Difficult to say as they are completely different. I have both. I would give the slight edge to the AirPods Max when it comes to ANC and for sound quality the AirPods Max are significantly better. I think they both have different use cases though. The AirPods pro are obviously more convenient to use but the Max have a more immersive sound. I use both outside. Tend to use the maxes more in winter and pros more in summer.