Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Retskrad

macrumors regular
Original poster
Apr 1, 2022
200
672
I have witnessed that people in my university, and a lot of people on social media, have adopted ChatGPT into their workflow. These "co-pilots" are a crucial part of working and they live permanently on the side. You are constantly sending it ideas and editing the draft. For that to happen, you need a keyboard which makes the iPad without a keyboard useless for people working in 2023. Of course, people say you can use the iPad with a keyboard but at that point, you might as well use the MacBook instead.

What are your thoughts on iPad's place in a world of AI butlers, like ChatGPT?
 

Arctic Moose

macrumors 68000
Jun 22, 2017
1,599
2,133
Gothenburg, Sweden
The same as before.

I don’t understand how the use case has changed, at least as far as text input is concerned.

You can use dictation, the on-screen keyboard, handoff copy-and-paste or any external keyboard you want, just like before.

It’s not like people didn’t frequently enter text before ChatGPT.

The iPad still has a smaller footprint, runs apps a Mac cannot and has pencil support, things many users appreciate and prefer.

I use my iPad and my Mac (and my iPhone, watch and Apple TV) pretty much equally, but for different tasks, just like before ChatGPT.
 
Last edited:

maflynn

macrumors Haswell
May 3, 2009
73,682
43,740
What are your thoughts on iPad's place in a world of AI butlers, like ChatGPT?
Can ChatGPT be used to watch a movie? Read a book. Send a text, edit a photo?

At work, we use tablets to enter data and confirm compliance, again, something that I don't think an AI engine can handle. So I don't see how the rise of chatgpt made the iPad useless
 

eltoslightfoot

macrumors 68030
Feb 25, 2011
2,547
3,099
I thought they were trying to say you can't load ML apps (like a mac can). I was going to be like, well yeah, you can't load XCode either. Now that I see they are talking about a website, then I agree with the others. I use a Magic Keyboard for those situations, otherwise it gets to be a tablet.
 

mkelly

Cancelled
Nov 29, 2007
207
218
I have witnessed that people in my university, and a lot of people on social media, have adopted ChatGPT into their workflow. These "co-pilots" are a crucial part of working and they live permanently on the side. You are constantly sending it ideas and editing the draft. For that to happen, you need a keyboard which makes the iPad without a keyboard useless for people working in 2023. Of course, people say you can use the iPad with a keyboard but at that point, you might as well use the MacBook instead.

What are your thoughts on iPad's place in a world of AI butlers, like ChatGPT?

Having a good understanding of what an "AI butler" actually is, and how they work behind the scenes, I don't use them for any kind of "real work". They're fun to play with, sure. But trust with my work? No. So I'm still good with my iPad and its limited built-in text input capabilities.

I strongly disagree that these "co-pilots" are a crucial part of working. They're shiny new text prediction engines, much like autocomplete on your iPhone, only trained on a larger dataset. The "I" in "AI" is a big misnomer. There is no intelligence at work.

I have a bit of a unique perspective when it comes to this sort of stuff in academia. I run the online learning management/course delivery systems for 13 or so universities and colleges. I also went to university for my undergrad both in the 90s and again 12 years later in the 2000s [I kinda got distracted the first time around]). That experience + my current work has given me a great deal of insight on how students have adapted to new technologies over the years.

Students have always looked for shortcuts to get their work done, and in the past 25 years or so these shortcuts have become more and more technologically-based. And I get it - depending on your area of study the workload can be huge (my area of study was physics, my 3rd year workload was nuts). Who wouldn't want to be more "efficient"?

But when it comes down to it, ChatGPT, Bard or Bing isn't likely to be there to answer questions or bounce ideas off during your final exam. In the long run, it's better to put in the effort to learn how to write a good essay, or write a C++ program, or calculate that partial differential equation yourself rather than trust that a predictive text bot running a bunch of linear algebra in a Microsoft datacenter is going to successfully and accurately do the work for you.
 
Last edited:

floral

macrumors 65816
Jan 12, 2023
1,011
1,234
Earth
I have witnessed that people in my university, and a lot of people on social media, have adopted ChatGPT into their workflow. These "co-pilots" are a crucial part of working and they live permanently on the side. You are constantly sending it ideas and editing the draft. For that to happen, you need a keyboard which makes the iPad without a keyboard useless for people working in 2023. Of course, people say you can use the iPad with a keyboard but at that point, you might as well use the MacBook instead.

