Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Do you want the colored Finder (and iTunes) icons back?


  • Total voters
    401

Major.Robto

macrumors 6502
May 11, 2012
286
0
Amen. All this texting, IM'ing, social networking - it's created/ing a generation of anti-social individuals. I'm only 35, and I've seen it tremendously, especially with H.R. departments having difficulty in hiring individuals with reasonable social skills. Technology should be an extension of humanity, not in lieu of humanity.

On the weekends, I make it a rule to avoid as much tech as possible, it's amazing how much of the world is unnoticed when you're buried into your smart phones and notebooks.

I turn my phone off at 6pm, I may be on the web late, but I never go on lame book or this social networking junk, I work on writing and stuff, and do important things to me,

social networking is a waist of time for a software pirate who is also a data horder...yes I hord data...yeah thats a bit of a problem....

I hate my generation, they don't even know what good music is, and all they lissen to is that rap trash. how the hell is that music? or that beaber girl, also who cares about the "stars" in hollywood? it seems ever one but me.... never seen the imortance of staking people online like most kids my age do.

back to the topic...I like finders new looks.
 

blow45

macrumors 68000
Jan 18, 2011
1,576
0
I use the bar all the time,

I know what the icon looks like, the colour bothered me more to be honest

also if i need to I can read what its called...

its not hard to read.

It isn't but the point of the colour cue is to avoid going that extra step, of course if the colour there bothers you in some way you I can understand how grey is much more preferable to you. :)

In any case that clearly signals to me, once more, how apple should offer a system wide option for this. Such a simple to implement ui choice that splits the users in terms of their preferences shouldn't go without an option. Actually is there's one thing that needs an option it's when users are 50-50% on what they prefer the best, all the more so if one 50% (and here it's the colour side) are vehemently in favour of it and feel it impacts on their work to a great extent.

Sadly, like I ve said before, this is clearly an ego thing for some ui designer here. It's not the same as ical or contacts gaining the ios look that people complain about that could be put down to marketing, and, although i don't believe so, one could claim it will lead to more mac sales. It's not the matte vs. glass issue where the choice was harder to implement at no cost or to no strong visual impact on the macs. It's not something even that gives some particular type of branding or look about os x.

There's hardly any reason why the user shouldn't be able to select if they do want colour in the sidebars (or for that matter on the dreadful monochrome icons in mail, safari etc.) or not. People are going to the lengths of installing a system hack that impacts the performance on their machines to get colour on their mac (and hopefully sandboxing via the app store and the like, won't kill simbl...), that means a lot of people (myself included) really do need it, not just want it.

----------

Amen. All this texting, IM'ing, social networking - it's created/ing a generation of anti-social individuals. I'm only 35, and I've seen it tremendously, especially with H.R. departments having difficulty in hiring individuals with reasonable social skills. Technology should be an extension of humanity, not in lieu of humanity.

On the weekends, I make it a rule to avoid as much tech as possible, it's amazing how much of the world is unnoticed when you're buried into your smart phones and notebooks.

amen to that. I will have to follow your rule. I done tech free weeks before, but it's not easy, whoever claims there isnt an element of addiction there are simply lying to themselves. I ditched my iphone for this very reason for the crappiest phone one could own. Such freedom to not have to google things up, or compulsively check emails. I m 33 btw, you don't know how many times I 've been at a waiting room, or in a doctors office and I wanted to flirt with a girl and she wouldn't let here eyes off the phone. It's kinda sad the world we leave in when a girl is texting her friend on facebook and is avoiding what's happening here and now in the real world.

----------

I turn my phone off at 6pm, I may be on the web late, but I never go on lame book or this social networking junk, I work on writing and stuff, and do important things to me,

social networking is a waist of time for a software pirate who is also a data horder...yes I hord data...yeah thats a bit of a problem....

I hate my generation, they don't even know what good music is, and all they lissen to is that rap trash. how the hell is that music? or that beaber girl, also who cares about the "stars" in hollywood? it seems ever one but me.... never seen the important of staking people online like most kids my age do.

back to the topic...I like finders new looks.
I hate most current music too, and I hoard data like crazy. The house might look clean and tidy with less stuff than most, but boy are these hard drives full with whatever piece of knowledge or entertainment I can get my hands on.
 

TheGdog

macrumors 6502
Sep 4, 2010
319
55
North Carolina, USA
Amen. All this texting, IM'ing, social networking - it's created/ing a generation of anti-social individuals. I'm only 35, and I've seen it tremendously, especially with H.R. departments having difficulty in hiring individuals with reasonable social skills. Technology should be an extension of humanity, not in lieu of humanity.

On the weekends, I make it a rule to avoid as much tech as possible, it's amazing how much of the world is unnoticed when you're buried into your smart phones and notebooks.

I agree! As much and as enjoy and work with technology (its 99% of my job) nothing beats time with friends, family and coworkers. People are what make my week enjoyable, not stuff.

I do find it hard to spend time away from technology sometimes, after all I enjoy it. But I often have to tell myself to put down the phone when I am at lunch with people or close the computer when others are talking to me. its hard for sure, but worth it!.
 

