Well I have a maxed a 2018- Mini i7 - and 2018 i5. Hadn't considered the 64GB expansion but I'm interested. And yes, as you say, to keep a Mojave platform that 2018 generation that's the end o' the line; ) - As far as my need for
a Silicon... i do need to have a newest or newer OS machine in the mix because of some browsers and apps becoming incompatible with Mojave. Hence i started looking at them and did order (returnable) an Apple $1099 refurb deal on an M2 Pro w/ 16gb RAM. Then, seeing M1s floating around refurbed for $500 - 600 started thinking twice. What i'm considering is making an M series Mini my "main' studio computer for recording, (and web-based stuff..browsers, uploads/downloads) but having the Intel machine tied in somehow, primarily for editing on that older app.
Honestly if I could stay on Mojave forever I'd be perfectly happy-- but...now with the change in architecture of all OS's and newer apps not Intel compatible.. i have to have at least one box running a current OS now; )
after that...it's just not feasible
I have a maxed out 2014 MacBook Air for Mojave. I also have a maxed out 2015 MacBook Air and I'm debating if I want to upgrade myself over (the 2014 is in better physical shape) or if the performance benefit for what I'd be using it for (32-bit binaries and apps that are not and never will be optimized for HiDPI/retina displays). I'm guessing Intel HD 5000 vs 6000 isn't that large of a bump, nor is an Ultrabook Haswell i7 vs. an Ultrabook Broadwell i7, especially since I'm running software that is that old if not older. I guess it depends on the need for speed for Mojave. I can't imagine 2018 Mac minis won't be great though; especially if you've got a decent amount of RAM and aren't needing a discrete GPU for anything.
As for M1 vs. M2 vs. M2 Pro on a Mac mini, I'd consider the following:
- Do you need more than two Thunderbolt ports and more than two displays being output? If so, M2 Pro is your only option.
- Is the goal to have something newer so that it is more likely to last longer? If so, don't get an M1.
- Do you need more than 24GB of RAM? If so, M2 Pro is your only option.
- Is 16GB of RAM too small? If so, don't get an M1.
- Would an M1 Mac mini actually serve your needs? If so, then anything else will cost you more with the only current benefit being future proofing.
Regardless, I wouldn't get an M1 (or M2) with only 8GB of RAM and I especially wouldn't get an M2 with only 256GB of storage, nor an M2 with only 512GB of storage. In general, I'd try to get as much RAM and storage as you can reasonably afford on whatever it is you get because you can't upgrade it later. Otherwise, only you can answer which Mac mini best suits your needs.
Makes sense to me... Just curious, and I know it's a subjective choice but if it were you, would you go the extra $$
for the M2 Pro as described...or try to save the $$ on a recent vintage refurb or new old stock, M1 Mini?
I'd probably do one of three options:
- M1 16GB RAM; 1TB or 2TB
- M2 24GB RAM; 1TB or 2TB
- M2 Pro (10 CPU Cores; 16 GPU Cores); 32GB RAM; 1-4TB
And the two determining factors would be "how beefy do I need this sucker to be" and "am I cool with spending less (and possibly having less support time) for the M1 or do I want the newer generation".