iPad Pro Using my iPad as a 'thin client'?

[imdropbear]

Hi guys,

I need your advice on something I want to do.\

I have an iPad Pro and a 14 inch MBP.

Outside of work, I mostly use my iPad and the MBP is used mostly stationary on my desk. Sometimes I do use it on the couch. So far no problem.

Last week my kid managed to damage the screen of my MBP. Mostly not an issue (since it was used stationary with external displays most of the time anyway) but my couch sessions are currently not possible.

My options:

(A) Get the screen repaired (up to 800€ last time I checked)

(B) Get a cheap MBA (800-900€)

Since my device is fully functional apart from the screen, I think option (B) seems more attractive to me. That way I would have 2 devices.

But after thinking about it a while, I was coming up with another idea:

(C) Get a Magic Keyboard (350€) for my iPad Pro and then use macOS' Screen Mirroring Feature to use the iPad Pro as an external Screen and then use my iPad Pro with its magic keyboard as a laptop.

Not only would this be the cheapest solution, it would also fit my "workflow" best. I'd love if my MBP could just stay stationary and I would be able to just use my iPad elsewhere.

I already used the screen mirroring feature to do that occasionally in the past but without a trackpad (had to use my external Magic Trackpad) and just the on-screen keyboard on the iPad that wasn't quite what I was looking for. Otherwise I was happy with the solution (latency is good enough for what I was doing).

There are a few problems with this solution. Maybe someone can help me out?

1. The only way to initiate the Sidecar session is from the MBP. So if I didn't want to walk up to my desk to start it, I would have to use something like Splashtop to connect to the MBP first to initiate the screen mirroring before being able to use my iPad. This works but isn't exactly a nice way of doing it. Is there a better solution for this? Ideally I would like to be able to wake my MBP from sleep with this but as far as I'm aware I would have to build some kind of custom solution for this?
2. Normally (unlike the keyboard), the trackpad of the magic keyboard can't be used to control the cursor of my MBP, correct? I have found this workaround, but since I don't have a magic keyboard yet, I can't test if this still works. Anyone knows? If it does not: Is there any way to directly connect the magic keyboard to my MBP (I assume not) and if there isn't, is there a third party keyboard like the magic keyboard that can do this? (I really don't want to tape a Logitech K400 to my iPad even though that would be *exactly* what I need...)

Thanks a lot!

Of course ideal would be option (D) which would be Apple allowing macOS to be installed on iPads, but... yeah. Let's stick with the doable ones...

 

[BeatCrazy]

1. Normally (unlike the keyboard), the trackpad of the magic keyboard can't be used to control the cursor of my MBP, correct? I have found this workaround, but since I don't have a magic keyboard yet, I can't test if this still works. Anyone knows? If it does not: Is there any way to directly connect the magic keyboard to my MBP (I assume not) and if there isn't, is there a third party keyboard like the magic keyboard that can do this? (I really don't want to tape a Logitech K400 to my iPad even though that would be *exactly* what I need...)

I could never get that workaround to function correctly or consistently. You will end up frustrated.

I'd advise just buying an external display for your MBP.

 

[imdropbear]

I have external displays, that's not the issue.

I just would like to be able to switch to my MBP on the couch or in the garden, ideally without even having to pull the MBP out of its dock. That's also a reason why I would prefer a cheap MBA over actually repairing the screen (also, I'd prefer my kids destroying an MBA over my MBP ... again).

But if this workaround isn't working reliably and there aren't any other workarounds or alternative products either, that sucks... That's the only hurdle I see that I may not be able to overcome.

Is at least the keyboard working reliably? Having to use an external mouse/trackpad would still suck though... Maybe getting an MBA is better then. I would love to make my iPad the only device I actually need though...

The Apple pencil doesn't work as an input device for the MBP while screen mirroring to the iPad either, does it?

