that sounds about right, ones i have done get from a few weeks to a few months extra life before the problem comes back, so i dont do them anymore...
I got my HD4850m reflown at a laptop repair shop. They had a reflow station which could focus the heat only to the graphic chip. But it didn't help. The card was still dead. Not a 100% successful solution.
A full reballing may be more effective. But judging from the cost of repair, I'd rather buy another card and hack the vBIOS, consider it as an upgrade.