Would it be dishonorable if it was to Apple as a trade in?Sorry - don’t mean to call you out, specifically, but I find it dishonorable to sell a known-defective iPad to someone else. I let mine (12.9”) die on its own from this unresponsive screen issue, without attempting to pass it off on some unsuspecting secondhand buyer.
And do you drive every car til it dies on its own as well? Do you trust every used car salesman?
Even if every 2nd gen 12.9" owner sold their defective unit to some unsuspecting secondhand buyer, it is on the buyer to research, test, and try the product before handing out their money.
Don't be quick to pass judgment without assessing both sides equally.