Anyone Using "CleanMyMac X" Program ?

[mreg376]

https://www.macworld.com/article/33...ac-app-hampered-by-its-malware-detection.html

CleanMyMacX gets dinged for poor malware protection.

With any utility you have to know what it's good and bad at. And you have to be smart. I'm very careful regrading malware and viruses, have never had a problem with either on any Mac, and have never used CleanMYMac to look for either. I use it mainly to keep a check on the accumulation of junk files, and keep permissions and launch associations straight.

 

[jazz1]

With any utility you have to know what it's good and bad at. And you have to be smart. I'm very careful regrading malware and viruses, have never had a problem with either on any Mac, and have never used CleanMYMac to look for either. I use it mainly to keep a check on the accumulation of junk files, and keep permissions and launch associations straight.

I'm a big fan of CleanMyMac. I jumped at upgrading to the "X" version when I saw how many improvements it offered.

If the anti-malware function is weak then I hope the developer improves that functionality. Failing that the anti-malware service should be removed so people don't rely on it.

I suppose one could argue that something is better than nothing. I also use Malwarebytes. To be fair it has never identified a problem. So who knows? Maybe I've just been lucky.
[doublepost=1543932570][/doublepost]

With any utility you have to know what it's good and bad at. And you have to be smart. I'm very careful regrading malware and viruses, have never had a problem with either on any Mac, and have never used CleanMYMac to look for either. I use it mainly to keep a check on the accumulation of junk files, and keep permissions and launch associations straight.

I'm a big fan of CleanMyMac. I jumped at upgrading to the "X" version when I saw how many improvements it offered. I like the new interface and the improvements it offers.

If the anti-malware function is weak then I hope the developer improves that functionality. Failing that the anti-malware service should be removed so people don't rely on it.

I suppose one could argue that something is better than nothing. I also use Malwarebytes. To be fair it has never identified a problem. So who knows? Maybe I've just been lucky or my secondary anti-malware app. is no better than CleanMyMac's.

 

[Hawk2Wind]

I'm a big fan of CleanMyMac. I jumped at upgrading to the "X" version when I saw how many improvements it offered.

If the anti-malware function is weak then I hope the developer improves that functionality. Failing that the anti-malware service should be removed so people don't rely on it.

I suppose one could argue that something is better than nothing. I also use Malwarebytes. To be fair it has never identified a problem. So who knows? Maybe I've just been lucky.
[doublepost=1543932570][/doublepost]

I'm a big fan of CleanMyMac. I jumped at upgrading to the "X" version when I saw how many improvements it offered. I like the new interface and the improvements it offers.

If the anti-malware function is weak then I hope the developer improves that functionality. Failing that the anti-malware service should be removed so people don't rely on it.

I suppose one could argue that something is better than nothing. I also use Malwarebytes. To be fair it has never identified a problem. So who knows? Maybe I've just been lucky or my secondary anti-malware app. is no better than CleanMyMac's.

[doublepost=1543952435][/doublepost]I read this review of CleanMyMac the guy only gave it only 2?the reason was just
malware-detection on there, he seemed happy with the rest of it.
incidentally i got some malware on here last week so i used the malware-detection on there.But after reading the review i downloaded
Malwarebytes and
scanned with that nothing was found i had it on here before but when they had it on CleanMyMac i took it off but i will leave it on here after the review.


https://www.macworld.com/article/33...ac-app-hampered-by-its-malware-detection.html

CleanMyMacX gets dinged for poor malware protection.
https://www.macworld.com/article/33...ac-app-hampered-by-its-malware-detection.html

://www.macworld.com/article/33...ac-app-hampered-by-its-malware-detection.html

 

[SaSaSushi]

The negative comments seemed to be based on what? Personal experience? A review by another person?

https://www.imore.com/cleanmymac-x-review-simplest-way-keep-your-mac-clean

https://www.producthunt.com/posts/cleanmymac-x

https://www.werockyourweb.com/cleanmymac-review/

From the iMore review:

It's not the cheapest software around at a retail price of about $90 for a one-time purchase or $40 per year for the subscription. Everything that you can do using CleanMyMac, you can do yourself if you know your Mac well and aren't afraid of Terminal.