What are your thoughts on iPad's place in a world of AI butlers, like ChatGPT?
The only times I remember using ChatGPT is to make a quick gag or because I was really bored.

I plan to be very stubborn if AI really is becoming our butlers, as I like working solo, and being independent has it's benefits:

No rules
No distractions
You are in full control

The iPad is the perfect tool for an AI rebellion (or to answer your question, it would be an outlier), as it makes every tool available that is perfect for humans (and only humans) to use: Pencil for drawing, keyboard for typing, and touchscreen for managing.

I'm betting that ChatGPT is just a fad, but considering how ambitious companies can be these days, I would not put it past them to adopt important AI features as well. Google and Bing as an example. So I'll just stop being involved with them as much as my workflow allows without feeling like there is something missing.
 
Last edited:

nmart1214

macrumors member
Aug 22, 2017
57
119
Funny enough, my iPad gets used for ChatGPT all the time. Not only do I have cheap Bluetooth keyboards laying around, but my iPad Air is a designated second display for my 14 inch MacBook Pro when I’m editing on the go. I use wired sidecar with files, chatgpt, and notes displaying on the iPad. Or universal control if I’m not worrying about files but I don’t use that as much.
 

iPadified

macrumors 68020
Apr 25, 2017
2,014
2,257
I have witnessed that people in my university, and a lot of people on social media, have adopted ChatGPT into their workflow. These "co-pilots" are a crucial part of working and they live permanently on the side. You are constantly sending it ideas and editing the draft. For that to happen, you need a keyboard which makes the iPad without a keyboard useless for people working in 2023. Of course, people say you can use the iPad with a keyboard but at that point, you might as well use the MacBook instead.

What are your thoughts on iPad's place in a world of AI butlers, like ChatGPT?
You mean you do know how to copy and paste using touch?

Workflow? Please explain. I read on Science (or was it Nature) homepage today that AI written texts was forbidden in their journals. Do you mean students using it for learning and report writing? It is better lookup than Wikipedia because it explain topics quite pedagogically and sometimes Wikipedia is too deep. ChatGPT write at high school to lower BSc level and does not always complete answers. Furthermore, it does not seem to say from where it takes the data/knowledge so it is in that sense quite useless without significant literature study where iPad is outstanding for reading books and scientific articles.
 

PsykX

macrumors 68030
Sep 16, 2006
2,745
3,921
The closest equivalent of ChatGPT on the iPad is Siri, and of course ChatGPT is light-years ahead it's not even funny.

But the iPad can do a whole lot more - am I the only one not understanding the logical reasoning behind this thread ?
 

jwolf6589

macrumors 601
Dec 15, 2010
4,919
1,643
Colorado
I have witnessed that people in my university, and a lot of people on social media, have adopted ChatGPT into their workflow. These "co-pilots" are a crucial part of working and they live permanently on the side. You are constantly sending it ideas and editing the draft. For that to happen, you need a keyboard which makes the iPad without a keyboard useless for people working in 2023. Of course, people say you can use the iPad with a keyboard but at that point, you might as well use the MacBook instead.

What are your thoughts on iPad's place in a world of AI butlers, like ChatGPT?
My iPad Mini 6 is a great device that I use daily. I don’t have a keyboard. The iPad is far far far from worthless.
 

ninecows

macrumors 6502a
Apr 9, 2012
760
1,249
I wanted to ask ChatGPT if it will make my iPad useless, but I got this, which actually answers my question. I don't really need that AI stuff. I can actually think for my self.
3F3BC108-DE23-4F86-87EA-E2AAD12D9517.png
 

sracer

macrumors G4
Apr 9, 2010
10,405
13,290
where hip is spoken
Just out of curiosity, I interacted with ChatGPT for it to write a sermon on Colossians 3:1-17. Because of the questions that I asked of it, the results were very, very close to what I would've done. We've come a long way since Eliza.

I'm trying to understand what the OP means by ChatGPT making the iPad useless. That's like saying my iPhone makes my Kia K5 useless. o_O
 

ninecows

macrumors 6502a
Apr 9, 2012
760
1,249
Has made Google useless, not iPads.
Not really. It just summarizes what ever researching online might give you, but it throws away any sort of source criticism and wraps the results into convincing wordings.

It’s fun and entertaining, but only marginally better than many of those “I’m doing my own research (on Facebook)” people out there

Edit: Just to be more precise. Not saying it doesn't do source criticism or picks it sources carefully, but you are not involved in that process.
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.