Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Yesterday, I walked into an Apple Store, after visiting 4 Best Buy stores in an unsuccessful attempt to replace the battery in my 13 Pro Max, and I had the privilege of forking over $450 for my trouble. Any news outlet could run this and say Apple overcharges for everything. But allow me to explain.

I purchased a refurbished iPhone 13 Pro Max a little over a year ago from Amazon. The configuration I wanted (512GB, Sierra Blue) wasn't available in Apple's refurbished store, so I went this route instead. When I received it, I ran a diagnostic on it (can't remember what app or program it was) and it checked out. All the hardware worked as it should.

I've noticed recently the phone is acting up, rebooting on it's own with around 70% charge, and when it comes back up, it shows 10% charge. Manually restarting it brings it back to what it should be. Battery health was at 83%, which makes me uncomfortable, and it definitely wasn't lasting as long as it used to (battery health was 99% when I received it) so I scheduled a service at Best Buy for a few days out (as I'm a Total member). I figured they'd get their ducks in a row, get a battery ready to go, I've never had trouble with the 4 phones I've taken in for service previously.

This time was different. They told me they don't have the battery to do the repair, and if I wanted to proceed, they'd order the battery but they'd also have to hold onto the phone. I'm not exactly sure why that is, so I declined. I then tried to call Best Buy to see if they could point me to a store that has a battery in stock. Apparently they couldn't help me, so I went to three other stores. The first two didn't have batteries, and the last one had a solitary Apple tech with one foot out the door, and would be gone for a week. So I scheduled an appointment at Apple for the next day.

I went into Apple, everything seemed to be going smooth, the Genius ran diagnostics and it flagged the display as having a problem. He said sometimes it could be due to a non-genuine screen, and sometimes there's no real issue, like the software freaks out. I authorize the repair, and they get to it. I grab a bite a few doors down and come back about an hour later. Then Apple hits me with the bad news.

The display broke during removal. I figure okay, they'll replace it no problem. But there was a problem. Not only was the display broken, it was a third-party part. Many thoughts then ran through my head, like it all makes sense. The money I saved buying refurbished was probably thanks to the previous owner breaking the screen, which happens a lot in iPhoneland. They probably ditched the phone due to the most likely higher cost of the screen replacement at that time, so the repair shop probably threw in whatever screen they could get their hands on, duped the phone into believing it's a genuine part, and sold it to me.

$89 for the battery, $329 for the screen. That's an expensive lesson to learn, but I'll take it in stride. Just wanted the community to see what could happen if you try and cut corners, it could happen to anybody. But I've learned, either buy new or from Apple Refurbished if you can.
I know most people will say lesson learned, always buy your iPhones from Apple, but it's quite sad and anti-competitive that we can't buy secondhand phones with third party components, because Apple writes the software to cause issues. Quite how a screen costs $329 too is daylight robbery. Apple have a business model where they sell you insurance on new phones, and make it difficult to buy secondhand, unless you buy from them. I buy new myself, but something doesn't sit right with me about your experience.
 
  • Like
Reactions: goldmac2006
the one part of your story that did mean a lot to me was that Authorised (by apple) repair places, which dont have the parts, want to keep your device from the time you agree to the repair, until the time it gets repaired, after they eventually get the part(s).
I had the same experience at Best Buy. Made an appointment, then they said they didn't have the battery but would order it. That took a few days. And they couldn't tell me if other Best Buy stores had the item in stock. - frustrating!
Based on this thread, I'll go to Apple next time I need a repair.
 
@markredf150 thanks for your post and sorry to read about your woes. I've been looking at buying a used/refurbished iPhone 13 pro and reading your story, I'm going to now save up and just buy refurbished from Apple.
I'm glad to save at least one person from a potential headache, heartache and wallet ache :)
 
But in most cases, it is an easy way to check out Device History. The Reprogrammer devices are not cheap, and usually have criminal organizations behind them
Hey do you watch Luke Miani on YouTube? He recently did a video on the 2017 MBP Function Keys like the one you have where he upgraded the storage on it. Probably the last MacBook model where you can upgrade the storage semi-easily (at least without soldering). I'm gonna check eBay out and get one to play with :)
 
Wouldn’t it of been cheaper to buy the refurbished model from Apple in exchange for your old phone?

I’ve had phones with problems where it was too internal issue and rather than fix parts they just swapped me for a refurbished phone of same spec I had.

You can’t have been far off that cost based on what you paid
It definitely would have been cheaper, but like I mentioned that color/config wasn't available at the time. I probably could have waited a few weeks and kept checking the store but given such limited time availability, I didn't want someone else buying it from under me. I've purchased an iMac from Apple Refurbished before and it was basically a new product but at a great price, and with a warranty. But on this hike, I went off the beaten path and got stung, simple as that. I knew the risks. I'm comfortable sharing this experience, because it seems a few people who replied to it have been helped by it, and that is worth it for me.
 
Wouldn’t it of been cheaper to buy the refurbished model from Apple in exchange for your old phone?

I’ve had phones with problems where it was too internal issue and rather than fix parts they just swapped me for a refurbished phone of same spec I had.

You can’t have been far off that cost based on what you paid
By the way, James May is awesome!
 
  • Like
Reactions: JamesMay82
Hey do you watch Luke Miani on YouTube? He recently did a video on the 2017 MBP Function Keys like the one you have where he upgraded the storage on it. Probably the last MacBook model where you can upgrade the storage semi-easily (at least without soldering). I'm gonna check eBay out and get one to play with :)
Yes, I did watch Luke’s content. I believe his Porsche upgrade was the last one I watched. My Mac was upgraded using this method. My Macs original Storage Module was 128GB. It’s the last upgradable MacBook
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.