Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Windows XP SP2 new Firewall "Not Very Secure afterall"

JeDiBoYTJ

JeDiBoYTJ

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
Jun 22, 2004
859
0
Ft. Lauderdale, FL
from slashdot.com and Flexbeta.com

Though Microsoft is doing their part in protecting Windows users from internet attacks by including a firewall in their latest service pack, one has to wonder just how secure is the Windows Firewall from XP Service Pack 2? Not too good according to Flexbeta. Their recommendation is to turn off Windows Firewall and get an alternative such as ZoneAlarm or Sygate PF. Simply the fact that Windows Firewall can be turned off by another application is enough to tell me Microsoft has goofed again." PCWorld also has a story about the new firewall capability.
Click to expand...

I figured some Mac users would get a kick out of this. I love how Microsoft still cant get the firewall/security thing right, while apple did it right a while ago! :p
 
JeDiBoYTJ said:
from slashdot.com and Flexbeta.com



I figured some Mac users would get a kick out of this. I love how Microsoft still cant get the firewall/security thing right, while apple did it right a while ago! :p
Click to expand...

Actually Apples Firewall is based on ipfw.... Which noone who had any sense would use either... It is a buggy implementation that has been dropped from most unix/linux except for open bsd distributions due to its numerous weaknesses.

Just for fun enable it then run a port scanner against your MAC...
You will be suprised by the ports left open

GIVEN A CHOICE.... I would prefer IPTABLES to ipfw

THAT being said I do agree anything would still be better than Microsoft Xtra Patches POS security
 
macsrus said:
Actually Apples Firewall is based on ipfw.... Which noone who had any sense would use either... It is a buggy implementation that has been dropped from most unix/linux except for open bsd distributions due to its numerous weaknesses.

Just for fun enable it then run a port scanner against your MAC...
You will be suprised by the ports left open

GIVEN A CHOICE.... I would prefer IPTABLES to ipfw

THAT being said I do agree anything would still be better than Microsoft Xtra Patches POS security
Click to expand...

I did a port checker a while back and i got a green report, there were only a few ports open and apparently they were ok. I am safe according to it. I can't remember where I checked it but i remember my mac had far fewer ports open than my pc! according to the tester my XP machine was wide open!
 
Hey now, ipfw isn't bad at all..

What IS bad is Apple's GUI control for it. It's completely worthless. Completely.
 
What IS bad is that MS has an enormous budget and can only manage to make half (if that) of their products worth using
 
Chaszmyr said:
What IS bad is that MS has an enormous budget and can only manage to make half (if that) of their products worth using
Click to expand...


How True...

The real problem with Windows is I.E.
When MICROSOFT.... decided in their infinite wisdom to intergrate I.E. into their O.S. they made a terrible mistake....

It was and is an terribly hole ridden sucurity nightmare...And since it cant be removed from the OS Windows security will always suffer
 
yellow said:
Hey now, ipfw isn't bad at all..

What IS bad is Apple's GUI control for it. It's completely worthless. Completely.
Click to expand...

You will get no argument from me on Apples worthless gui tools for ipfw, nfs, web services, dns, etc.....
They are all terrible at best....

But then again... I never configure those types of items from a gui tool anyway...
 
stoid said:
I can't wait for SP2 to get smashed by the next virus. And then Microsoft says, "Don't worry, we'll fix it!" And all the lemmings, errr people, say "Ok, sounds good." And continue to take it up the...
Click to expand...

Na dont blame the Windows lemmings... er users...
They live in the monopoly world of Microsoft.....
And until vertical market business apps start showing up in sufficent numbers on the MAC and or Linux.... We will all be stuck with Windows...
 
macsrus said:
I never configure those types of items from a gui tool anyway...
Click to expand...

Nor do I, but using the CLI or reading man pages can be daunting to someone who knows nothing about UNIX or using command line apps. Certainly the GUI control for ipfw is there for them, but it's so mind bogglingly worthless. It's such an afterthought. I couldn't believe they didn't fix it in Panther.
 
macsrus said:
You will get no argument from me on Apples worthless gui tools for ipfw, nfs, web services, dns, etc.....
They are all terrible at best....
Click to expand...

If you take a look at OS X Server, Apple does have good GUIs for those. In OS X, there are many third party apps that provide you with "advanced" GUI control for them as well. Apple just figures (correctly) that a normal user has no idea what nfs or dns is.
 
crazzyeddie said:
If you take a look at OS X Server, Apple does have good GUIs for those. In OS X, there are many third party apps that provide you with "advanced" GUI control for them as well. Apple just figures (correctly) that a normal user has no idea what nfs or dns is.
Click to expand...

I disagree... I have extensively used OSX server...
And as a matter of fact I work on the largest OSX server installation in the world... And the server tools for those utilities are not very good...

Now I do think server monitor is usefull. and Server admin to a lesser degree ... but opinions are opinions... I have mine you have yours
 
macsrus said:
I disagree... I have extensively used OSX server...
And as a matter of fact I work on the largest OSX server installation in the world... And the server tools for those utilities are not very good...

Now I do think server monitor is usefull. and Server admin to a lesser degree ... but opinions are opinions... I have mine you have yours
Click to expand...

And where is "the largest OS X Server installation in the world"? I've never heard any site make that claim - no big universities, no big businesses, no-one.

Are you comparing Apple's GUI server admin tools to other OS-bundled apps, such as Windows' or something else?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back