That's a very sensible thing to do. I wouldn't want to walk on the street with noise cancelling QC35 headphones on. It will reduce my awareness of car horns and easier for robber to sneak up behind me to attack me.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
AirPods or Bose QC35?
- Thread starter michial
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I have the QC-30s for work and love them. I have some noisy coworkers in the cubes around me so the noise cancelling is a godsend for when I need to focus. Scoring a barely used pair for $200 also helped me chose these over the AirPods.
I really like the design of the AirPods and would probably have bought them if the sound quality was better than the standard EarPods that come with the iPhone. But the so-so sound quality combined with no noise canceling outweigh the convenience benefits in my mind.
I really like the design of the AirPods and would probably have bought them if the sound quality was better than the standard EarPods that come with the iPhone. But the so-so sound quality combined with no noise canceling outweigh the convenience benefits in my mind.
I second this, I have been using Bose for travel for a long time. Tried out the Sony and not only is the noise cancellation better, the sound quality is better as well (IMHO of course). Bose is great, just a personal preference for me. Where Bose excels is comfort, Sony does get a tad uncomfortable over extended wear, but gives more passive noise cancelation because of this.
I also recently got the AirPods and have to say they are awesome. As people said before it’s use case specific. For every day use, the AirPods can’t be beat. The huge advantage here is the noise canceling mic (pretty amazing) and quick sync / device swap between all Apple devices. You can be using on your iPhone and switch to iPad, AppleTV, and MacBook pretty quickly and seamlessly. I was surprised at how well it worked with the AppleTV. The sound quality is impressive as well, and I am pretty particular.
Have both as well, and the AirPods are definitely used more around the office and majority of my settings. The Bose QC35ii are used when I'm trying to tune out, or during flights.
I have both as well. It would be difficult to recommend one over the other as both are very good for their use case. I use the Airpods more as I don't need noise cancellation often but the Bose sound much better and are indispensable when traveling
I have AirPods and had a set of QC35's that were stolen and now a competing product that is often compared to them.
The AirPods and QC35's can only be compared on the most generic of terms. There functions, features and uses are different across the board.
The AirPods are great when you want/need to be aware of your surroundings. They are great as a bluetooth headset replacement for phone calls (using one at a time) again. They are light weight and tuck away easily and quickly. In their charging case its unlikely they could be damaged.
Conversely the QC35's are great when you don't want to be aware of your surroundings. This is subjective but I don't like phone calls on ANC headphones. I like to hear my own voice so I know how loud I'm talking, I want to hear ambient sounds and I don't like phone calls in stereo (pulling one ear cup off gets uncomfortable). Audio fidelity isn't even comparable and unless you've used high end headphones they will spoil you.
For me I use the AirPods when I'm out in public exercising, walking around town, driving (BT calls), etc. And I used the QC35's on flights/trains/buses for the ANC and/or when I want to just listen to music especially at louder volumes.
The AirPods and QC35's can only be compared on the most generic of terms. There functions, features and uses are different across the board.
The AirPods are great when you want/need to be aware of your surroundings. They are great as a bluetooth headset replacement for phone calls (using one at a time) again. They are light weight and tuck away easily and quickly. In their charging case its unlikely they could be damaged.
Conversely the QC35's are great when you don't want to be aware of your surroundings. This is subjective but I don't like phone calls on ANC headphones. I like to hear my own voice so I know how loud I'm talking, I want to hear ambient sounds and I don't like phone calls in stereo (pulling one ear cup off gets uncomfortable). Audio fidelity isn't even comparable and unless you've used high end headphones they will spoil you.
For me I use the AirPods when I'm out in public exercising, walking around town, driving (BT calls), etc. And I used the QC35's on flights/trains/buses for the ANC and/or when I want to just listen to music especially at louder volumes.
I have just returned my airpods and trying to decide if I should get the QC35 or the new Sony for the same price.
I’ve always been a Bose fan, but I have read and watched videos saying the the Sony headphones are better. Only real reason thar I might go with the Bose is because of comfort and a bit more stylish IMO.
Anyone has tried both?
I’ve always been a Bose fan, but I have read and watched videos saying the the Sony headphones are better. Only real reason thar I might go with the Bose is because of comfort and a bit more stylish IMO.
Anyone has tried both?
I tried both and bought the Sony. I wanted noise canceling and decided the Sony's had more to offer me.
Another who appreciates that the AirPods are not noise cancelling. I use them while doing things around the house and walking. Be able to hear some things around me is a plus.
I think it really depends on what your primary use will be.
I think it really depends on what your primary use will be.
I bought the QC35's and the noise cancelling broke after 4 days, returned them and got the sony's. The QC35's were a tiny bit more comfortable but I really like the sony's and I got the 1000X and not the X2 as the 1000X were $229 on amazon so I saved a bunch over the bose as well.
I fly all the time for work, sony's work awesome and sound a little better, IMO.
Depends on if noise canceling is on. If it is, then yes, you can hear something. But it doesn't bother me.
I find Sony’s audio quality to be better if you like well balanced and slightly warmer sound. The noise cancelling is a tad better, you can auto-adjust it based on environment. At first I thought this was a gimmick (particularly the atmospheric pressure optimizer) but it does make a difference.
Comfort goes to Bose, I tend to have to adjust the Sony’s during a long flight.
One thing to note the Sony’s were $50 cheaper but that could have been a sale.
Agree 100% But don't misunderstand, the comfort is just fine. I usually wear glasses as well and the sony's work fine with them. Usually just a quick adjustment and I am good to go.
Watch out for potential headband cracking issue with 1000X. X2 has apparently solved this issue.
Thanks! I did read about that and apparently it only affected certain serial numbers, mine were made after that issue I believe. Regardless I will watch out for it.
Thanks for all the inputs guys. After nights of reading and watching video reviews, I have decided to go with the newly released Bowers & Wilkins PX. At only $50 more, sound and build quality beat the Bose and Sony. Only departments that I have to sacrifice in are Noise Cancelling and comfort (slightly inferior). I can live with that. I'd rather go with better sound and build quality! I plan to pick them up later after work.
Also, just found out that they will come out with a new B&O Beoplay H9i end of this month. It's at $499 though lol. This one looks promising too.
Also, just found out that they will come out with a new B&O Beoplay H9i end of this month. It's at $499 though lol. This one looks promising too.
Last edited:
MDR-1000X has been my best purchase, I had the QC35 and gave them to family.
10 hours extra for the new Sony seems like a good improvement but not enough to upgrade from gen 1. No interest in google assistant or siri.
I'd like the WF-1000X if if it had at least 8 hours battery, water resistance 56 or 67 ideally, and without the signal issues that even airpods have for me to buy into that form factor. The sound quality and lack of isolation is too much of a compromise for me. I must say I'm surprised the airpods have become so prevalent. The earpods came with the iPhone so that wasn't a surprise.
10 hours extra for the new Sony seems like a good improvement but not enough to upgrade from gen 1. No interest in google assistant or siri.
I'd like the WF-1000X if if it had at least 8 hours battery, water resistance 56 or 67 ideally, and without the signal issues that even airpods have for me to buy into that form factor. The sound quality and lack of isolation is too much of a compromise for me. I must say I'm surprised the airpods have become so prevalent. The earpods came with the iPhone so that wasn't a surprise.
I like the earpods that come with the iphones, they are my goto daily "headphones" and if I didn't need over the ear and noise cancellation for frequent travel, I would be all over the air pods.