Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I've never used an iPhone with cellular service, so I never get them. (Thus, I suppose I can't be fairly accused of dismissing them.)
 
I think it’s funny how cross-platform messaging apps aren’t very popular in the US. Haven’t we learned anything from BBM?


iMessage sucks, especially so if you have many iOS devices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Falhófnir
I've never used an iPhone with cellular service, so I never get them. (Thus, I suppose I can't be fairly accused of dismissing them.)

I don’t understand, your cell phone doesn’t have cellular service? Do you use it without a SIM card, basically as an iPod?

No, not an issue.

Why not? Does everyone you know use an iPhone?


I think it’s funny how cross-platform messaging apps aren’t very popular in the US. Haven’t we learned anything from BBM?


iMessage sucks, especially so if you have many iOS devices.

What makes you say that iMessage sucks? I would think that having many Apple devices would make it all the more useful for you. I just have an iPhone and an iPad.
 
What makes you say that iMessage sucks? I would think that having many Apple devices would make it all the more useful for you. I just have an iPhone and an iPad.

Not cross-platform. 8 years in and I’m still not sure what it’ll do with the pics I send and receive.

WhatsApp is a lot better overall.
 
  • Like
Reactions: iSilas and YaBe
I don’t understand, your cell phone doesn’t have cellular service? Do you use it without a SIM card, basically as an iPod?

It requires a SIM card to activate (I think one that was previously on a contract, even – it feels ridiculous, but it works). I used iPod touches until the release of the Apple Watch, and now I'm using an iPhone SE.
 
It requires a SIM card to activate (I think one that was previously on a contract, even – it feels ridiculous, but it works). I used iPod touches until the release of the Apple Watch, and now I'm using an iPhone SE.

Out of curiosity, do you have an Android phone, a “dumb phone”, or no cellphone at all?
 
Out of curiosity, do you have an Android phone, a “dumb phone”, or no cellphone at all?
Well he said:
I'm using an iPhone SE.
That said,
Not cross-platform. 8 years in and I’m still not sure what it’ll do with the pics I send and receive.

WhatsApp is a lot better overall.
Agreed, Whatsapp is the way to go... Apple could have taken the spot had they release a cross platform iMessage, but probably afraid of losing iOS customers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Starfia
I couldn't care less, it's the snobbery around green bubbles that makes me feel dreadful to no end
 
  • Like
Reactions: compwiz1202
Green bubles are evolving... But whatsapp is still the best.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20190826-093135.png
    Screenshot_20190826-093135.png
    189.8 KB · Views: 197
  • Screenshot_20190826-092753.png
    Screenshot_20190826-092753.png
    154.4 KB · Views: 199
  • Screenshot_20190826-092807.png
    Screenshot_20190826-092807.png
    383.9 KB · Views: 164
  • Like
Reactions: ZebraDude
Well he said:

That said,

Agreed, Whatsapp is the way to go... Apple could have taken the spot had they release a cross platform iMessage, but probably afraid of losing iOS customers.

He did say he's using an SE, but he also said he's using it without cellular capabilities, so I was just wondering what, if anything, he uses for a phone.
 
I don’t really notice any difference except if the phone is turned off then my other devices (Mac and iPad) don’t receive or send to the green bubbles - iPhone needs to be turned on
 
It’s not something I think about. I only know a few people with Android phones and green bubbles are the same as blue ones for me. It’s a text message, not a status symbol.

Exactly. So silly worrying about a different color bubble. iMessage is good but an over rated feature
 
Exactly. So silly worrying about a different color bubble. iMessage is good but an over rated feature

I like that it doesn’t compress pics or videos so I use it between close family. It’s also cool to get the messages on my iPad.

I mainly use WhatsApp for group messaging though as it’s better for sharing media cross platform.
 
Exactly. So silly worrying about a different color bubble. iMessage is good but an over rated feature
No. iMessage is arguably the only messaging platform that shares pictures in their original quality. The only other app that does this is wechat. The rest (whatsapp, telegram, etc) resized your photos into a low res crap. I have provided the data a while back in the Android sub-forum.

But I won't judge you if you prefer the low quality MMS photos and videos. More power to you.
[doublepost=1566813747][/doublepost]
iMessage isn't a thing where I live. Most people I know use WhatsApp even if they have an iPhone.
True, which is unfortunate.
I see people sharing their important moments, trips, even wedding photos, via whatsapp, not realizing all of them are being resized into low-res photos that are unusable for anything else. Of course, later they are upset why their printed photo album don't look good.
 
I don’t avoid green bubbles or have any aversion to them, but I do tend to find there’s a natural tendency for chats with non-iOS friends to end up in WhatsApp and that’s usually their decision, not mine.

I don’t think it’s anything to do with the colour of a Bubble. iMessage and the likes of WhatsApp tell you a lot about the type of interaction you’re having with somebody - you can easily gauge how much of their attention you have and how much of your attention it’s worth giving. With SMS, you’re more in the dark.

Unfortunately that means that people who consider the world to revolve around themselves adopt a “why don’t you have an iPhone?!” attitude.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Azzin
I’ve categorically banned Facebook from my life and anything related to Facebook, which included WhatsApp. Especially when the former CEO of WhatsApp left the merged company after disagreements related to privacy.

So it’s either iMessage to contact me or signal for non iOS users.
 
My family is split down the middle with half android and half apple. I see the different color bubbles but really don't care. Why is it an issue? Now my son in law can customize the backgrounds of his texts which is actually kind of cool but not cool enough to leave apple. My sisters (android users) use the Verizon app which is also customizable but I like iMessage and I am just boring that way.
 
This is about the dumbest thing I've read since a long time. Bored wannabe journalist pulls a problem out of the worlds ass.

I read the article until the argument that the "green was intentionally made ugly". It's just ridiculous. Colors have their limited meaning, but it's mostly dictated by context - be it other colors, images, ... And green is in no way an ugly color, even in a poisonously saturated version. If you want to have significant data on this topic, read Beauty by Sagmeister and Walsh, who concluded that most people consider ****-like brown to be ugly, but green was nowhere near that (Blue was by far the favourite though).

From a design perspective its clear, that Apple needs to signal the feature disparity somehow (where the reasons of the disparity might be of technological, design and business related nature). Choosing two different colours with similar saturation and brightness, both of which are consistently used in their design language -- hell, the message app itself is THAT green -- is the most natural and neutral thing to do (allthough the blue certainly puts a light bias in here).

Now does Apple intentionally segment their user base here? Of course they do. Everybody who utilises the power of branding does it. But in this case they do it as subtly as possible. I really think its design wise one of the best ways to accomplish this task.

The problem described here has nothing to do with Apple. It's purely a matter of the maturity of society. There always has been the rich kids, the wannabe rich kids and the poor kids at school. I was one of the poor kids and i never had fancy brand stuff. And yes, other kids made fun of me. Try being the only one not wearing Nike sneakers, see who's talking to you then - loser.
It's part of life, it's part of economics. As long as there is an income disparity (which is another topic), there will be people buying vanity items. Yes it's painful as a kid, but its better to learn this lesson young than as an adult, because there is no escaping it. Making a whole fuzz about "green message bubbles" out of it is beyond ridiculous... and most likely paid by the competition who would kill to have the same brand power.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: akash.nu
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.