Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Super Real

macrumors member
Original poster
Jun 18, 2021
51
11
Brave vs Firefox vs Tor vs Opera vs…
Which do you think is the best desktop browser for online banking/shopping?

Please forget about antivirus softwares for now, just let me know which browser(s) you think best or better for online banking/shopping.

Thank you in advance.

Some recommend:

Brave (guards you by blocking attempts to track or collect your information)

Firefox (light and fast with great basic protection, doesn’t gather your data)

Tor (slow but with onion-like multi security layers)

Opera (with more frequent security updates, offers a built-in VPN)


Or do I need a paid VPN app for more security?

VPNs
 

KaliYoni

macrumors 68000
Feb 19, 2016
1,794
3,945
I have a 2-browser setup. I use Firefox with privacy and security add-ons for general browsing. I use Safari in its default configuration for a very small number of trusted websites I visit regularly. This compartmentalizes my browsing and helps keep sensitive browsing separate from daily browsing.

I don't think it matters much which browsers you choose. I went with Firefox because it is widely used and open source, which means there are lots of eyes watching how it works, and because it is free. I continue using Safari because it is highly integrated with macOS and Apple consistently provides updates for it.

I've looked at VPNs several times and for the way I use my computers, tablets, and phones, I don't think using one would add much security. But if I used public Wi-Fi, hotel Wi-Fi, or did sensitive tasks on my iOS devices, I definitely would subscribe to a VPN service.

Firefox add-ons I use:
  • Adblock Plus
  • Disconnect
  • Ghostery
  • Google Analytics Opt-out
  • NoScript
  • Privacy Badger
A good article on VPNs:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Super Real

Super Real

macrumors member
Original poster
Jun 18, 2021
51
11
I have a 2-browser setup. I use Firefox with privacy and security add-ons for general browsing. I use Safari in its default configuration for a very small number of trusted websites I visit regularly. This compartmentalizes my browsing and helps keep sensitive browsing separate from daily browsing.

I don't think it matters much which browsers you choose. I went with Firefox because it is widely used and open source, which means there are lots of eyes watching how it works, and because it is free. I continue using Safari because it is highly integrated with macOS and Apple consistently provides updates for it.

I've looked at VPNs several times and for the way I use my computers, tablets, and phones, I don't think using one would add much security. But if I used public Wi-Fi, hotel Wi-Fi, or did sensitive tasks on my iOS devices, I definitely would subscribe to a VPN service.

Firefox add-ons I use:
  • Adblock Plus
  • Disconnect
  • Ghostery
  • Google Analytics Opt-out
  • NoScript
  • Privacy Badger
A good article on VPNs:
Thank you very much for your time, KaliYoni.
I have currently used Brave for online payment and Chrome for general use (it seems that Chrome is the only browser to allow us non native English speakers the whole web page translation system which I need lately), but I'm still interested in FireFox.
You said you don't think which browser you choose doesn't matter though, still I would like to ask you if FireFox is better than Brave.
And also I'd appreciate much if you could tell me what is the advantage of Mullvad compared to ExpressVPN (please take the last link on my OP).
Thank you and have a great day,
SR
 

vs40

macrumors member
Jan 9, 2016
74
85
Opera (with more frequent security updates, offers a built-in VPN)
I don't trust Opera in terms of privacy, because by default they silently put referral links to amazon/ebay/booking/etc in to your recommendations.
And worst part is, they watching your activity on those sites and can put some link on item, which you put in cart, but didn't ordered.
 

firedept

macrumors 603
Jul 8, 2011
6,278
1,130
Somewhere!
I don't do any banking except from the banks own app. I tend to do my banking in person as my bank is only a five minute walk from home. Maybe I like the old school feel.
 

KALLT

macrumors 603
Sep 23, 2008
5,380
3,415
I do not really see a point in using different browsers for different activities, at least not for security purposes. Any of the mainstream browsers provide ample security and to a varying degree privacy by blocking trackers. Any of these browsers can be figured to block ads/trackers and discard cookies. The links given by the OP are not persuasive let alone particularly credible and the reasons for the recommendations there are barely explained.

I would instead focus on the sites you are visiting and verify whether they are trustworthy, e.g. by checking if they use HTTPS, secure payment methods, have a privacy policy, have decent customer service and so forth.

