MBP redesign is technically overdue....
the rock said:
So, what is your problem with the current MBP design? I think it is absolutely stunning, and way better than any other competitor. BTW, most, if not all parts, of the MBP is redesigned compared to the PB.
MBP redesign is technically overdue.... from an engineering point of view!
Here is why:
ONE. there seem to be engineering flaws in the design. The metal frame around
the screen is not stiff enough. thatresults in a wobbling motion of the screen I have noticed with all PBs and MBPs. Everyone owning one can try this:
take a piece of paper maybe 2 inches wide, bend the open screen slightly backwards, then insert the paper in the bottom of the screen, let go, and the paper is trapped. This also happens with dust. It gets trapped there... To solve this the frame must be at least double in thickness (maybe 1 mm) to stiffen it. ALso the hinge itself is too flimsy.
I own an IBM and Toshiba laptop. There is no wobble and this even though the frame is plastic. It is clearly an engineering design flaw on the APPLEs.
TWO, the plate surrounding the keyboard and the pad is plastic, and I have noticed scratches on those which are really in use by their owners...
THREE, I envision a complete redesign using carbon fiber. Actually ASUS uses carbon on 2 or three models. Very nice.
FOUR: I find the quality control of ASUS TEC sloppy. And APPLE MUST stop this ASAP. A complete redesign would allow implication of better standards in terms of quality and control of same.
Software, OS is A1, hardware and quality is soso. That is not good enough, given the price tag.
It is true, the design of the old PBs and the (same) of the new MBPs is very nice.