Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Apple_Robert

Contributor
Sep 21, 2012
35,645
52,423
In a van down by the river
That’s what I wanted to do… just wondering the exact steps you took as I tried it several times yesterday… both from my iPad and iPhone running 18.1
It would allow me to set my alias as the primary email… (and it would show my Alias email as my Primary Apple Account email), however…. Mail stopped working correctly both in the mail app, and iCloud Webmail. It wouldn’t let me delete, send or open emails. With various error messages coming up…


When I looked at the mail settings it was still showing my original iCloud email as my primary (so conflicted with what my Apple account was showing).

Apple support said others reported the same.

I’m wondering, as my original iCloud email also has a @me.com email whether that is causing issues?

The only way to get mail working again was to revert the Primary back to my normal iCloud email (not the alias).
Did you try wiping the devices and logging in with the new primary account ?
 

Sami13496

macrumors 6502a
Jul 25, 2022
692
1,527
I did this: https://support.apple.com/en-us/109353

And it went great. Old email myfirstname.myoldlastname@icloud.com is gone and I successfully added new myfirstname.mynewlastname@icloud.com address. Also checked account.apple.com on browser and the old address was gone, new address is there. So it seems that old address is gone from the account just like I wanted.

But. When I go to iMessage or FaceTime settings the old address is still in the list under “You can be reached at”. :rolleyes:

Any idea why? I tried to delete FaceTime app and download it again, didn’t help.
 

Cliantyeo

macrumors newbie
Sep 23, 2023
5
1
I did try again this morning (following Apples guide above), and still the same (worse if anything) - I'm sure when I did it the other day my changed address showed everywhere apart from in iCloud Mail - however, this time it was still showing my original email everywhere.

As soon as I change it, mail everywhere stops working both on iPhone, iPad, Mac and web iCloud.
Mac shows the mailbox as offline (I've tried turning mail off after 20 secs and back on like someone else posted - but didn't have any affect).

It's frustrating that it doesn't 'just work', and worse that it actually causes things to break.

My situation is trying to change oldemailaddress@icloud.com to my (long standing) myalias@icloud.com

One thing which I think may be getting in the way, when looking in Mail I have:
oldemailaddress@icloud.com
oldemailaddress@me.com
basically showing as one thing... I'm not sure if that's the issue.

When changing the Primary back to oldemailaddress@icloud.com mail starts working again fine.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: roronl

ZEEN0j

macrumors 68000
Sep 29, 2014
1,569
721
That’s what I wanted to do… just wondering the exact steps you took as I tried it several times yesterday… both from my iPad and iPhone running 18.1
It would allow me to set my alias as the primary email… (and it would show my Alias email as my Primary Apple Account email), however…. Mail stopped working correctly both in the mail app, and iCloud Webmail. It wouldn’t let me delete, send or open emails. With various error messages coming up…


When I looked at the mail settings it was still showing my original iCloud email as my primary (so conflicted with what my Apple account was showing).

Apple support said others reported the same.

I’m wondering, as my original iCloud email also has a @me.com email whether that is causing issues?

The only way to get mail working again was to revert the Primary back to my normal iCloud email (not the alias).

All I did was (my phone is not set to English)

Open settings
Tap your name
Sign in and security
In the top list I tapped my alias and checked the box setting it as my primary
Then I deleted my old primary email from this list
Then opened iCloud settings
Tap mail
Account information - emails/addresses
In here I could still see my old primary so I deleted it here as well

I've had no issues with sending or receiving emails. No idea if other combinations of account creations could be the cause of some people still having issues. Before 18.1 released I got an error after step 4.
 

ZEEN0j

macrumors 68000
Sep 29, 2014
1,569
721
I did this: https://support.apple.com/en-us/109353

And it went great. Old email myfirstname.myoldlastname@icloud.com is gone and I successfully added new myfirstname.mynewlastname@icloud.com address. Also checked account.apple.com on browser and the old address was gone, new address is there. So it seems that old address is gone from the account just like I wanted.

But. When I go to iMessage or FaceTime settings the old address is still in the list under “You can be reached at”. :rolleyes:

Any idea why? I tried to delete FaceTime app and download it again, didn’t help.
Check my steps above. I think I had the same issue and that's the reason I deleted the old primary from iCloud mail settings.
 

Cliantyeo

macrumors newbie
Sep 23, 2023
5
1
All I did was (my phone is not set to English)

Open settings
Tap your name
Sign in and security
In the top list I tapped my alias and checked the box setting it as my primary
Then I deleted my old primary email from this list
Then opened iCloud settings
Tap mail
Account information - emails/addresses
In here I could still see my old primary so I deleted it here as well

I've had no issues with sending or receiving emails. No idea if other combinations of account creations could be the cause of some people still having issues. Before 18.1 released I got an error after step 4.

Thank you…. The only thing I didn’t do was delete my original iCloud address, I guess I’m worried if I do that and it doesn’t work then I may stop everyth8mg working and/or get locked out of my account completely.
 

Sami13496

macrumors 6502a
Jul 25, 2022
692
1,527
Check my steps above. I think I had the same issue and that's the reason I deleted the old primary from iCloud mail settings.
Thanks. Very interesting. I didn't have old primary under iCloud>Mail>Account information>Addresses. But still when I go to iMessage or FaceTime settings the old address is still in the list under “You can be reached at”. Very strange.
 

Sami13496

macrumors 6502a
Jul 25, 2022
692
1,527
Hey, actually, this just resolved itself after I went online with my iPad and Mac. Apparently, since those devices still had the old information (while offline), things showed up a bit mixed in the iMessage and FaceTime settings on my iPhone. But once those devices connected to the internet and everything synced, the old address no longer shows up in the iMessage or FaceTime settings. Yay!
 
  • Like
Reactions: DCIFRTHS
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.