This is quite a human response. Its also "wrong". There have been numerous studies that nearly 95% of subsrciption services end up OVER charging a customer for the contest they actually use. Here's some quick math: Average cost of a season on iTunes is around $35. Average monthly cable bill in the US (tv only) is around $100 per month. So yearly, you pay at least $1200 to watch your "free" shows with commecials...one time only. Now, at $35 for a show's season, you would have to purchase nearly 35 (34.28) ENTIRE seasons of shows to reach the same amount. Do you watch 35 entire season's worth of shows each year? 95% of american households don't (even with children in the house). AND that doesnt include the fact that you can watch the shows anytime you want...AND you own then...forever.
That's nice of you to tell me how "wrong" I am for my opinion, especially given I said my ideal would be to rent a tv show from Apple (say for 50 cents an episode) and get rid of cable. But a subscription is only a bad deal if you don't make use of it.
You speak in seasons of shows. Who watches TV that way exclusively? I watch news, for example in spurts. I don't watch "episodes" of it. I don't know how they could sell CNN through iTunes save specials, etc. Charge by the 15 minute interval?
In any case, a single episode of TV might last 22 minutes to 44 minutes (without commercials or 30/60 with them). How much TV does an average American watch in week? 20-30 hours seems to be the number I'm seeing online (Nielsen stated in 2005 a number around 31 hours a week for an average American and that's ONE PERSON not including a spouse or a whole family living in the house). Let's go with the lower number for demonstration purposes and to give you a major edge. Furthermore, let's assume half those shows are 60 minute episodes and the other half are 30 minutes (in reality there might be movies, etc. also and the news, etc., let alone channel surfing, but you were talking about tv shows so let's go with that). That means an average person is watching the equivalent of 30 episodes of tv shows a week. How long does a season last? It varies from 6-27 episodes. A typical number is around 22-23 episodes. Let's go with 25 episodes to give your method the edge. That means any given tv series in this example only spans 25 weeks out of the year. That means to fill the yearly average "quota" for a typical American, you need over 60 tv series worth of episodes (to go by your example).
You said,
Do you watch 35 entire season's worth of shows each year? 95% of american households don't (even with children in the house).
Sorry, but by my very simple calculations, you are just flat out WRONG (to borrow your own term). The AVERAGE person (***LET ALONE HOUSEHOLD***!!!) watches over 60 seasons worth of tv every year. That's the AVERAGE (using very low-ball figures at that)!
You give an example of $100 a month for cable. I have cable with an HD/DVR cable box plus 80 channels of analog available in almost every room in the house. I get almost 50 HD channels and over 200 SD channels (but no premium channels). The cable portion of my monthly bill is $70. For $100 a month I could have HBO, Showtime and Cinemax added! So I honestly don't believe for a minute that $100 is the "average" monthly cable bill to begin with. Standard cable here would be $30 a month and about $60 for all but HD/DVR.
So even if I watch 30% less TV than the average American, your model still doesn't make the grade. iTunes would have to cost 50-200% (depending on your household size) less for it be a competitor to cable for all but those watch very little tv or very little network tv.
Even so, if it works for you, great. But don't tell me how "wrong" I am when you didn't research your numbers.