Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Just_Kevin

macrumors member
Original poster
Jan 31, 2024
91
101
Picked up a S10 46mm last night.

I bought a S7 41mm roughly three years ago. Picked it up as a somewhat impulsive buy when Amazon had a deep discount. Hadn't looked at or tried any on in a store prior, only looked at a coworkers older larger watch. That eventually proved to be a mistake. I went with the 41mm at the time partially due to the cost and partially I thought the larger would be too big. Since this was my first smart watch and I'd gone over 20 years since wearing any watch, I wasn't sure if I'd wear it long term.

I've been telling myself I was not going to buy a new Watch until the O2 sensor functionality had returned. Had I bought the larger one back then, I probably would not have just bought a new one. I ended up buying now partially because I really wanted the larger display to combat my older eyes. Battery life was starting to be a factor, but not significantly. I've also been more attentive of how the larger watches looked on people with similar sized wrists as me and the 41mm began looking too small.

I almost bought from Amazon again, for convenience, I'm glad I didn't, it would have been a mistake. I went to the store, expecting to get a black watch with the black magnetic fake leather fine woven, whatever strap. I just happened to pick up the silver first to check the size on my wrist. It happened to have the velcro strap on it at the time. I didn't care for it, but wasn't considering one anyway. I tried the magnetic one and disliked it. It seemed comfortable enough when on and looked good, but was too much of a hassle to put on and get adjusted correctly. I tried the Milanese and ended up going with that, in slate. I still thought I was going to get the black watch, but looking at it, I decided to go with the silver. My wife and I agreed the silver makes it look more like a traditional watch. I also prefer how the bezel appears against the body. I'd read here that some other people feel the same way.

I feel I do notice the slimmer case of the S10 vs the S7. I am loving the larger screen. My eyesight is at the point I needed the glasses to see the smaller screen. With the 46mm it is easier to see without my glasses and it is also easier to interact with. I may need to go back to the store to take another look at the watch face the demo watch had. I liked the appearance, but more importantly, the complications seemed larger. I cannot find that face in the Gallery. I was/am concerned about the Milanese band catching my arm hair. So far it hasn't been much more than another band I've had.

I was surprised the store said they'd give me $105 for the S7. I kept it for now, they said I have 14 days to trade it in. I'm torn between keeping it as a spare and/or for when I'm doing yard work, working on my truck, or other activities more likely to damage the watch, vs getting a protective case I can pop on when needed.

I now fully expect the S11 to somehow be a huge leap forward and make me regret buying the S10 and not waiting for the S11.
 
Picked up a S10 46mm last night.

I bought a S7 41mm roughly three years ago. Picked it up as a somewhat impulsive buy when Amazon had a deep discount. Hadn't looked at or tried any on in a store prior, only looked at a coworkers older larger watch. That eventually proved to be a mistake. I went with the 41mm at the time partially due to the cost and partially I thought the larger would be too big. Since this was my first smart watch and I'd gone over 20 years since wearing any watch, I wasn't sure if I'd wear it long term.

I've been telling myself I was not going to buy a new Watch until the O2 sensor functionality had returned. Had I bought the larger one back then, I probably would not have just bought a new one. I ended up buying now partially because I really wanted the larger display to combat my older eyes. Battery life was starting to be a factor, but not significantly. I've also been more attentive of how the larger watches looked on people with similar sized wrists as me and the 41mm began looking too small.

I almost bought from Amazon again, for convenience, I'm glad I didn't, it would have been a mistake. I went to the store, expecting to get a black watch with the black magnetic fake leather fine woven, whatever strap. I just happened to pick up the silver first to check the size on my wrist. It happened to have the velcro strap on it at the time. I didn't care for it, but wasn't considering one anyway. I tried the magnetic one and disliked it. It seemed comfortable enough when on and looked good, but was too much of a hassle to put on and get adjusted correctly. I tried the Milanese and ended up going with that, in slate. I still thought I was going to get the black watch, but looking at it, I decided to go with the silver. My wife and I agreed the silver makes it look more like a traditional watch. I also prefer how the bezel appears against the body. I'd read here that some other people feel the same way.

I feel I do notice the slimmer case of the S10 vs the S7. I am loving the larger screen. My eyesight is at the point I needed the glasses to see the smaller screen. With the 46mm it is easier to see without my glasses and it is also easier to interact with. I may need to go back to the store to take another look at the watch face the demo watch had. I liked the appearance, but more importantly, the complications seemed larger. I cannot find that face in the Gallery. I was/am concerned about the Milanese band catching my arm hair. So far it hasn't been much more than another band I've had.

I was surprised the store said they'd give me $105 for the S7. I kept it for now, they said I have 14 days to trade it in. I'm torn between keeping it as a spare and/or for when I'm doing yard work, working on my truck, or other activities more likely to damage the watch, vs getting a protective case I can pop on when needed.

I now fully expect the S11 to somehow be a huge leap forward and make me regret buying the S10 and not waiting for the S11.
New watches have never been a huge leap forward just like iPhones. If you use that thought process then the watch 12 would be a huge leap over the 11.. Just buy a watch if you want it, don't wonder if the next version is better..
 