 

[jazz1]

From the iMore review:

It's not the cheapest software around at a retail price of about $90 for a one-time purchase or $40 per year for the subscription. Everything that you can do using CleanMyMac, you can do yourself if you know your Mac well and aren't afraid of Terminal.

Go ahead. knock yourself out

https://ss64.com/osx/

 

[SaSaSushi]

Go ahead. knock yourself out

https://ss64.com/osx/

Thanks, but I'm fine with the command line.

As for knock yourself out, I offer that same advice to those who'd spend $40 a year for an app that doesn't do anything they can't do for themselves with the bonus of learning something new in the process.

 

[Consultant]

The negative comments seemed to be based on what? Personal experience? A review by another person?

https://www.imore.com/cleanmymac-x-review-simplest-way-keep-your-mac-clean

https://www.producthunt.com/posts/cleanmymac-x


https://www.werockyourweb.com/cleanmymac-review/

You do know that iMore and most sites that review the cleanmymac junk ware only post it because they are approached by the software maker, gets FREE copy of the software (offered by the software maker), and posts AFFILIATE links?

Translation: the only reason most of these site posts "reviews" is because they are offered commission by that software maker.

 

[jazz1]

You do know that iMore and most sites that review the cleanmymac junk ware only post it because they are approached by the software maker, gets FREE copy of the software (offered by the software maker), and posts AFFILIATE links?

Translation: the only reason most of these site posts "reviews" is because they are offered commission by that software maker.

I certainly "read between the lines" regarding such practices. As a long time buyer of this software I can state, and have stated, this software works great for me.

BTW I also see a lot of comments about the viability of plain old anti-malware software. Some of it, itself malware (being called out in those reviews). How is that for horrible irony?

But I do use reviews to help me find what is legitimate to keep my iMacs running. Same for ad blockers. Running a computer these days without utilities is every user's decision. The more information about them the better.

Buyer beware on reviews is always a good thing. Some reviews are so "sweet" the red flag does go up. Thank you for pointing this out.

 

[Hawk2Wind]

So do i Jazz 1 as in HIFI reviews i read behind the lines.The CleanMyMacx works fine for me. I understand that with Onyx you have to be more knowlageable and know what to delate,where as CleanMyMacx does it all for you ,whichsuits me.
[doublepost=1544979676][/doublepost]Just add to my last posting i watch the very knowlogeable Mac classes with David.A.Cox that i watched when i first got my Mac just over a year ago.I
don,t know weather he has done one on On yX

 

[jazz1]

So do i Jazz 1 as in HIFI reviews i read behind the lines.The CleanMyMacx works fine for me. I understand that with Onyx you have to be more knowlageable and know what to delate,where as CleanMyMacx does it all for you ,whichsuits me.
[doublepost=1544979676][/doublepost]Just add to my last posting i watch the very knowlogeable Mac classes with David.A.Cox that i watched when i first got my Mac just over a year ago.I
don,t know weather he has done one on On yX

Thanks for pointing me to David A. Cox's You Tube videos. I found this one very helpful.

 

[Hawk2Wind]

H everyone I have been using CleanMyMac for just over a year now and have had no problems with it and would recommend it. I also have the Appcleaner no one should be without it.

[doublepost=1545331795][/doublepost]Hi. everyone I went to the Apple store today, about my Bluetooth connection, and the woman said CleanMyMacx said CleanMyMacx was malwarei totally disagree with her I go with David David A.Fox, did she get mixed up Mac Keeper is malware.

 

[jazz1]

[doublepost=1545331795][/doublepost]Hi. everyone I went to the Apple store today, about my Bluetooth connection, and the woman said CleanMyMacx said CleanMyMacx was malwarei totally disagree with her I go with David David A.Fox, did she get mixed up Mac Keeper is malware.

I think the Apple Rep. is giving "mal-advice" . Maybe that woman is "Mal-adjusted

I've never read anything that identified CleanMyMac as malware. I've been using the various versions for a long time on multiple iMacs and MacBooks (at work and home). Works great for me. I'd like to see what the developers could do with an iOS version.

