Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
A 4 inch screen is definitely not the ideal size for a smartphone
- Thread starter SomeDudeAsking
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
No the body isn't much larger, it's the screen size that makes the S3 more cumbersome.
...?
Look at your picture. If I wanted to touch something at the top of the S3 screen it would be equivalent to reaching to the top of the iPhone 5. Plus it's wider...trying to reach the top left corner of the S3 would be a chore.
I been enjoying the GS3 since the beginning of August. My only real complaint is the auto screen rotate is too damn sensitive. Sometimes I have to toggle off.
Actually not really. Might seem that way at first, but you'll develop a way of holding it that makes one handed use easy.
Easy? I'm sure easier, but I doubt it'd ever be completely painless to use one-handed. I suppose I'm talking out of my a** since I don't own one, but I've used it on many occasions and I can't ever imagine it being easy to use one-handed.
The truth of the matter is there is no perfect or ideal size screen.
Only iOS would put things at the top of the screen that require constant touching (back/cancel usually). Back is part of the OS on Android and always at the bottom be it on screen or capacitive.
If Samsung wasn't using AMOLED displays the S3 would be more appealing. Those screens just dont look very good at this point. Brightness and blue-ish contamination being a big problem.
Also, American iterations really need to stop being gimped with Qualcomm SOC's.
Also, American iterations really need to stop being gimped with Qualcomm SOC's.
Notifications? UI buttons? There's tons of stuff on Android at the top...just not Back.
----------
Agreed. AMOLED is a drawback.
Everyone is built differ. My hands can manuver through the GS3 screen easily. The same way you feel about the GS3 is the same way I feel about the Note(2) being to big for one handed use.
You don't need to reach to the opposite corner (left or right handed) for notifications. What UI buttons?
I'm not saying you NEVER need to reach the opposite corner, just unlike iOS where regardless of app there is something important in the upper left and/or right.
I conclude that The picture shows that the actual size between the two devices is very close, so if people like one versus the other, then, largely, the reason is for some reason other than size.
Last edited:
Can you give any specific examples?
I've just tried doing a few things one handed on my Galaxy Nexus with no issues.
(Chrome, Settings, Play Store and GReader below).
Holding the handset in my right hand, everything I needed was in reaching distance of my thumb. I was also able to easily pull down the notification tray and flick away any unneeded notifications.
Attachments
A couple of things...
Are we seriously still talking about how "difficult" it is to get an S3 into one's pockets? This is such a non-issue. (Personally, I feel the S3 actually feels amazing in the pocket. It just disappears because it's so thin and rounded.)
And... the back button, people. It's a beautiful thing.
Are we seriously still talking about how "difficult" it is to get an S3 into one's pockets? This is such a non-issue. (Personally, I feel the S3 actually feels amazing in the pocket. It just disappears because it's so thin and rounded.)
And... the back button, people. It's a beautiful thing.
S3 is too big.
I agree the back button is one of the greatest innovations in Android.
Big surprise. On a big screen things look.... bigger.
The question is where's the right balance. I've have 3.5, 3.7, 4.0, 4.3 inch phones. I found the 4.3 too big. iPhone 5's 4" screen seems like a good compromise. I could see a very thin no bezel 4.3", but the 4.8" S3 screen is simply too big. If you want something that huge, why not get a Galaxy Note II, its even bigger, its likely stuff on the screen will look bigger too. Or get a 7" tablet and use it as a phone. Where does it stop. The bigger the display the better it looks, but the more awkward to carry around.
Of course its a personal decision. If its the right size for you thats great. But its easy to forget about how much larger it is to carry around when you look at it in a store and see pretty big pictures. Back when the iPhone was announced with its 3.5" screen, folks thought that was huge. My how times have changed. Rather than trying to get more into a smaller package, we seem to reward a bigger package.
AMOLED screen works different. Black is really black. Black on an LCD is the LCD trying to block the light that's still there. I have/had an AMOLED screen phone. Its ok but has some downsides including:
- can get screen burnin. Didn't happen to mine but its possible.
- colors can be unrealistic. The S3 colors are a little off but most folks wouldn't notice.
- AMOLED can be harder to see in the sun. I think the technology has continued to improve.
- Battery life. The more bright areas there are on the screen the more power is needed. The worst case is displaying an all too common white page at maximum brightness. Can be much worse than LCD. On the other hand, looking at a white on black page in relative darkness has minuscule power drain.
And, BTW, at least to my eyes, the iPhone 5 display is the best LCD display I've seen or owned. Blacks are excellent. Color reproduction is spot on. Automatic brightness is just right so you're never staring into a headlight. To me, it looks like a richly colored piece of bright paper, not a display.
Yes I have and I'll actually be picking up the Note II when it comes out. I've never placed a phone in my front shirt pocket, that's just asking for trouble. The S3 is bigger than the 4S, I agree with you there but I'm sure you'd feel a noticeable difference with an iPhone 5 in your pocket compared to the 4S as well..
LOL...so funny to see this. Before the iP5 came out, most in here said 3.5" was the perfect size.
It's posted in a section called "Alternatives to iOS and iOS devices" so I don't see any issue with this thread. If you don't like Android devices then don't read about them.
----------
Funny thing is the reverse has happened with the iPad. Before the iPad Mini came out most in here said no one would ever want a tablet with a display smaller then 9.7 in.
It's posted in a section called "Alternatives to iOS and iOS devices" so I don't see any issue with this thread. If you don't like Android devices then don't read about them.
----------
Funny thing is the reverse has happened with the iPad. Before the iPad Mini came out most in here said no one would ever want a tablet with a display smaller then 9.7 in.
Yeah, this forum is filled with a bunch of iRobots.
Devoted Apple users may seem to blow with the winds of apple, yet I'm sure that has to do with a sense that apple delivers a decent overall set of products. Even I was having second thoughts about apple in the late 90s. Nonetheless, apple continues to deliver, thus, too much emphasis on Consistency could be considered the hobgoblin of small minds.
I'm sure if apple came out with a 4.3 or a 4.8, there would be a large number of converts, but for now, 4" works pretty good - and by the large number of adopters is probably the best for many, if u can afford it, or can rob a bank.
I don't think anyone, including Apple, is claiming the iPad Mini can be used one-handed. The issue many have regarding phone size is using it one-handed. I also agree that 4.3" would be ideal--I've also owned a Galaxy Nexus and personally found its 4.65" screen a touch too large for one-handed use but again that's just my personal experience. I also own a Nexus 7 and love how comfortable it is too hold one-handed, suspect I would have a similar experience with the iPad Mini.
Update: Well I stand corrected after watching the promo video--Apple clearly does think the 7.9" form factor is perfect for one handed use.
Last edited:
Thank you thank you thank you!
I cannot believe iOS put the back button in the top left of the screen. Unless you're left handed it's a real pain and something Android uses won't have to bother with.
p.s, How often do you really type with 1 hand? unless of course you're driving illegally