 

[Digitalguy]

Why do you want to use Sidecar and not a remote desktop software? You mention Splashtop. Maybe because it's not good enough? There are other apps, some are even better, although they work similarly.

 

[Rafterman]

Why do you want to use Sidecar and not a remote desktop software? You mention Splashtop. Maybe because it's not good enough? There are other apps, some are even better, although they work similarly.

Like Jump. I've used that for years.

 

[chabig]

Maybe someone can help me out?

Some people will recommend TeamViewer, but I really like Screens. It's in the App Store with a subscription, which I think is fine, as the app receives great support and regular updates. If you want to connect from out of your home, they also provide a service that tracks your IP address so you can connect remotely.

‎Screens 5: VNC Remote Desktop

‎Easily control your Mac, Windows PC, Linux PC, or Raspberry Pi from anywhere, whether you're in your living room, a local coffee shop, or on the other side of the world. Screens is the versatile remote desktop solution you can rely on for speed, security, and reliability, offering seamless...

apps.apple.com

 

[Shirasaki]

I just use Splashtop to connect to my Mac when needed. AFAIK you cannot initiate a connection from iPad so I never even bother to use it aside from trying it out as a novel feature (which was already available through third party software such as duet before).

 

[imdropbear]

You can initiate Splashtop sessions from the iPad remotely.

The reason I wanted to use Sidecar and not remote access software is that it felt a lot more… “native“. it automatically has the correct resolution for the iPad and everything looks all nice and crisp.

TeamViewer and Splashtop can‘t do that, they just take the resolution of my MBP which can‘t be displayed natively on the iPad. I would probably have to set up some kind of “virtual display“ on my MBP with my iPad’s resolution and then use Splashtop to access that.

But the video quality over Splashtop is just noticably worse than what Sidecar has to offer (looks really compressed and the colors washed out). Is Jump or Screens better on that regard? Might give them a try.

 

[Digitalguy]

You can initiate Splashtop sessions from the iPad remotely.

The reason I wanted to use Sidecar and not remote access software is that it felt a lot more… “native“. it automatically has the correct resolution for the iPad and everything looks all nice and crisp.

TeamViewer and Splashtop can‘t do that, they just take the resolution of my MBP which can‘t be displayed natively on the iPad. I would probably have to set up some kind of “virtual display“ on my MBP with my iPad’s resolution and then use Splashtop to access that.

But the video quality over Splashtop is just noticably worse than what Sidecar has to offer (looks really compressed and the colors washed out). Is Jump or Screens better on that regard? Might give them a try.

I was sure it was mainly a matter of resolution and aspect ratio....
Yes, Jump Desktop is the best, you can choose your resolution. Set to use retina resolution and set 4:3 aspect ration resolution like 1600:1200 and voilà.
The video quality in Splashtop is worse because it does not use retina...

 

[BeatCrazy]

I have external displays, that's not the issue.

I just would like to be able to switch to my MBP on the couch or in the garden, ideally without even having to pull the MBP out of its dock. That's also a reason why I would prefer a cheap MBA over actually repairing the screen (also, I'd prefer my kids destroying an MBA over my MBP ... again).

But if this workaround isn't working reliably and there aren't any other workarounds or alternative products either, that sucks... That's the only hurdle I see that I may not be able to overcome.

Is at least the keyboard working reliably? Having to use an external mouse/trackpad would still suck though... Maybe getting an MBA is better then. I would love to make my iPad the only device I actually need though...

The Apple pencil doesn't work as an input device for the MBP while screen mirroring to the iPad either, does it?

Yes, the Apple pencil works as an input device when the iPad is mirroring a Mac. But I never figured out how to right-click with just the Apple Pencil.

I have attempted the same thing you're after, and ultimately gave up. Even though I have ridiculously fast and stable Wi-Fi access point in the same room as the devices, it's just an unreliable connection. Has to do with sleep/wake, I suppose. I spent more time reconnecting and doing other one-off activities compared to actually getting the iPad to function as expected.