A VPN is not as beneficial anymore since HTTPS became the norm, it potentially adds needless risk (cf. the problems with Tor linked above). I would avoid them, unless you have a reason to distrust your own network provider more than a remote VPN provider.
 
Last edited:

KaliYoni

macrumors 68000
Feb 19, 2016
1,794
3,945
You said you don't think which browser you choose doesn't matter though, still I would like to ask you if FireFox is better than Brave.
And also I'd appreciate much if you could tell me what is the advantage of Mullvad compared to ExpressVPN (please take the last link on my OP).
If Brave is based on Chrome, I would prefer Firefox. Most Chrome-based browsers maintain some links to Google. I try to minimize how much I use Google products and how much data I send to Google. Also, I like diversification for risk management (yeah, I'm a finance freak) so in your case, Firefox would probably keep you to one Chrome-based browser.

The link in my post above has an extensive discussion and comparison of many VPNs, including Mullvad and ExpressVPN.

us non native English speakers
If you are posting here without using a translation site or app, your writing in English is clear and easy to understand.
:)
(what is your first language, if you don't mind my asking?)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Super Real

Super Real

macrumors member
Original poster
Jun 18, 2021
51
11
The link in my post above has an extensive discussion and comparison of many VPNs, including Mullvad and ExpressVPN.
Oh I didn't see ExpressVPN in your link.
I asked about ExpressVPN, because it has earned a better reputation than others.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KaliYoni

Super Real

macrumors member
Original poster
Jun 18, 2021
51
11
If you are posting here without using a translation site or app, your writing in English is clear and easy to understand.
:)
(what is your first language, if you don't mind my asking?)
I'm from Japan, and don't use any translation system to write a comment here because it's almost useless (there is a big grammatical wall between the two languages). Still I need Google Chrome's whole page translation system which helps me know if it's an error or a valid phrase worth learning when I happen to meet an article or a post which uses lots of unique/unknown wordings. The page translation system on Chrome is the best for the purpose for me. If FireFox had the function, I would have taken it as my #1.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AppleSmack

KaliYoni

macrumors 68000
Feb 19, 2016
1,794
3,945
I asked about ExpressVPN, because it has earned a better reputation than others.
You are correct: ExpressVPN isn't rated in that article. My mistake, I'm sorry.

The article does mention something that sounds good:
"ExpressVPN was unable to provide logs to Turkish authorities, who raided the data center and took the company’s Turkey server but found no logs or customer data."

But the reason ExpressVPN wasn't rated is:
"We dismissed ExpressVPN and Surfshark for not being public about their ownership or leadership."

So if you agree with the criteria Wirecutter uses to evaluate VPNs, it looks like ExpressVPN might not be the best choice.

there is a big grammatical wall between the two languages
I watch NHK World and it has a show called "Easy Japanese". The funny thing to me is that as a native English speaker, the way the show tries to teach Japanese is anything but easy! And yes, the differences in grammar between Japanese and English do seem to be pretty significant. So your skill in writing in English is impressive to me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Super Real

Super Real

macrumors member
Original poster
Jun 18, 2021
51
11
You are correct: ExpressVPN isn't rated in that article. My mistake, I'm sorry.

The article does mention something that sounds good:
"ExpressVPN was unable to provide logs to Turkish authorities, who raided the data center and took the company’s Turkey server but found no logs or customer data."

But the reason ExpressVPN wasn't rated is:
"We dismissed ExpressVPN and Surfshark for not being public about their ownership or leadership."

So if you agree with the criteria Wirecutter uses to evaluate VPNs, it looks like ExpressVPN might not be the best choice.


I watch NHK World and it has a show called "Easy Japanese". The funny thing to me is that as a native English speaker, the way the show tries to teach Japanese is anything but easy! And yes, the differences in grammar between Japanese and English do seem to be pretty significant. So your skill in writing in English is impressive to me.
Thank you very much for the info and tips for choosing the VPN.
As for the language barrier between English and Japanese, you can see it by using Google Translate. You seldom get good results on it. It would be acceptable at times when done from easy Japanese into easy English, but almost no chance in the opposite way. Still Chrome's page translating system is helpful in differentiating between errors and the English words/phrases/slangs which I have to learn.
 