Major.Robto

macrumors 6502
May 11, 2012
286
0
I hate most current music too, and I hoard data like crazy. The house might look clean and tidy with less stuff than most, but boy are these hard drives full with whatever piece of knowledge or entertainment I can get my hands on.

Yeah, I am in the need of a Fourth hard-rive and need a fifth just because I don't have a timecapsoul drive running yet.


My room is super clean also, so well, I doubt we would be eligible for that show hoarders as they don't take on people with mass amounts of data....God reality tv sucks....

Well, I'm going back to my pinkfloyd
also, I know this is way off topic
 

WhackyNinja

macrumors 68000
Jul 6, 2012
1,843
497
Kissimmee, FL
Im a new Mac user, and I started with Lion. So I've never had Mac OS X with the colored icons on the side bar but I will love to see them come back
 

Vorlox

macrumors newbie
May 1, 2012
7
0
I want them back, but you know apple :( OS X will never look as good a it did in tiger, it's still pretty, It''s just not the same!

vi-K6gFJm.png
 

JDrive

macrumors member
Jun 3, 2010
38
3
I migrated to Mac from Windows during the tiger era with a Powerbook G4. I really miss the colorful, "lickable" look of Aqua. Even then, Tiger was more Aqua conservative than 10.2 and earlier when OS X made heavy use of pinstriped titlebars and window backgrounds. I do like the direction apple took with the soft grey windows, but I am kind of worried about the use of monochrome icons. I understand that Apple wants OS X to look and feel more like iOS, but these icons do make it harder to distinguish between different places in Finder.
 

macdatadrive

macrumors regular
Apr 25, 2011
126
0
The city of Macintosh :)
IMHO, I quite like the grey icons. I think some colour is good, but Lion is becoming more refined. I do think though that Apple should give us a choice on whether we want colour or not.
I must say though, there are little touches of colour is you just look around ;D
 

blow45

macrumors 68000
Jan 18, 2011
1,576
0
I migrated to Mac from Windows during the tiger era with a Powerbook G4. I really miss the colorful, "lickable" look of Aqua. Even then, Tiger was more Aqua conservative than 10.2 and earlier when OS X made heavy use of pinstriped titlebars and window backgrounds. I do like the direction apple took with the soft grey windows, but I am kind of worried about the use of monochrome icons. I understand that Apple wants OS X to look and feel more like iOS, but these icons do make it harder to distinguish between different places in Finder.

the funny thing is that despite this looking like ios myth that's been repeated by apple fanbois (and I don't mean you of course goes without saying, I mean the archetypical fanboi who ll first criticize god himself than apple) is not even accuate. Sidebars in settings and in mail for example are all very, very colourful indeed so users can distinguish between the options!!!!!!

Yes the some icons are monochrome but ios doesn't rely really so much on icons for the interface. Even some of apple's own recently released apps when they want to make them pretty usable (and not joke ios looking apps like calendar and contacts) they use a lot of colour in their icons, such as ibooks author! This is probably their most recent os x app and it's relief that it didn't go down that grey hell path.

So I guess there are two sets of mentalities in apple, one is marketing: make ical and contacts look like ios, even if ical shows much less info, even if it looks like something to be touched but there's no touch interface on the mac and the other is make ibooks author have vivid colour cues cause if we grey it out no one will be adopting it for use. All that is very sad of course because it clearly shows a lack of leadership in os x.

The nasty thing that's happening is that some of the devs have taken this monochrome cue and are crapping up on app after the other. Boy will it look great when most of our apps will have a grey bar on top, with all grey icons...ugghhhh:rolleyes:

----------

IMHO, I quite like the grey icons. I think some colour is good, but Lion is becoming more refined. I do think though that Apple should give us a choice on whether we want colour or not.
I must say though, there are little touches of colour is you just look around ;D

They should grey out the dock while they are at it, so instead of the os looking like mismatched crap, it will look like matching crap :D, who needs colour cues anyway shapes are easier to tell apart :)rolleyes:)
 

innominato5090

macrumors 6502
Sep 4, 2009
452
71
of course they are poorly designed, and the other guy has some nerve to tell you where to spend your money...:rolleyes:

I just wish I could kick the heck out of the finder from the left hand corner of the dock...

it's not a poor design: their bright colors used to distract the user from the main content of the window, i.e. the user's files.

I found the grey user a big improvement!
 

Cougarcat

macrumors 604
Sep 19, 2003
7,766
2,554
it's not a poor design: their bright colors used to distract the user from the main content of the window, i.e. the user's files.

I found the grey user a big improvement!

The problem with that logic is that the sidebar is my content.
 

Ddyracer

macrumors 68000
Nov 24, 2009
1,786
31
Just tried this on the released 10.8. Worked perfectly, and it's so much better than the grey icons.

It is better. Unfortunatley, it isnt fully colored like it is in SL. Opening finder dialog boxes windows doesn't support color.
 

bcasey25raptor

macrumors newbie
Jul 31, 2012
4
0
St john's newfoundland
I'm new to apple (as in i have only had a mac for 4 months) but i have't really noticed enough to care. It still looks way better then any windows interface. However i do like color and it is unfortunate apple took that out.


 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.