8
Here is my conclusion so far: the Canon 5D (haven't researched lenses yet).
Is this a good camera to step into the digital world with?
I know no one can foresee the future, but did the recent Mark III steal the 5D's upgrade? Regardless of MP, resolving, I still feel pro-sumer digital cameras have "blotchy" almost artificial color saturation/gradation in uncontrolled lighting instances. I was hoping a new chip was on the way to bring 16 bit to the pro-sumer line.
Anyway, I'd love to hear comments/suggestions.
Thanks