Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

CSBBody

macrumors member
Original poster
Jan 23, 2020
60
44
I have been reading everyone’s threads, watching various reviews. i love tech, i sadly however am technologically challenged lol

i work in nutritional sciences by trade, much of my day is dealing with Nutrition design (spreadsheets, docs etc) browsing the web, research papers, and general day to day running of my company. And live-streaming here and there.

I am just starting in music as a hobby so will be playing with DAW, Probably Logic Pro - emphasis on newbie, just to support my guitar journey.

Myself and the lady are hobby photographers and play around with video as well, FCP will be the editing software. The videos are mainly for my social media content, so very basic needs at this stage.

I am itching to jump on the M1 train, GAS i know sue me lol, i am quite happy to grab the base MBA with 8GB ram.

I do not think 16gb will benefit me much now, i will update again as soon as the higher spec ones get released. So future proofing isn’t a necessary reality for me past the next 2 years max, and the 6 week wait for a custom machine in my country, I don’t have that patience.

My current work/private life consists of :

16” MacBook Pro base i7 16gb 512 machine that drives my office : (purchased February 2020 just before hard lockdown)

Dell 3818 monitor
Focusrite 2i2 audio
couple external drives only 1-2 hooked up at any time.

it does everything i want, main complaint is the fan noise, no matter what i am doing or working on. To date, it has never left my office or been out of clamshell mode. I would opt for the new mac mini, but i do need to travel occasionally , and the iPad doesn’t quite do everything i need on the road.

Otherwise i have a IPad Pro 12.9 2020 with MKB, which i am on much of the time, which floats around the house with me.

The idea is to purchase the MBA, test it, make sure all my software works and sell my 16” which should recoup me the cost of the MBA and probably leave me with 700-1000 dollars in the bank. Which i can use later when the new top spec machines get released.

Really scared of them releasing a top spec 16 and mine is rendered worthless on the second hand market, well certainly for what i can get now for it privately.

The only “upgrade” i would do is take the 512gb version and not the 256gb, although i use the cloud a lot, I remember the nightmare that was my 128gb 13” MacBook in 2017.

This isn’t an affordability issue for me.

Rather am i just throwing money away? when all my bases are covered already, i think i am struggling with this decision the most and secondly whether 256 or 512gb is enough, lastly do i need more ports, but cant think so At this stage.
 
Last edited:

TheGenerous

macrumors 65816
Nov 14, 2010
1,122
438
I'm an Austronaut
i sadly however am technologically challenged lol

i work in nutritional sciences by trade, much of my day is dealing with Nutrition design (spreadsheets, docs etc) browsing the web, research papers, and general day to day running of my company. And live-streaming here and there.


And then he has the latest and greatest tech. ?‍♂️
…and wants the latest-latest and greatest tech.
 

Mike Boreham

macrumors 68040
Aug 10, 2006
3,913
1,896
UK
1. Likely all your software will not run ... yet.
2. Smaller screen won’t mater as you are clamshell.
3. Same for battery.

All you will be gaining right now is quiet machine.
Very misleading and not my experience. I spent yesterday installing all the software from my old Macbook on my new M1 Air and haven’t found anything which won’t run. The whole experience was so seamless that I can't tell what is Rosetta and what is Universal. If there is a speed difference it is not subjectively different.

If this had been a “blindfold” test I would not have known I was on an M1 or an Intel Mac apart from being asked to install Rosetta the first time.
 
Last edited:

matrix07

macrumors G3
Jun 24, 2010
8,226
4,895
The decision should be easy. If you get good offer for your 16” sell it and buy MBA 512 GB.
Don’t listen to @Zazoh your software should be fine.
Now is a time for stealth selling as next year when new 16” drops the value of your existing one will do as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CSBBody

badsimian

macrumors 6502
Aug 23, 2015
374
200
So this is uncanny. I am in *exactly* the same position only I have gone ahead and actually got the 8GB/512GB Air and am typing on it right now. My plan is exactly the same, sell my 16" now in the knowledge that I will get GAS in a couple of years at most and want the fancy 14"/micro-LED or whatever is around at that point so I don't want to sink too much money into this one to lose it again later.

