Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Why Apple never caught the reception issues during testing

C

cdebnil

macrumors regular
Original poster
Jun 22, 2010
103
3
Very simple reason....Remember when Gizmodo first released the pictures of the "found" iphone? They mentioned that it was in camouflaged to look like an Iphone 3gs...In reality it had a early bumper design. If all the engineers were testing the phone with the bumper on, they probably never experienced a lot of the signal issues that people with naked iphones are seeing today. See the attached pic of the Gizmodo "found" phone with the "camo". Since I used to do quality control for a living, I say this is bad quality testing on Apple's part. However, I do love my iphone with the bumper on!!! No signal issues here once its on.

http://gizmodo.com/5520164/this-is-apples-next-iphone

Original quote from the article:

"You are looking at Apple's next iPhone. It was found lost in a bar in Redwood City, camouflaged to look like an iPhone 3GS . We got it. We disassembled it. It's the real thing, and here are all the details."

Also Gizmodo's original picture with the "camo" on. Probably a prototype bumper
 
That's part of the working theory, yep: that testing was done with the iPhone 4 inside masked cases, fake ones to disguise the actual product inside, and in the process preventing the skin-on-metal contact which is what most of us with problems truly believe is causing those same problems.

This is discussed in many threads, including the "Occam's razor" one (mine) and several others.

You're in good company with that line of thinking... :D
 
So this is going to be posted once every day then?


Really, did you not think that someone here thought of that already?
 
Apple never releases accessories for their products (iPad case being an exception). They announced bumpers when the iPhone 4 was introduced. They knew about the problem.
 
chriskzoo said:
Apple never releases accessories for their products (iPad case being an exception). They announced bumpers when the iPhone 4 was introduced. They knew about the problem.
Click to expand...

But... they didn't update the software on purpose to overwhelm their tech support with bumper requests?
 
Munitalp said:
But... they didn't update the software on purpose to overwhelm their tech support with bumper requests?
Click to expand...

apple needs to grow earnings like they did before. the bumpers are pure profit. almost like going go large at a fast food joint or buying applecare or a best buy warranty.

apple just thinks they are still dealing with ifanatics that will buy anything Steve tells them and will wait around for a fix. apple needs to grow up and learn how to be a mass market company.

just like microsoft did 10 years ago
 
Ferris23 said:
So this is going to be posted once every day then?


Really, did you not think that someone here thought of that already?
Click to expand...

Really smart A? I did a search for iphone camo, iphone reception camo, and found nothing specifically related to what I said before I posted. My point was the Gizmodo camo pic and the engineers leaving them on. Please tell me what to type in the search box to find similar posts.
 
cdebnil said:
Really smart A? I did a search for iphone camo, iphone reception camo, and found nothing specifically related to what I said before I posted. My point was the Gizmodo camo pic and the engineers leaving them on. Please tell me what to type in the search box to find similar posts.
Click to expand...
Wow, I'm so surprised that the keyword "camo" didn't give you the results you desired. :facepalm:
 
cdebnil said:
Really smart A? I did a search for iphone camo, iphone reception camo, and found nothing specifically related to what I said before I posted. My point was the Gizmodo camo pic and the engineers leaving them on. Please tell me what to type in the search box to find similar posts.
Click to expand...

This is Macrumors, in all honesty news and rumors start here. I just thought it would be kind of obvious that this would have been thought of by now, but I probably post here a lot more than you so....

And yes I know sometimes searching for things can be a pain in the ass if you don't word it properly.
 
chriskzoo said:
Apple never releases accessories for their products (iPad case being an exception). They announced bumpers when the iPhone 4 was introduced. They knew about the problem.
Click to expand...

:rolleyes: Incorrect. They introduced the bumper, which has rubber on the front and rear, to shield the impact of a fall that would otherwise shatter their GLASS phone.
 
Do you think all the testers are morons and they to a bar to test their iPhones? They can do all their testing in their own home, with no one else around, without any cases on.
 
Tbh i don't buy into this theory

Maybe i'm giving Apple a little too much credit, but i doubt they would not test a new product feature such as the new Antenna system properly, yes the device Gizmodo found/bought was in a case, but thats not to say that device wasn't being used for a different test entirely which didn't require the antennas be to out. I think Apple would have had devices out without any cases on to test the reception, probaby in areas with perfect coverage tbh though
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back