Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
the fate of IDE enclosures
- Thread starter zoran
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Electronics recycling service.
The main problem is that these enclosures have old disk controller chips that won't support the size (capacity) and bandwidth of today's large SATA drives.
The chips were designed in an era when the disk capacities were much smaller. The controller chip in an IDE enclosure from 2008 isn't going to recognize a 16TB SATA spinner even if you could find some sort of reasonably priced and electrically compatible conversion cable.
Furthermore, the physical clearances in these types of enclosures rarely allow for any sort of extension cable or extra electronics.
Lastly, SATA enclosures are cheap. Retrofitting an old enclosure with geriatric capacitors (and other components) makes zero sense.
The main problem is that these enclosures have old disk controller chips that won't support the size (capacity) and bandwidth of today's large SATA drives.
The chips were designed in an era when the disk capacities were much smaller. The controller chip in an IDE enclosure from 2008 isn't going to recognize a 16TB SATA spinner even if you could find some sort of reasonably priced and electrically compatible conversion cable.
Furthermore, the physical clearances in these types of enclosures rarely allow for any sort of extension cable or extra electronics.
Lastly, SATA enclosures are cheap. Retrofitting an old enclosure with geriatric capacitors (and other components) makes zero sense.
Your not wrong, but I guess I’m too emotionally connected with a couple of IDE enclosures I have, and don’t really want to give them for recycling. 😉
If your handy with a soldering iron and a Dremel, you could Frankenstein the innards of a new IDE enclosure into the case of an old one. Maybe some epoxy, too.
And you can borrow a hacksaw from @AngerDanger.
And you can borrow a hacksaw from @AngerDanger.
Over in the PowerPC section we're still dealing with these. Although I suspect, we probably use 2.5 enclosures more as Powerbooks/iBooks use 2.5 drives.
That said, a lot of members have been converting to SSD. In our G4 laptops that's mainly m2 SATAs in a SATA/IDE enclosure or an adapter. My own 17" Powerbook G4 runs a 128GB mSATA.
So we're a bit behind the curve as far as this stuff going to recycling. But not that far behind I think.