Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Cham2000

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Mar 11, 2022
426
216
I keep reading messages about mini-LED and Promotion. What is it all about? What is mini-LED? And what is Promotion? Why these features are good things to have on a desktop display? What are their advantages over display that don't have mini-LED and Promotion? Should I really care about mini-LED and Promotion before buying the Studio Display (which doesn't have these features)?
 

solouki

macrumors 6502
Jan 5, 2017
339
213
I keep reading messages about mini-LED and Promotion. What is it all about? What is mini-LED? And what is Promotion? Why these features are good things to have on a desktop display? What are their advantages over display that don't have mini-LED and Promotion? Should I really care about mini-LED and Promotion before buying the Studio Display (which doesn't have these features)?
Hi Cham2000,

I'm no expert, but since your query hasn't attracted any experts to answer it, I'll attempt a simple explanation.

Computer monitors are often, at least in the recent past, LCD displays (Liquid Crystal Display). Liquid crystals make up the pixels and are used to block light in varying amounts passing through the pixels from the backplane. The backplane is typically lit by a bank of LED (Light Emitting Diode) lights with the light being funneled to the pixels, often by fiber optics. [Sometimes, in the past, these LCD displays have been called LED displays, but technically they should be called LCD displays.]

A regular LCD display uses a bank of LEDs and fiberoptic cables to light the entire backplane of the liquid crystal display with a uniform white light. The liquid crystal pixels then block varying proportions of this light which bleeds through the individual pixels to form the image you view on the display. This type of display typically has a contrast ratio (the ratio for the brightest to the dimmest possible pixel) around a 1000:1 because the entire backplane is uniformly lit with white light and since even for black pixels some of this white light will still bleed through the "black" liquid crystal pixels. These displays also do some other fancy things to allow the viewing angle (the angles to the screen for which you can still view the image) to be expansive. And, of course, there are color filters to provide RGB pixels for color images. In addition, because of the thinness requirements for laptop displays, these displays are usually edge-lit with fiber optic cables employed to conduct the light to the LCD pixels. [The details of how all this works employs not only liquid crystals but also circular polarizing filters, etc.]

The mini-LED display, on the other hand, divides the display screen into small regions (sort of like a tiling) with each small region being lit by its own LED(s), and this LED can be switched on or off. Thus the backplane of the liquid crystal display is not uniformly lit, rather each small region is lit separately. This means that a region of the display that is supposed to be black can be truly black since its LED(s) lighting that small region can be switched off and thus there is no light to bleed through the liquid crystal pixels to be seen -- i.e., true black (total lack of light) pixels. This type of display can achieve a contrast ratio of 1000000:1 since the display's blacks are truly black. And, according to Apple, their mini-LED display has 10000 mini-LEDs to light the backplane, but I do not believe there are 10000 different "tiles", rather I think there are more than one mini-LED that lights any particular backplane region. I'm not sure precisely how it is organized, and until the display is taken apart and studied we may not know all of the details. [An emerging technology called microLED is the extension of the miniLED concept to even more mini-LEDs so that every LCD pixel has its own micro-LED to light it.]

While you didn't ask, I should still probably quickly mention OLED displays. For these displays the pixels themselves actually emit light (Organic Light Emitting Diode) instead of just blocking light from the backplane. This again means that a black pixel can be truly black since the pixel can be turned off and thus not emit any light. Also OLED displays are often described as having more "vibrant" colors, whatever that means.