 

[CarAnalogy]

OK so first thing to do, if you haven't read this article check this out because he's doing something similar:

MacPad: How I Created the Hybrid Mac-iPad Laptop and Tablet That Apple Won’t Make

It all started because I wanted a better keyboard for my Vision Pro. I had no idea that, in looking for one, I’d accidentally create the hybrid Apple computer of my dreams. As I quickly discovered after working on the Vision Pro daily, you can get by without an external trackpad, but a keyboard is

www.macstories.net

My personal opinion, don't spend the money on a half fix. That Magic Keyboard alone is almost half the display repair.

I would either use the MBP at your desk with an external display, or try to use the iPad Pro directly with a cheaper external keyboard and mouse.

I have the exact same two devices. I'm not sure you'd be pleased going back to an Air after the Pro. Personally my eyes don't like working on 60Hz displays anymore (my external display is also high refresh rate.)

That's a dilly of a pickle there. Maybe just try to make it through until you can replace the MBP.

 

[Chancha]

Like Jump. I've used that for years.

I second the notion of using Jump Desktop. Been using it on an iPad Pro M1 12.9" with Magic KB, even accessing from across the globe (UK to Asia and back), it works flawlessly. Out of the VNC client iOS apps I have tried, this is a rare one that supports touch, trackpad (on MKB), and external bluetooth mouse all without issues.

But I also have to concur with an above comment saying the Magic KB alone costs too much of a purchase, when the original scenario was to avoid the 800 Euro MBP screen repair. The OP wants a couch solution so I am not sure if a better alternative exists though.

 

[imdropbear]

Wow, thanks for the link. *That* is what I really want. I may consider just doing exactly that but don‘t exactly have the tools to engineer the proper attachments for the iPad like he did.

 

[heretiq]

Wow, thanks for the link. *That* is what I really want. I may consider just doing exactly that but don‘t exactly have the tools to engineer the proper attachments for the iPad like he did.

That MacPad article is ingenious but I don’t think you need to go all the way like Viticci did to get the results you’re looking for. The section on “Using Sidecar to Turn an iPad into a Mac Display” discussed a modified version of Sidecar Launcher shortcut that allows you to initiate the Mac connection from your iPad.

 

[KPOM]

Like Jump. I've used that for years.

I like Jump as well, though I notice that my MacBook Pro sometimes doesn’t connect and I have to try again a few minutes later. It’s the same with Parallels Access. Does the Mac only ping the network looking for remote access apps periodically?

 

[imdropbear]

That MacPad article is ingenious but I don’t think you need to go all the way like Viticci did to get the results you’re looking for. The section on “Using Sidecar to Turn an iPad into a Mac Display” discussed a modified version of Sidecar Launcher shortcut that allows you to initiate the Mac connection from your iPad.

This still leaves the issue of the magic trackpad not properly/consistently working with Universal Access/Sidecar.

 

[heretiq]

This still leaves the issue of the magic trackpad not properly/consistently working with Universal Access/Sidecar.

Might this solution on the Apple Support forum address the issue for you?

 

[imdropbear]

Might this solution on the Apple Support forum address the issue for you?

It does address the issue, that‘s why I linked to it in my post. :–)

Someone here said it wouldn‘t work reliably/consistently. I might just buy the magic keyboard and try it out though…

Since my display is broken answay, I might also try to remove it like in the link above. Anyone knows if this is an easy thing to do or do I risk damaging my MBP (excluding the display of course)

 

[Amplelink]

I completely get the appeal of wanting to use the iPad in these circumstances, but you're way better off with an MBA. It'll do everything you need and you won't have to make any compromises. Unless of course you use the Apple Pencil.

 

[Rafterman]

I like Jump as well, though I notice that my MacBook Pro sometimes doesn’t connect and I have to try again a few minutes later. It’s the same with Parallels Access. Does the Mac only ping the network looking for remote access apps periodically?

