After reading this, I went to AMEX website to see what they got. And it turns out for a AMEX card holder, you should definitely purchase Applecare without any hesitation, and here is why:
If you purchase an additional service contract or extended warranty with a product which is otherwise eligible
under the Buyer's Assurance Plan, and the combined coverage provided by both the original manufacturers
warranty and the purchased service contract does not exceed five years, then the product is eligible for coverage
under the Buyer's Assurance Plan. The Buyer's Assurance Plan will extend the warranty time period and mirror
coverage of the original manufacturers' warranty up to one additional year after both the original
manufacturers warranty and the purchased service contract have expired.
Awesome! Full warranty for totally
4 years!!
Thanks OP for bringing this up!! It's great to know there's one more year of FREE warranty under your belt even after Applecare expired.