Now on to the meaning of ProMotion:
Until the latest MBPs, the displays typically had a constant refresh rate of 60Hz, 60 times a second the image on the display could be changed. (fps=frames per second) In the old days, movie theaters employed 24Hz films while older TVs used roughly 30Hz (depending on what part of the world you lived in). But with gaming enthusiasts wanting faster refresh rates, displays were designed with faster refresh rates, such as 120Hz, 140Hz, 144Hz, and 240Hz, etc. On a laptop, the refresh rate on the display also affects the battery life since the more often the image is changed the more energy is used to effect those changes. So a laptop with a 120Hz display would use considerably more energy than a laptop with a 60Hz display. So, incomes ProMotion...ProMotion displays can vary their refresh rates automatically to accommodate the actual rate of the video signal, all the way from 24Hz to 120Hz. Thus if you are watching a 24Hz video signal, the display will refresh at 24Hz instead of running at a constant 60Hz, thereby saving a lot of energy and extending the battery life of the laptop. But if you are watching a 120Hz video signal, then the ProMotion display is capable of ramping up its refresh rate to 120Hz to match the video signal. At 120Hz the display is "more fluid", it appears smoother to most people's eyes than if the display is running at 60Hz. [By the way, the various Hz speeds listed above actually refer to sets of very close speeds, thus 30Hz actually refers to 29.97Hz and 30Hz. There are also 50Hz, 25Hz, 59.94Hz, etc. signals, again depending upon the actual video signal being viewed and in what part of the world.]

The new Apple Studio Display is a 60Hz display. Now having a refresh rate greater than 60Hz is very useful for gaming, but I doubt you are wanting to game on this display, rather you would simply buy a gaming PC with an appropriate 144Hz or 240Hz monitor for your gaming endeavors. [Supposedly, the professional, expert gamers can tell the difference between 144Hz and 240Hz displays, but I'm sure that my poor, ancient, eyes cannot.]

Hope this simplistic explanation has provided a modicum of help for you.

Regards,
Solouki

P.S. Hopefully an expert will post corrections to any mistakes I've made above and provide you with further details.
 

Cham2000

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Mar 11, 2022
426
216
I'm no expert, but since your query hasn't attracted any experts to answer it, I'll attempt a simple explanation.
...

Thanks Solouki. It helps.

So mini-LED is a good thing to get very dark blacks on the screen.

Would you say that Promotion isn't very relevant for desktop computers?
 

macOS Lynx

macrumors 6502
Jun 3, 2019
386
555
Would you say that Promotion isn't very relevant for desktop computers?
For the most part, its just for visual flare. Something like Promotion is nice because your system animations, down to just moving windows, feels smoother, fluider, and faster.

Outside of competitive video games though, there's not some big major advantage to a higher refresh rate.
 

solouki

macrumors 6502
Jan 5, 2017
339
213
Hi Cham2000,

I agree with macOS Lynx's comments.

It probably depends on your own eyes, but unless you are a professional gamer, a 60Hz desk display would most likely be fine. A good part of the reason ProMotion is so useful on Apple's latest MBPs is its capability to save battery life by running the display at the FPS rate of the video being viewed. But this depends on the user's actual viewing habits. Some individuals claim that browser scrolling looks smoother in ProMotion at 120Hz, and I suppose that is true, but my poor old eyes have never detected any glitches while scrolling on material that I'm pretty sure is just 60Hz.

I think the mini-LED makes the greatest difference in the latest MBP's display, as the 1000000:1 contrast ratio provides a really nice look to many scenes and it allows for HDR content to be displayed well (shadows have more details as well as brights). Mini-LED is not perfect, however, as the tiling regions do allow for some bleed through pixels that should be black but aren't totally black because that region's mini-LEDs are on. This is noticeable on certain images. The concept of microLED where each pixel has its own LED light source would correct this, so it will be interesting in the future if the display manufacturers are capable of engineering this type of display. And, of course, OLED displays solve many of these bleed through problems, but I believe as of today they aren't as bright as the LCD displays.

Everything is a tradeoff ... but it's nice that we actually have different options providing different tradeoffs for different applications, such as the professional gamer who wants a 240Hz display.

In a nutshell, unless you are a professional gamer or a professional photographer or videographer, I suspect that you will be quite happy with the Studio Display. On the other hand, I think the older LG Ultrafine 5K display is a very close competitor to Apple's new Studio Display (which I personally haven't seen yet), and so you might also consider saving $300 and get the LG 5K instead of the Studio Display. I believe, as of today, you might be able to compare both displays side-by-side in Apple Stores (unfortunately for me, the nearest Apple Store is over a six hour drive away).

Enjoy whatever display you purchase, you most likely can't go wrong.
Solouki
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.