c2d mbp's batteries usually last 3 hours and maybe a few minutes more on a full charge so your battery is probably okay...the chip on it might not be functioning correctly to report the accurate health though.
Yeah, I think that's what's happening here. I woke my MBP from safe sleep this morning and the batt's saying it only has 4500 mAh available to it.
I'll just watch it over the coming weeks. I plan to get a second batt anyway and in the meantime I'll turn Bluetooth off and measure my uptime on this one.