Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

gtackett

macrumors newbie
Original poster
May 19, 2011
25
0
USA
In a PCIe gen 2 4x slot in my Mac Pro 4,1 (flashed as 5,1) I have the pictured OWC SSD which uses on-board Marvell RAID 0 Hardware and two OWC 60 GB SSD “blades“ to present a very fast 60 GB to the Mac.
2F979851-2BAC-4C69-A902-7BF7C905DA32.jpeg

The original owner of this Mac joined this with a 1 TB 7200 rpm SATA 3G to produce a pretty impressive roll-your-own Fusion Drive (jhfs+ file system).

Since both the SSD and rotating drive are aging, and newer/faster tech is available, I’d like to upgrade somehow without losing capacity or performance.

I recently tried a OWC Accelsior S with a 1 TB Electra 6G SSD installed in a 16x slot and was unhappy to find that it underperformed the Fusion Drive I described, using several benchmarks.

So I’m looking for alternatives that will be at least as fast as the existing Fusion combo, with more than 1 TB capacity, that won’t cost me more than the $200 I shelled out to OWC. (Their own tech rep couldn’t find anything in their current product line that he thought would even equal these requirements, without costing a great deal more.)

I can provide some benchmark figures from ATTO or other benchmarks, if anyone wants to see them.

(I'd probably settle for either replacing the two 60 GB blades with something a lot larger. But OWC says these blades, no longer available from them, used a proprietary design, so I'd have to buy them used, or replace the whole assembly with a larger-capacity SSD that would be just as fast.)
 
It's just a RAID-0 of two SATA 600 blades. Any good NVMe M.2 blade, like Samsung 970 PRO will run around it.
 
I have an OWC Accelsior S and a NVMe PCIe card in a 5,1. You can easily see the difference. The NVMe drive is hugely faster. I’d see about either upgrading the Marvell card or just buying a cheap Chinese NVMe card.
 
This old Mac Pro can’t directly use NVMe M.2, can it? I know there are PCIe gen 2 adapters for NVMe but don’t really know what to shop for, or whether I should still use two blades and Hardware RAID 0, or just one blade?
 
Read the first post of the thread below:

 
Thanks! This looks very helpful and gives me some confidence that what I want can be done at an affordable price.

The post is so loaded with detail, though, that sifting through it to select what I need, will be hard. Anyone willing to lend a hand selecting appropriate components for an actual configuration or two, suitable for my 4,1>5,1 running 10.13.6?

* Under $300 US, if possible
* 1 TB min.
* Bootable
* PCIe gen.2 (I have open 16x and 4x slots)

We can discuss other system details and desired performance as needed.
 
Last edited:
Thanks! This looks very helpful and gives me some confidence that what I want can be done at an affordable price.

The post is so loaded with detail, though, that sifting through it to select what I need, will be hard. Anyone willing to lend a hand selecting appropriate components for an actual configuration or two, suitable for my 4,1>5,1 running 10.13.6?

* Under $300 US, if possible
* 1 TB min.
* Bootable
* PCIe gen.2 (I have open 16x and 4x slots)

We can discuss other system details and desired performance as needed.

Any suggestions?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.