What do yo want the external HD for?
to back up my files if i do a clean install
I use them both. Time Capsule = long term backups. External drive = for doing things like clean installs. I use SuperDuper to make a copy of my Mac to the external drive before doing the clean install, and then restore from that.
For me, restoring from an external drive is a gazillion times faster than restoring from Time Capsule (even when connected directly via ethernet).
Based on what you keep on your Mac, it may entirely be overkill.I doubt all that is necessary (even if somewhat faster); it seems like overkill to me.
Based on what you keep on your Mac, it may entirely be overkill.
I have over 200GB of music, photos, videos and virtual machines. Last time I tried Time Capsule, it took about 8 hours to restore everything. With an external drive, it takes a little over an hour. To me, that's "significantly faster", not "somewhat faster". But to each their own.
2nd gen. Glad to know they're faster now!Wow, what TC model do you own? Because I know that the third generation model along with Snow Leoaprd improved speeds drastically. I have roughly the same amount of media as you do but it surely didn't take me 8 hours to restore...Maybe a couple of hours I think.
I use them both. Time Capsule = long term backups. External drive = for doing things like clean installs. I use SuperDuper to make a copy of my Mac to the external drive before doing the clean install, and then restore from that.
For me, restoring from an external drive is a gazillion times faster than restoring from Time Capsule (even when connected directly via ethernet).