I convinced myself last time to get a specced up 64GB/2TB/16" - realised it was daft and returned that for a 32/1TB/16" which I have been using for a year. Again like you very happy with it except for fan noise. I use it docked with an LG 5K a lot and before I got that a Benq 4K and both cause the fan to go nuts so that I need to use Turbo boost disabler to make it bearable.

I have installed everything I use day to day, it has been indexing etc over night and it hasn't skipped a beat. It is fast no matter what I do with it. The only slight wrinkle is I couldn't install a bunch of stuff via a single line in Homebrew as that side of things isn't there yet so I went back to installing everything manually like a caveman. That will get resolved in time.

Spec-wise the decision gets difficult, I almost ordered the 16GB/1TB because obviously that's what I need right? I work in IT, I couldn't possibly get by on the base model for mere mortals!...Only it turns out I can. If I am brutally honest with myself, with the move to the cloud my local computing needs have got less over the years not more. I actually was working with a 12" MB a couple of years ago for a few months and that was fine too. Fanless is amazing.
I occasionally play games via bootcamp on my 16" but nowhere near enough to warrant keeping it for that, my favourite though is Warcraft 3 reforged and that works amazingly well on this Air.

Like you suggested - juggling for space from the get-go is bad and for that reason alone I went 512. I don't need and can't run VMs any more so can easily drop from 1TB. I can run those on my server anyway and remote into them. I never did it much on my 16" because of fan noise.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CSBBody

CSBBody

macrumors member
Original poster
Jan 23, 2020
60
44
Thank you all, picked up a base model MBA to try quick, we don’t have a return policy here, but will give to my wife if it doesn’t work for me, as i am slowly getting her more into the apple ecosystem. Or sell and take a small knock.

Feels so weird as i am waiting for the transfer, the 16 seems so big now lol. Some buyers remorse haha as the 16 is a killer machine.

But as mentioned above, NOW i can get decent money back for my 16” actually more than I paid for it earlier in the year, the prices skyrocketed locally pre and post lockdown, but a 20-30 % margin.

I am more worried i lose a lot more come next year, on the 16 and i know i will be itching for whatever comes out.

I may not appreciate all the bells and whistles of the “pro” machines but i buy base usually, I don’t spec out, i can afford it, even if I couldn’t its a tax write off for me, and usually have stars on my eyes and grand ideas of editing this and that and being left wanting Tech wise, only to be left wanting in actually utilizing it to its full potential. We all ave our vices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mr_jomo

Zazoh

macrumors 68000
Jan 4, 2009
1,516
1,121
San Antonio, Texas
The decision should be easy. If you get good offer for your 16” sell it and buy MBA 512 GB.
Don’t listen to @Zazoh your software should be fine.
Now is a time for stealth selling as next year when new 16” drops the value of your existing one will do as well.

“Should be fine” ? OP is running the office and business, livelihood from current device. I think caution is in order.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CSBBody

badsimian

macrumors 6502
Aug 23, 2015
374
200
Anyone who doesn't have an alternate way to be able to earn their livelihood if their current machine breaks down/stolen/sets on fire is clearly not interested in caution.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CSBBody

CSBBody

macrumors member
Original poster
Jan 23, 2020
60
44
i am sorted for now and have my 16 as back up, for now i am going to take my time testing everything i need. Before selling the 16”. I will keep it as long as i need to till comfortable With the M1, if it doesn’t just become another supplementary device or getting my lady deeper into apple and a nice machine for her Work and hobbies.

I can now see ports are a minor issue/irritation i will need to address, and will need a better hub / docking station. I have 2 here (small hyperdrive and a Qdos wireless charger / hub ,i will test as soon as i can, the display out i normally just ran thunderbolt direct, but now with one port for power and only one for a hub.

see the hubs give out HDMI just not sure if 4K/30 or 4k60 yet. Waiting to test.

Software wise , so far no issue‘s on my very basic needs.

Plex works - via Rosetta
Torrent works
Seeing my one hub and external drive, and focusrite audio interface

before testing more, just trying to figure out why on the merge across, i was only using 100-120gb on my 16, and already blown 200gb on the M1.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.