Yes, I know there are built-in iOS based "cleaning" strategies under "settings". But what about junk building in iOS operating system somewhere. A clean install is one option I guess.

If someone can point to a reliable source identifying this software as malware I'd like to know about it.

 

[sracer]

[doublepost=1545331795][/doublepost]Hi. everyone I went to the Apple store today, about my Bluetooth connection, and the woman said CleanMyMacx said CleanMyMacx was malwarei totally disagree with her I go with David David A.Fox, did she get mixed up Mac Keeper is malware.

I've been using CleanMyMac for years to great results. My systems have been lean and mean without even the slightest hiccup.

That woman most likely didn't confuse CleanMyMac with Mac Keeper. It is hip for the "cool kids club" to diss CleanMyMac. It makes them sound like they're "in the know".

 

[SaSaSushi]

It is hip for the "cool kids club" to diss CleanMyMac. It makes them sound like they're "in the know".

All I did was quote from a review one of the CleanMyMac fans posted a link to. Does that qualify me? I want in the club!

 

[Hawk2Wind]

From the iMore review:

It's not the cheapest software around at a retail price of about $90 for a one-time purchase or $40 per year for the subscription. Everything that you can do using CleanMyMac, you can do yourself if you know your Mac well and aren't afraid of Terminal.

 

[jtara]

I'm wary of any application or website that has "My" in it.

 

[infantrytrophy]

Excellent utility.
... But it really shines when I use it to clean up a friend's machine before upgrading their hard drive to an SSD or larger SSD, and I am often able to use it to fix nagging annoyances ...

If I understand correctly, you use CleanMyMacX on your machine and on another computer as well? Are you buying separate copies, or is there some kind of free one-time use for another computer available?

And thanks for your comments. I have used CleanMyMacX without a problem, as a part of the SetApp selection of apps. After years of many OS X (and macOS) updates in my first Mac, then a replacement, my computer seemed slower that it had been previously - especially the Mail app. I did a backup, then used CleanMyMacX. The result was noticeable - faster general operation, faster app launches, faster Mail app, and more free disk space.

I was leery of using any of these Mac "cleanup" apps. The app MacKeeper, for example has a terrible reputation and is junk and probably malware/adware, in my opinion. I have seen firsthand the mess it made in a friend's Mac. Could some of those who posted comments above be confusing MacKeeper with the more reputable CleanMyMacX? I tried CleanMyMacX only after seeing recommendations from trusted sources (I think one of the sources was the podcast Mac Power Users).

I can also recommend the app Appcleaner from Freemacsoft. It is a simple, small-footprint app used for deleting apps and their accompanying "helper" files scattered about your Mac.

I have no relationship with CleanMyMacX or Appcleaner developers, or any app developers. I'm just a satisfied user and want to clear up some conflicting information.

 

[Hawk2Wind]

No, it isn't,t .yes you are right there but you have to know what you're doing. I am not a Tech person my self.

If I understand correctly, you use CleanMyMacX on your machine and on another computer as well? Are you buying separate copies, or is there some kind of free one-time use for another computer available?

And thanks for your comments. I have used CleanMyMacX without a problem, as a part of the SetApp selection of apps. After years of many OS X (and macOS) updates in my first Mac, then a replacement, my computer seemed slower that it had been previously - especially the Mail app. I did a backup, then used CleanMyMacX. The result was noticeable - faster general operation, faster app launches, faster Mail app, and more free disk space.

I was leery of using any of these Mac "cleanup" apps. The app MacKeeper, for example has a terrible reputation and is junk and probably malware/adware, in my opinion. I have seen firsthand the mess it made in a friend's Mac. Could some of those who posted comments above be confusing MacKeeper with the more reputable CleanMyMacX? I tried CleanMyMacX only after seeing recommendations from trusted sources (I think one of the sources was the podcast Mac Power Users).

I can also recommend the app Appcleaner from Freemacsoft. It is a simple, small-footprint app used for deleting apps and their accompanying "helper" files scattered about your Mac.

