Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
What Is The Best External Hard Drive To Use On iMac ?
- Thread starter Dr.Zizooo
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I just grabbed a Western Digital My Book Studio edition 1 TB with FW 800. Fat quiet and huge capacity. Working great for me so far.
When researching hard drives, I seemed to find two nodes with all HD makes and models. One node is thrilled, and the other says DO NOT BUY drive failed. I think that is just the way it goes with all hard drive makers.
When researching hard drives, I seemed to find two nodes with all HD makes and models. One node is thrilled, and the other says DO NOT BUY drive failed. I think that is just the way it goes with all hard drive makers.
You're right ..... after looking for a good External HD i found that many people recommend a Western Digital or Lacie ....
Thanks for Your response ^_^
Thanks ..... I'm Looking now for the best deal on either Lacie or Western Digital ...... Also thanks for your nice spirit ..... ^_^
Thanks ... I'm readinf every reply on this post .... being a big help brother ... ^_^
Western Digitals are usually cheaper as well. I'd even suggest buying two 500 GB's, as the price of the tri-connect (USB 2.0, Firewire 400 and eSata) is pretty cheap right now.
The advantages of Firewire 800 over Firewire 400 aren't that great, especially depending upon what you're using the drive for.
The advantages of Firewire 800 over Firewire 400 aren't that great, especially depending upon what you're using the drive for.
If you want FAST, stay away from "ready made" external drives, and
buy a FAST drive mechanism and a good FW800 external enclosure.
WD doesn't make any fast 1TB drives. LaCie doesn't tell you which drive they
use, and doesn't specify performance (other than meaningless "burst rates").
OWC does tell which drive they use -- and it's a not-very-fast Hitachi 7K1000.
According to manufacturers spec sheets and online benchmarks from sites
like tomshardware.com, Seagate and Samsung are the current 1TB speed
champions. Samsung has the fastest sustained transfer rates, but Seagate
beats 'em in most real-world benchmarks. No other 1TB drives come close.
There are lots of good FW800 enclosures around; just look for one with an
Oxford OXUF924DSb or OXUF934DSb chipset and whatever other features
float your boat. I like Icy Dock's MB559UEB-1S ($70 at newegg), but OWC's
Mercury Elite Pro and miniStack v3 also have a good reps.
...DO NOT buy an IDE-based enclosure -- IDE is obsolete,
LK
If price is a factor,
I saw a WD 750GB formatted for Mac, USB 2.0, FireWire 800 and E-Sata
on sale for $179 at Best Buy
I saw a WD 750GB formatted for Mac, USB 2.0, FireWire 800 and E-Sata
on sale for $179 at Best Buy
I've got a G-Tech f/w 800 that is both quiet and fast. Comes with a 3 year warranty. I like it. Best price I found for it was at Amazon.
Morod
Morod
I'd suggest (as others have) getting a good fast drive and then buying a decent enclosure to put it in. Some enclosures now include LAN as well as eSATA, FW, and USB (like mine does!)
I purchased a Samsung drive and it romps along at good speed.
Using it with 2 partitions - 1 for Time Machine and the other for data storage.
Cheers
I purchased a Samsung drive and it romps along at good speed.
Using it with 2 partitions - 1 for Time Machine and the other for data storage.
Cheers
I also love G-Tech. Not cheap but very well made. I own three.
I would stay away from Lacie as they crash more often than they should.
However, ALL HD's crash. All of them! Multiple redundancy is the best way to handle that.
i've never had a HDD crash, internal or external lol maybe you're riding em too hard
Maybe, but just count yourself lucky! HD's eventually crash. And I'm not even talking about the iPods I had to have replaced because of HD crashes ... I really got tired of looking at the unhappy Mac face and that clunking sound interrupting the heavy disc spinning! Brrrrrrrrrrrrr!
my drive crashed too
But if you don't move your drive too much around, it will very likely last a very long time. I don't think 5 years average would be exagerated, unless of course you buy a super cheap low quality product.
True. I had a HD crash last week on my SE/30 and it's only about 20 years old... Problem is where to find a new SCSI-1 80Mb HD these days...
But if you don't move your drive too much around, it will very likely last a very long time. I don't think 5 years average would be exagerated, unless of course you buy a super cheap low quality product.
True. I had a HD crash last week on my SE/30 and it's only about 20 years old... Problem is where to find a new SCSI-1 80Mb HD these days...
But if you don't move your drive too much around, it will very likely last a very long time. I don't think 5 years average would be exagerated, unless of course you buy a super cheap low quality product.
Uh, I want to own your old drive!!! 20 Years is amazing. You have been lucky. The Lacie that crashed never moved - just sat on a desk. And portable drives are meant to be, well portable - like the ones in iPods (that are not SSD's).