S11 will probably only add blood pressure, keep the same design and not much else. I wouldn't expect a big leap forward. You're still within the return period for the S10.
 
S11 will probably only add blood pressure, keep the same design and not much else. I wouldn't expect a big leap forward. You're still within the return period for the S10.
Blood pressure does interest me, I’ve been told mine is borderline high. No way I’m returning the S10 and going back to the smaller screen. Just about a day in on the larger screen and I’m hooked. If the S11 does have BP, I’ll consider trading in the 10 at that point.


If eyesight is a concern, you should give the Ultra a try. I know the S10 screen has a slightly larger surface area, but the flat screen on the Ultra is easier to read than the curved screen, plus I believe the Ultra screen is brighter.
I did look at the Ultra, too much bulk, too expensive.
 
New watches have never been a huge leap forward just like iPhones. If you use that thought process then the watch 12 would be a huge leap over the 11.. Just buy a watch if you want it, don't wonder if the next version is better..

So much this. And not just Watch, any computational device.

Phrased in a different way: the X version of Widget will be obsolete the minute you walk out the door with one because the next one with the faster/bigger processor, better something is already in development, will be constantly chasing/FOMO. And when the next version is very meh, "I waited all this time for that??".

No way I’m returning the S10 and going back to the smaller screen. Just about a day in on the larger screen and I’m hooked. If the S11 does have BP, I’ll consider trading in the 10 at that point.

Sound like you made the right decision and have the right attitude. "Just do it" and not worry about FOMO (read: do trade in) if any major upgrades with 11.

In my case, would be nice to have a thinner and bigger display 10, but my SE is still going strong so no real need to upgrade at this time. Getting close to battery replacement time, so might last until 11, wait and see time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BugeyeSTI
Blood pressure does interest me, I’ve been told mine is borderline high. No way I’m returning the S10 and going back to the smaller screen. Just about a day in on the larger screen and I’m hooked. If the S11 does have BP, I’ll consider trading in the 10 at that point.

If your blood pressure is borderline high, a watch isn't the answer you need. You need to be getting a real blood pressure cuff. The watch can only warn you that your numbers might be bad. Using it as your blood pressure monitor isn't the best idea.
 
Last edited:
Wouldn't measuring your blood pressure regularly with cuffs also show any trends? Not sure what you're expecting the watch to do differently.
I see the benefit of AW monitoring throughout the day (or even over 24 hours) vs once every day or so with a BP machine (which takes more effort to remember and do). Probably both in their own way as most useful.
 
Considering the AW10 is a new design, I wouldn't worry about any redesigns until AW12, and I wonder if the AW11 even releases this year, or if they release the AWU3, and the SE, and then alternate release years from here on out. There isn't really much space to go anywhere new with the Apple Watch beyond making it thinner, bigger screen, bigger watches at this point I wouldn't think, so it would make sense that those products are updated semi-annually someday.
 
Picked up a S10 46mm last night.

I bought a S7 41mm roughly three years ago. Picked it up as a somewhat impulsive buy when Amazon had a deep discount. Hadn't looked at or tried any on in a store prior, only looked at a coworkers older larger watch. That eventually proved to be a mistake. I went with the 41mm at the time partially due to the cost and partially I thought the larger would be too big. Since this was my first smart watch and I'd gone over 20 years since wearing any watch, I wasn't sure if I'd wear it long term.

I've been telling myself I was not going to buy a new Watch until the O2 sensor functionality had returned. Had I bought the larger one back then, I probably would not have just bought a new one. I ended up buying now partially because I really wanted the larger display to combat my older eyes. Battery life was starting to be a factor, but not significantly. I've also been more attentive of how the larger watches looked on people with similar sized wrists as me and the 41mm began looking too small.

I almost bought from Amazon again, for convenience, I'm glad I didn't, it would have been a mistake. I went to the store, expecting to get a black watch with the black magnetic fake leather fine woven, whatever strap. I just happened to pick up the silver first to check the size on my wrist. It happened to have the velcro strap on it at the time. I didn't care for it, but wasn't considering one anyway. I tried the magnetic one and disliked it. It seemed comfortable enough when on and looked good, but was too much of a hassle to put on and get adjusted correctly. I tried the Milanese and ended up going with that, in slate. I still thought I was going to get the black watch, but looking at it, I decided to go with the silver. My wife and I agreed the silver makes it look more like a traditional watch. I also prefer how the bezel appears against the body. I'd read here that some other people feel the same way.

I feel I do notice the slimmer case of the S10 vs the S7. I am loving the larger screen. My eyesight is at the point I needed the glasses to see the smaller screen. With the 46mm it is easier to see without my glasses and it is also easier to interact with. I may need to go back to the store to take another look at the watch face the demo watch had. I liked the appearance, but more importantly, the complications seemed larger. I cannot find that face in the Gallery. I was/am concerned about the Milanese band catching my arm hair. So far it hasn't been much more than another band I've had.

