Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

harrisonjr98

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Dec 15, 2019
347
200
Hey all! I have an external drive that I'm putting photos on. The drive is formatted as exFAT to use on both mac and PC. After organizing them on my mac, I was using the drive on my PC and noticed that "Properties" (the windows equivalent of "get info" in Finder, basically) was showing usually double the amount of files actually in the folder! So I ticked the "show hidden items" button in Windows and bam, there's a bunch of files with identical names to each of my photos, but hidden, starting with a period, and 4KB each - no more, no less. I included a picture below of how they appear in File Explorer on windows. I *cannot* see these files in the Finder on macOS, even by enabling hidden files, but I can see them on windows. I assume they're thumbnails or something like that - is this something that macOS does? Pictures below, any help appreciated.

hidden files.jpg
 
I believe, exFAT file system cannot natively read macOS's metadata, so macOS adds those hidden files, so it can later "assemble" the files back.
 
I believe, exFAT file system cannot natively read macOS's metadata, so macOS adds those hidden files, so it can later "assemble" the files back.
Hmm. Is this only with image files? I also have music on that drive and there’s no hidden files. If I were to ever move the files to an APFS drive, would everything be good or would it move them without metadata?
 
Well, that should work for all media files. That means I'm probably wrong in this exact instance.
And I don't have other guesses.
 
Those are not thumbnails, those are resource fork files store as a separate file, more info on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_fork

You can safely delete them if the related file is a video or an image.
So if you don't mind me asking, if you know a lot about this kind of thing, what might've led macOS to generate resource forks for my photo library but not my music library?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.