That's been a bug in Mac remote desktop for years. If you unload/reload the screensharing service, it comes back, at least for a while.

echo 'pawword' | sudo -S launchctl unload /System/Library/LaunchDaemons/com.apple.screensharing.plist

echo 'password' | sudo -S launchctl load -w /System/Library/LaunchDaemons/com.apple.screensharing.plist

 

[Digitalguy]

It does address the issue, that‘s why I linked to it in my post. :–)

Someone here said it wouldn‘t work reliably/consistently. I might just buy the magic keyboard and try it out though…

Since my display is broken answay, I might also try to remove it like in the link above. Anyone knows if this is an easy thing to do or do I risk damaging my MBP (excluding the display of course)

I tried it and it does not work, you cannot use Sidecar and Universal Control at the same time with the same iPad. At least if that's what this solutions is trying to achieve

 

[heretiq]

I tried it and it does not work, you cannot use Sidecar and Universal Control at the same time with the same iPad. At least if that's what this solutions is trying to achieve

Not sure of the exact use case but this MR article addresses the topic including how to switch between Sidecar and UC on the same iPad. Hope it helps.

 

[Digitalguy]

Not sure of the exact use case but this MR article addresses the topic including how to switch between Sidecar and UC on the same iPad. Hope it helps.

yeah but that's the point you can you one or the other, not both at the same time on the same iPad

 

[Allen_Wentz]

Hi guys,

I need your advice on something I want to do.\

I have an iPad Pro and a 14 inch MBP.

Outside of work, I mostly use my iPad and the MBP is used mostly stationary on my desk. Sometimes I do use it on the couch. So far no problem.

Last week my kid managed to damage the screen of my MBP. Mostly not an issue (since it was used stationary with external displays most of the time anyway) but my couch sessions are currently not possible.

My options:

(A) Get the screen repaired (up to 800€ last time I checked)

(B) Get a cheap MBA (800-900€)

Since my device is fully functional apart from the screen, I think option (B) seems more attractive to me. That way I would have 2 devices.

But after thinking about it a while, I was coming up with another idea:

(C) Get a Magic Keyboard (350€) for my iPad Pro and then use macOS' Screen Mirroring Feature to use the iPad Pro as an external Screen and then use my iPad Pro with its magic keyboard as a laptop.

Not only would this be the cheapest solution, it would also fit my "workflow" best. I'd love if my MBP could just stay stationary and I would be able to just use my iPad elsewhere.

I already used the screen mirroring feature to do that occasionally in the past but without a trackpad (had to use my external Magic Trackpad) and just the on-screen keyboard on the iPad that wasn't quite what I was looking for. Otherwise I was happy with the solution (latency is good enough for what I was doing).

There are a few problems with this solution. Maybe someone can help me out?

1. The only way to initiate the Sidecar session is from the MBP. So if I didn't want to walk up to my desk to start it, I would have to use something like Splashtop to connect to the MBP first to initiate the screen mirroring before being able to use my iPad. This works but isn't exactly a nice way of doing it. Is there a better solution for this? Ideally I would like to be able to wake my MBP from sleep with this but as far as I'm aware I would have to build some kind of custom solution for this?
2. Normally (unlike the keyboard), the trackpad of the magic keyboard can't be used to control the cursor of my MBP, correct? I have found this workaround, but since I don't have a magic keyboard yet, I can't test if this still works. Anyone knows? If it does not: Is there any way to directly connect the magic keyboard to my MBP (I assume not) and if there isn't, is there a third party keyboard like the magic keyboard that can do this? (I really don't want to tape a Logitech K400 to my iPad even though that would be *exactly* what I need...)

Thanks a lot!

Of course ideal would be option (D) which would be Apple allowing macOS to be installed on iPads, but... yeah. Let's stick with the doable ones...

Personally I would buy an MBA: M2 or M3. They are being offered at bargain pricing now. For couch usage the very lame RAM in a base model will be tolerable since you still have the sessile MBP.