Which lamp should I get?

[Shannighan]

Which of these two lamps should I get for my end table?

Flos Miss K | Foscarini Lumiere 05




This is the (current) end table:

 

[bowzer]

I like the lumiere better... not a fan of the see through plastic look.

 

[drewsof07]

I like the lumiere better... not a fan of the see through plastic look.

+1

Also you have to keep in mind how the plastic would look after a bit of use. Scratches are inevitable with this type of design.

 

[velocityg4]

Personally I would go with the Alien Abduction Lamp.

 

[wordoflife]

Plastic doesn't look good in my opinion.
I would try to look for literally, "a modern design".
But I voted for the lumiere

 

[fkhan3]

I like Lumiere. Not sure how plastic would respond if the lamp got really hot.

 

[kyle1320]

The ones on the left look too much like an upside down giant condom in a trashcan blowing into a trumpet (or a vuvuzela ) So I'm gonna have to go with the ones on the right.

 

[mac&cheesey]

Plastic doesn't look good in my opinion.
I would try to look for literally, "a modern design".
But I voted for the lumiere

wordoflife,

What lamp is that that you posted a pic of? I like it.

I voted for the one on the right by the way. The clear plastic is a no-go for me.

m&c

 

[wordoflife]

wordoflife,

What lamp is that that you posted a pic of? I like it.

I voted for the one on the right by the way. The clear plastic is a no-go for me.

m&c

Here you go, it's on Amazon.
http://www.amazon.com/Lite-Source-L...DW/ref=sr_1_18?ie=UTF8&qid=1311575301&sr=8-18

 

[mac&cheesey]

wordoflife,

Thanks for the link!

m&c

 

[fel10]

I'd pick the second one. The first one looks kind of cheap.

 

[Shannighan]

Personally I would go with the Alien Abduction Lamp.

View attachment 295797

That lamp is amazing, but I'm trying to keep my room from looking like the stereotypical comp sci / college student room.

The ones on the left look too much like an upside down giant condom in a trashcan blowing into a trumpet (or a vuvuzela ) So I'm gonna have to go with the ones on the right.

That's a very interesting interpretation... hahaha!

 

[(marc)]

Definitely the right one. The left one looks like a plastic cup...

 

[Shannighan]

OK. So I bought the Foscarini Lumiere, what do you think?
The odd shaped thing next to the lamp is a to scale mockup of a Aalto savoy bowl.

 

[fireshot91]

I like it. I would have voted for the Right-hand picture anyways, if I came across this thread sooner.

It looks nice with your table