I have no relationship with CleanMyMacX or Appcleaner developers, or any app developers. I'm just a satisfied user and want to clear up some conflicting information.

[doublepost=1545414218][/doublepost]There is no way you can put it on more than one computer with out upgrading to have it on more than one computer.There are lots of fans of it. The people who are more tech savey anmddon,t beleave you should use APPS like that but i bet they have App Cleaner everyone should. And also
MALWAREBYTES both estental apps for Mac
[doublepost=1545414438][/doublepost]

No, it isn't,t .yes you are right there but you have to know what you're doing. I am not a Tech person my self.

[doublepost=1545414218][/doublepost]There is no way you can put it on more than one computer with out upgrading to have it on more than one computer.There are lots of fans of it. The people who are more tech savey anmddon,t beleave you should use APPS like that but i bet they have App Cleaner everyone should. And also
MALWAREBYTES both estental apps for Mac

[doublepost=1545415052][/doublepost]i had that terrible message saying i had been affected. i run the CleanMyMacx it cleaned my Mac ,but after reading a review of CleanMyMacx where they stated that it fell down on the Malware removeal ,thats when i decided to down load MALWAREBYTES needles to say it found nothing there.

 

[Hawk2Wind]

I think the Apple Rep. is giving "mal-advice" . Maybe that woman is "Mal-adjusted

I've never read anything that identified CleanMyMac as malware. I've been using the various versions for a long time on multiple iMacs and MacBooks (at work and home). Works great for me. I'd like to see what the developers could do with an iOS version.

Yes, I know there are built-in iOS based "cleaning" strategies under "settings". But what about junk building in iOS operating system somewhere. A clean install is one option I guess.

If someone can point to a reliable source identifying this software as malware I'd like to know about it.

[doublepost=1545418425][/doublepost]I think they think they are holier than thou.If they work there they must know all about Mac,s.After she told me the CleanmyMACX was malware, she did a scan with MALWAREBYTES she seemed surprised that my mac Was clean. Having said that she told me to switch the WHFI ON and that is the way to connect Bluetooth was still not connected.i had problems connecting to WHFI IT KEPT ON GETTING DISCONNECTED, BTWHFI .ON FON apparently its free to BT . customers.

 

[acader]

Thanks, but I'm fine with the command line.

As for knock yourself out, I offer that same advice to those who'd spend $40 a year for an app that doesn't do anything they can't do for themselves with the bonus of learning something new in the process.

Its great to do stuff on the command line. But not every user can do a ps -ef | grep something and kill 13949. There has to be a way by which the common folks can also enjoy their device without being bogged down. That's where GUI wrappers come into play. Yes, I am a user of CMM to the extent that I know what I am doing. I control usage of the utility and not the other way round.

 

[ysf.elansary]

Hello,

Anyone using the program: "CleanMyMac X" ?

Effective ?
Safe ?
Worth $40 ?

I am most interested in speeding up the switching between W10 via Bootcamp, and back to the Mac OS.

Not particularly interested in claiming more HD space; have plenty.
Only would hope for a betterment in speed.

Any thoughts on CleanMyMac X would be most appreciated.

Thanks,
Bob

I have cleanmymac
Safe and clean

 

[Sadomacoist]

I'll just say this. Today I DL'd CMM from AppStore. Cleaned a few files. Then it asked for upgrade to paid version. I balked and attempted to close app. It would not close and my machine froze. I tried to reboot and it has yet to come up. I should have just cleaned my cache by hand.

 

[smirking]

I'll just say this. Today I DL'd CMM from AppStore. Cleaned a few files. Then it asked for upgrade to paid version. I balked and attempted to close app. It would not close and my machine froze. I tried to reboot and it has yet to come up. I should have just cleaned my cache by hand.

If you want to purge kruft that's built up in your filesystem, you can do it for free. Start with clicking the Manage button from the Storage tab of "About This Mac".



That'll help you hunt down the usual suspects, but you might still have programs that save excessive backups and never delete them. For that, I'd recommend OmniDiskSweeper. It doesn't make any judgements as to what's junk or not, but it helps you zero in on folders that are suspiciously large.