Last edited:

theMarble

macrumors 65816
Sep 27, 2020
1,023
1,509
Earth, Sol System, Alpha Quadrant
Brave vs Firefox vs Tor vs Opera vs…
Which do you think is the best desktop browser for online banking/shopping?

Please forget about antivirus softwares for now, just let me know which browser(s) you think best or better for online banking/shopping.

Thank you in advance.

Some recommend:

Brave (guards you by blocking attempts to track or collect your information)

Firefox (light and fast with great basic protection, doesn’t gather your data)

Tor (slow but with onion-like multi security layers)

Opera (with more frequent security updates, offers a built-in VPN)


Or do I need a paid VPN app for more security?

VPNs
I personally use Firefox (Firefox Stable for secure sites and Nightly for main-use) as my main browser on all of my modern machines (Mac, PC and Linux) as I find it to be more stable and secure overall than all of the Chromium based browsers (Chrome, Vivaldi, Opera, Brave) and there are good extensions that you can use (KaliYoni mentioned some of those higher up in this thread) however I still do use a VPN if I need more privacy or security than what Firefox can offer to me.
 

killhippie

macrumors 6502a
Jan 12, 2016
691
755
UK
Firefox with uBlock Origin, better I think than adblock plus as it has many more filters but uses less memory and slips past sites that notice most adblockers and you can use it for so much more than ad blocking and Privacy Badger, disconnect is built in anyway, then Firefox Containers and the browser in strict mode, that works well for me. Safari rarely gets used but that's just using what I feel works for my needs we all like different things for different reasons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Super Real

theSeb

macrumors 604
Aug 10, 2010
7,466
1,893
none
Get virtualisation software such as virtual box or vmware fusion. Create a virtual machine on your Mac and install Linux on it. Then install virtualisation software on the Linux virtual machine and install Chrome OS on this virtual machine. Now power all of the virtual machines down and take a snapshot of the first virtual machine that you created (Linux).

Power up your Chrome OS virtual machine after you have powered up your Linux virtual machine. Now you are ready to do internet banking safely, but ensure that you are using multiple VPNs to connect to the internet and that your computer is connected to the router via an Ethernet cable. Do not use wifi to be 100% safe.

Once you have finished your internet banking power everything down and restore VM1 from snapshot. This way you will always have a completely clean and safe environment for internet banking.

A much simpler good rule to follow is to use one browser for the important stuff like internet banking. Do not use that browser for general browsing. The other option is to just use your bank's app on your iPhone and enable biometric log on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Super Real

Super Real

macrumors member
Original poster
Jun 18, 2021
51
11
A much simpler good rule to follow is to use one browser for the important stuff like internet banking. Do not use that browser for general browsing.
Yes, I created this thread on that condition (sorry, I should have wrote that clearly).
Which browser could you recommend me for that purpose?
 

Super Real

macrumors member
Original poster
Jun 18, 2021
51
11
The other option is to just use your bank's app on your iPhone and enable biometric log on.
My new SE2020 will be delivered this week, so I'd consider this as a great option though I'm not very good at using smartphone (and am worried about losing it...).

Thank you very much for the great lecture, theSeb.
 

theSeb

macrumors 604
Aug 10, 2010
7,466
1,893
none
Yes, I created this thread on that condition (sorry, I should have wrote that clearly).
Which browser could you recommend me for that purpose?
I use Safari for the important stuff and I use Brave with Duckduckgo as the search engine for general online shenanigans.
 

Super Real

macrumors member
Original poster
Jun 18, 2021
51
11
I use Safari for the important stuff and I use Brave with Duckduckgo as the search engine for general online shenanigans.
Thank you for the quick reply, may I ask you if you use Safari (exclusively) for online banking/shopping?
 

Super Real

macrumors member
Original poster
Jun 18, 2021
51
11
Does anybody know about CyberGhost (VPN)?
I'm now interested in it because it has so many base stations in my home country (Japan, but live here in the states).
I don't know if it should be a priority condition in choosing a VPN, though, I often online-shop with web stores over there.
Thank you in advance, have a great day.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.