Face ID works fine for me. Already used apple pay on it twice with no issues. However one thing I may miss is 3D Touch which is gone.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPhone 8/Plus 8+ or IPhone XR?
- Thread starter jwolf6589
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Face ID works fine for me. Already used apple pay on it twice with no issues. However one thing I may miss is 3D Touch which is gone.
Apple Pay via an Apple Watch is the superior method anyway.
I’d argue @Wide opeN nailed the primary tech’ specs between both phones, a price difference should be common sense, being the OP is likely already aware of that. The difference of battery life obviously is greater to the XR, but of course is variable for everyone depending how they’re using their phone/settings.
I moved from 8+ to XR a couple weeks ago when I decided to give my daughter a phone. For me, Face ID’s superiority comes during use, not in unlocking the phone. Specifically, I use stored passwords all the time, and I love how seamless that is.
(And, yes, Apple Watch is definitely the best Apple Pay! I do it that way even if i have my phone in my hand.)
(And, yes, Apple Watch is definitely the best Apple Pay! I do it that way even if i have my phone in my hand.)
It is when you have a pass ready and you can’t double tap to bring up apple pay. You have to lock the phone then double tap the lock button. Completely useless.
I chose 8+ instead of XR because of the dual camera, higher res screen, and "classic" form factor of home button/touchID that I'm used to since 2007
You don't need to have a 'pass ready'. You just double click the side button on a locked phone and it brings up Apple Pay automatically which is set to the card you used last. Glance at the phone for FaceID, and that's it. It takes a second and not 'completely useless'. It works flawlessly every time for me although I use the same card for most things so am not fumbling to change it. If necessary, I would be sure that was done before I was actually ready to pay.
Last edited:
Does it make phone calls? So does my 8.
Yeah. All iPhones make phone calls....
Yawn.... anything else?
You don’t get what im saying.
After the person at checkout has scanned my pass ,i have to either lock my phone or press “done” to then be able to bring up apple pay to scan my face.
I use apple pay and passes a lot and its too much messing around.
I don't fly so I've never dealt with boarding passes or movie passes and I've never had a person at checkout scan anything before paying for my items. I double click the side button, glance down at it, and that's it. I only use it at stores to pay for things and I see no inconvenience at all for that purpose. Even if I did use it for other things, I would consider that a minor inconvenience at worst and certainly not a deal breaker. I guess I'm not that anal.
Last edited:
To be honest I don’t think Apple Pay is a particularly drawn out process whether you are using TouchID or FaceID to be honest. It’s a button press or a swipe and both were designed with a heavy emphasis on convenience. If you want something that beats using an iPhone, use it on an Apple Watch. It’s nearly 3 years since I last paid through an iPhone.
Even using it to fly, you scan it yourself. I’ve gotten through an entire trip... tsa... boarding... buying snacks... with just my watch. Fun!
Because the newer models are more expensive. The iPhone 8/8+ is discounted under the newer models. Not to mention, if somebody were considering the 5.5 inch iPhone 8 Plus, you’re getting the dual camera/larger battery.
I would have purchased an XR instead of the 8 if it were smaller. I became tired of carrying around a large phone which is why I no longer have my 7+. I also liked the XS because of its size but could not see paying the extra $$ for it.
I also would like to have the option for a smaller XR but I think that nearly nobody would buy the XS any more if that happens....
To me, the added swiping of the new X series reminds me of the 1st few iPhones- I absolutely hated having to "swipe to open". It's just not as natural as a "button" press even if it's a simulated (haptic)"button press".
You forgot screen size & weight (ok just kidding), but also the modem and haptic vs 3D Touch.
Last edited:
I waited for the XR to come out when I was due an upgrade. I went with an 8 Plus and never looked back. The XR is bulky and the screen actually has less useful UI real estate than the 8 Plus. It feels narrow to me compared to the 8 Plus which makes the keyboard awkward to use ( i have big hands) The 8 Plus is a phone you can actual do some productive work on. I notice text being less sharp on the XR as well due to the lower resolution. The 8 Plus with it's 1080p True Tone display and pleasing ratio is great to use. I also get a dual lens rear camera setup with optical 2x zoom and proper portrait mode. Also for some wierd reason mail on the XR does not have a landscape mode but messages does. I like how apps take advantage of the 8 Plus screen. Again makes it more productive.
Also still have touch ID and a nice 16:9 display with no notch!
I suppose the XR has some better battery life buts that's the only advantage. Get an 8 Plus.
Also still have touch ID and a nice 16:9 display with no notch!
I suppose the XR has some better battery life buts that's the only advantage. Get an 8 Plus.
FaceId is superior than touch ID (particularly) in the following two unlocking scenarios; well at least for me:
> When the phone is docked in the dash of the car, unlocking with faceId is a breeze whereas with touch Id you all know the procedures.
> TouchID can be a major annoyance in light drizzle or bit of sweat /moisture on your finger/ftouch pad - no such issues with FAceID
These two are very good quality of life improvements for me when using the phone.
That said, I own both the 8+ and XR.
Such terrible advice. The 8 plus is legacy tech, dated and old old old. It’s also almost nearly 2 years old, based on a 3 year old design when it came out and was pretty much dead on arrival
How many consumers do you know that care about a phone that virtually looks the same as the iPhone 8 as it does the iPhone XS? I doubt you know very many people that would. Keep in mind, the iPhone 8 shares many same features as the iPhone XR/XS with two-tone, wireless charging, stereo speakers, dual camera, etc. In terms of design for smart phones, they’re all really the same, it’s the features that separate the phones that consumers want to see, look at Apples marketing for example, it’s about the camera, Animoji, etc. Those are the things that they want to consumer to see.