Which of these HD enclosures would work?

[M@lew]

I have a CD Macbook and I've since upgraded the HD to 160GB. Because of this, I have a spare 60GB HD lying around and I've been looking for an enclosure for it. I've found two on eBay which look very similar, but I'm not sure which is the one I should get.

Option 1

Option 2

Would either of these work?

 

[shipdestroyer]

The second one won't work because it takes an IDE drive. Macbooks have SATA hard drives.