Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

maxoakland

macrumors 65816
Original poster
Oct 6, 2021
1,045
1,531
Photos is taking up a ton more space than I want. I have optimize photo storage on so I’d expect iCloud to remove the photos when my storage gets too full.

Right now it’s telling me I can’t update my phone because there’s not enough storage to download the update. It’s been saying that since 18.2. That’s exactly the kind of situation I’d assume optimize photos is for

So what’s going on? Is this normal?
 
Possibly. Would need to know how many photos you have and how much space they're taking up in iCloud compared to on your device.
 
  • Like
Reactions: G5isAlive
Possibly. Would need to know how many photos you have and how much space they're taking up in iCloud compared to on your device.
I have a ton of photos. Over 90k and they’re taking up about 1TB on iCloud
 
Do you have Live Photos turned on? They take a lot of additional space. I'm in the process of removing all that don't actually provide additional value.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: krvld
Do you have Live Photos turned on? They take a lot of additional space. I'm in the process of removing all that don't actually provide additional value.
Yeah I do that’s good to know

Do you know a way to remove the live part of photos that don’t need it?
 
There's probably more efficient ways to do it, but I'm gradually doing it on my iOS and iPadOS devices whenever I have a bit of downtime.

I check Live Photos one by one to see if they contain anything interesting, select a handful of those that don't, duplicate them, and when asked tell Photos to duplicate them as just regular photos. I then delete the versions that are marked as containing Live content.

This method retains other metadata.
 
OP: BAIL on storing 90K photos in iCloud. Even if you "needed" to flip through all of them but gave each only 1 second per view, you'd need more time than a brand new battery could supply.
  • If you haven't done so already, import ALL of them into a Mac (Photos) app. Once they are there,
  • turn OFF iCloud Photos.
  • If you want some favorite photos with you on device at all times, make some Photo Albums in Photos and synch them to your iDevice.
  • If you legit need all 90K always available at all times (which is almost never the case in this kind of situation), buy yourself a NAS box, own your own cloud and put them in that cloud. Bill yourself $0/month for rent to that cloud.
Lastly, use Time Machine, Super Duper, Carbon Copy Cloner or similar to BACK UP that Mac, ideally to at least 2 drives (one stored offsite and regularly rotated with the other), so your risk of completely losing your photo collection falls to near nill. Fire-flood-theft are all real things and one store of personal media like photos is DANGEROUS. ☠️☠️☠️

Once you bail from renting all that space for photos, you MIGHT be able to step down from renting 1TB iCloud to free iCloud. If not, work on the NEXT big fat cloud data hog, likely also storable on your Mac and probably also able to have favs albums/playlists/etc selectively synched. Or again, put whatever that data/media is in your own NAS 'cloud' and pay yourself $0/month for cloud access to it.

ELSE, pay up for more iCloud... and then bump into the next ceiling eventually and pay up for the next tier... and repeat & repeat. Landlord for your media & data appreciates the monthly rent... forever. 💰💰💰
 
Last edited:
OP: BAIL on storing 90K photos in iCloud. Even if you "needed" to flip through all of them but gave each only 1 second per view, you'd need more time than a brand new battery could supply.
  • If you haven't done so already, import ALL of them into a Mac (Photos) app. Once they are there,
  • turn OFF iCloud Photos.
  • If you want some favorite photos with you on device at all times, make some Photo Albums in Photos and synch them to your iDevice.
  • If you legit need all 90K always available at all times (which is almost never the case in this kind of situation), buy yourself a NAS box, own your own cloud and put them in that cloud. Bill yourself $0/month for rent to that cloud.
Lastly, use Time Machine, Super Duper, Carbon Copy Cloner or similar to BACK UP that Mac, ideally to at least 2 drives (one stored offsite and regularly rotated with the other), so your risk of completely losing your photo collection falls to near nill. Fire-flood-theft are all real things and one store of personal media like photos is DANGEROUS.

Once you bail from renting all that space for photos, you MIGHT be able to step down from renting 1TB iCloud to free iCloud. If not, work on the NEXT big fat cloud data hog, likely also storable on your Mac and probably also able to have favs albums/playlists/etc selectively synched. Or again, put whatever that data/media is in your own NAS 'cloud' and pay yourself $0/month for cloud access to it.

ELSE, pay up for more iCloud... and then bump into the next ceiling eventually and pay up for the next tier... and repeat & repeat. Landlord for your media & data appreciates the monthly rent... forever. 💰💰💰
I definitely don't need access to the photos at all times. I just want to make sure I don't lose them.

You made me realize that I could end up saving money by cutting down my iCloud storage and just buying an external hard drive and a backup one. I pay $10 a month and that will pay for an external hard drive in less than a year
 
  • Like
Reactions: HobeSoundDarryl
Tim brags about how fast the internal storage is on iPhones as a reason for not giving micro SD card slot but photos don't need fast storage. He only wants to upsell you. Dance with the devil, you're going to get burned. And now Samsung has copied apple.🤑
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rainbow Apple
Photos are saved in different formats, that's why their file size varies. Now due to this, they occupy a lot of storage space. You can either manually delete them or use any duplicate photo finder from the list that I found:

 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.