Hi All! I purchased the HomePod and ended up returning it. I've owned the Sonos system and the Amazon Echo. My review is comparing the three:
1) The Sonos system sounds great! But the Alexa microphone is weak and has trouble hearing you.
2) The Amazon Echo listens perfectly and gives great responses to inquires. The speaker is "ok".
3) The HomePod suffered on all fronts. The sound was too "bassy" on any content I played on it. It was like the speaker was over compensating for other faults. Siri was not very functional for me. I have Philips Hue system and Siri didn't work well with it. The alarm functionality was ok. It functioned but getting snooze to work correctly was messed up.
I donated the Sonos system I had to a friend (tired of yelling at Alexa. I returned the HomePod because overall it was a terrible smart speaker system. I upgraded to the Amazon Echo plus (upgraded version of the Echo).
A few final words on the HomePod:
1) Give users the ability to control the equalizer on all content coming out of the sonos. So audiobooks are more treble (less bass and easier to hear without muddled sound). OR make the equalizer so 'smart' that it changes with the content (Sonos did this well).
2) A smarter system that handles alarms, Philips hue system and just "works" (Siri currently does not "just work").
3) Fix the overall quality of the speakers sound. Right now I feel that the "quality of tone" is best out of the sonos for my ears. It balances well the bass and treble and makes the music sound amazing. HomePod sound did not stand out to me other than being over bassy.
If the HomePod could take the echos smart system (Alexa) and the sonos sound they would have a winning speaker and I would buy 3 of them immediately. At the moment Amazon is getting my money.
Of course, these are all my opinions. I'm curious to see if others agree with my assessment. I'm a huge apple fan boy.
1) The Sonos system sounds great! But the Alexa microphone is weak and has trouble hearing you.
2) The Amazon Echo listens perfectly and gives great responses to inquires. The speaker is "ok".
3) The HomePod suffered on all fronts. The sound was too "bassy" on any content I played on it. It was like the speaker was over compensating for other faults. Siri was not very functional for me. I have Philips Hue system and Siri didn't work well with it. The alarm functionality was ok. It functioned but getting snooze to work correctly was messed up.
I donated the Sonos system I had to a friend (tired of yelling at Alexa. I returned the HomePod because overall it was a terrible smart speaker system. I upgraded to the Amazon Echo plus (upgraded version of the Echo).
A few final words on the HomePod:
1) Give users the ability to control the equalizer on all content coming out of the sonos. So audiobooks are more treble (less bass and easier to hear without muddled sound). OR make the equalizer so 'smart' that it changes with the content (Sonos did this well).
2) A smarter system that handles alarms, Philips hue system and just "works" (Siri currently does not "just work").
3) Fix the overall quality of the speakers sound. Right now I feel that the "quality of tone" is best out of the sonos for my ears. It balances well the bass and treble and makes the music sound amazing. HomePod sound did not stand out to me other than being over bassy.
If the HomePod could take the echos smart system (Alexa) and the sonos sound they would have a winning speaker and I would buy 3 of them immediately. At the moment Amazon is getting my money.
Of course, these are all my opinions. I'm curious to see if others agree with my assessment. I'm a huge apple fan boy.