I was surprised the store said they'd give me $105 for the S7. I kept it for now, they said I have 14 days to trade it in. I'm torn between keeping it as a spare and/or for when I'm doing yard work, working on my truck, or other activities more likely to damage the watch, vs getting a protective case I can pop on when needed.

I now fully expect the S11 to somehow be a huge leap forward and make me regret buying the S10 and not waiting for the S11.
In short, you don't have to worry about Apple making big changes to Watch with Series 11, 12 or 13.

The longer explanation is that no business with a product as uniquely successful as Apple Watch will ever spend the r&d to make big changes from one year to the next.

Even after all these years, almost 10, no competitor has a product that in any significant way is stealing market shares from Watch.

The only genuinely big change we've ever gotten for Watch was Series 4. But Series 4 was the culmination of several years of wildly expensive r&d to get a promising product to reach maturity and become the best-seller consumer tech icon that we know it as today.

The only other larger change was the first generation Apple Watch Ultra. But, at its core, it's still 1/1 built on the same principles as Series 4. It's really just a "Pro/Max" spin-off of Watch.

You can safely keep your Series 10. Apple will, at best, improve the internals modestly, or alter the finish and dimensions incrementally.

Watch simply isn't iPhone, Mac, or AirPods, and doesn't have to stack up against any of the fierce competition that characterize those markets.

Capitalism doesn't lead to innovation or advances when a company sits on an (indirect) monopoly. Apple can safely rest on its Apple Watch laurels and just watch the money roll in, so that's what it's doing.

We aren't getting a second Series 4 "moment".
 
  • Like
Reactions: I7guy
If eyesight is a concern, you should give the Ultra a try. I know the S10 screen has a slightly larger surface area, but the flat screen on the Ultra is easier to read than the curved screen, plus I believe the Ultra screen is brighter.

Apple is still failing to optimize the size of its fonts for people with less than perfect vision. There are areas where data is displayed and the font only uses a small amount of the space.
 
Last edited:
Wouldn't measuring your blood pressure regularly with cuffs also show any trends? Not sure what you're expecting the watch to do differently.

I see the benefit of AW monitoring throughout the day (or even over 24 hours) vs once every day or so with a BP machine (which takes more effort to remember and do). Probably both in their own way as most useful.
If I was better about taking the time to use it the way it’s supposed to be done, yes. Perhaps the watch would be able to take readings when I’m already at rest. Perhaps it could also be helpful in reminding me to “take a step away” when I get frustrated at work? Until/if it releases, I won’t know.

I was just using BP as an example of what I could see myself wanting to upgrade for next.
 
I had a S7 and upgraded to a S9. The S7 actually ran better than the S9. It was a lot quicker on responses and the actions were a lot smoother. The 9 does have the 02 sensor so I'm sticking with the 9 until they get that figured out.
 
I considered picking up the S9 before the O2 was disabled. I didn't think the ban would go on this long. I'm still slightly annoyed over losing it, but the larger display makes up for it. I was surprised to see the O2 app still listed on the Watch. That's a little bit like salt in the wound.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Andy_2341
I kept it for now, they said I have 14 days to trade it in. I'm torn between keeping it as a spare and/or for when I'm doing yard work, working on my truck, or other activities more likely to damage the watch
It’s totally your choice but since you brought it up, I’d take the trade in. That’s guaranteed dollars that are on the table. Think of it this way, if you bought the AW10 and had $105 in your pocket, would you spend it to buy a 7? If you can say yes, then keep it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jdoll021
It’s totally your choice but since you brought it up, I’d take the trade in. That’s guaranteed dollars that are on the table. Think of it this way, if you bought the AW10 and had $105 in your pocket, would you spend it to buy a 7? If you can say yes, then keep it.

I see your point. Like I said, the benefit of keeping it is when I know I'll be doing work with a greater likelihood of the Watch getting damaged, I can use the S7. I ordered a protective cover for the S10. If I think that will do the trick,I will likely keep that and then trade in the S7. I don't want the cover on all the time.
 
Whenever I get a new Apple Watch, I always keep the older one as you said, as a backup and for around the house, yard, shower, etc.
 
Haha Congrats on your new purchase. The title of this thread should read "I brought a new watch... Hurray for Apple".

One thing though. the next watch due for release in Sep 2025 won't be a huge leap forward. It might only be a small puddle jump if you ask most of the people here.
 
Haha Congrats on your new purchase. The title of this thread should read "I brought a new watch... Hurray for Apple".

One thing though. the next watch due for release in Sep 2025 won't be a huge leap forward. It might only be a small puddle jump if you ask most of the people here.
It could have Blood Pressure Sensor which would be a BIG DEAL for a lot of people, myself included, even though I have the 10 now, I would deff upgrade for that reason, and that reason alone.
 
If eyesight is a concern, you should give the Ultra a try. I know the S10 screen has a slightly larger surface area, but the flat screen on the Ultra is easier to read than the curved screen, plus I believe the Ultra screen is brighter.
It's the reason I went with the Ultra. It's probably a lot bigger of a watch than I'd normally get, but at least I can see everything on the screen. The extra battery life is nice too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Night Spring
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.