Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

muzzy996

macrumors 65816
Feb 16, 2018
1,119
1,068
I love OneNote but I use it for my typed notes. The other thing I like in OneNote (aside of what you mentioned already) is the fact that it is way easier to share your notebooks with people. That is really helpful in work setting.

For easy sharing in Notability what I do is auto-backup to PDF format to OneDrive, from which I can share the PDF notes with other team members. Not everyone that I work with has OneNote experience so I find PDF sharing easier. OneNote has its infinite canvas setup which isn’t conducive to PDF sharing so I don’t use it. Generally I find Notability quite powerful.
 

aajeevlin

macrumors 65816
Mar 25, 2010
1,427
715
For easy sharing in Notability what I do is auto-backup to PDF format to OneDrive, from which I can share the PDF notes with other team members. Not everyone that I work with has OneNote experience so I find PDF sharing easier. OneNote has its infinite canvas setup which isn’t conducive to PDF sharing so I don’t use it. Generally I find Notability quite powerful.

I just recently got back to the iPad Pro scene. I had the first iPad pro several years ago. I actually used Notability at the time. I recalled it would sometime have issues taking in large PDF files? say 50-70MB? there was something that really bothered me at the time. I think it suffer from having hard time dealign with large pdf and writing sync issues on it? The other one I have is PDFExport. I think I got it for very cheap several years ago, just got it back last time and it still works very well.
 

muzzy996

macrumors 65816
Feb 16, 2018
1,119
1,068
Yeah I can’t really speak towards importing of large PDFs like that. I generally don’t do it, but I do import small PDFs, things like handouts and powerpoints to take notes on and don’t have any issues.

My experience with PDFs in general on the iPad is ok for general use but when I try to review plan sets (I’m a civil engineer and do roadway/utility design) that have complex topography within them things can get dicey. I’ve had some files that I just couldn’t open in various applications without major lag issues moving around. It wasn’t always a large file either though it coulld contain a TON of vectorized graphics. So yeah I know what you mean. In a pinch a few times I’d import troublesome PDFs into Notability and they’d sometimes work better (but not great).
 

secretk

macrumors 65816
Oct 19, 2018
1,494
1,229
I just recently got back to the iPad Pro scene. I had the first iPad pro several years ago. I actually used Notability at the time. I recalled it would sometime have issues taking in large PDF files? say 50-70MB? there was something that really bothered me at the time. I think it suffer from having hard time dealign with large pdf and writing sync issues on it? The other one I have is PDFExport. I think I got it for very cheap several years ago, just got it back last time and it still works very well.

Unfortunately still an issue. I tried once or twice to import such big files and it failed. I ended up with over 200! empty pages that I had to delete manually as you cannot delete multiple pages in Notability with one action. Quite annoying really.
[automerge]1594107861[/automerge]
For easy sharing in Notability what I do is auto-backup to PDF format to OneDrive, from which I can share the PDF notes with other team members. Not everyone that I work with has OneNote experience so I find PDF sharing easier. OneNote has its infinite canvas setup which isn’t conducive to PDF sharing so I don’t use it. Generally I find Notability quite powerful.

True that if you want to export in PDF OneNote is not the best option due its infinite canvas. However at work we all use OneNote so I do not need to do export. I just share the OneNote notebook itself and that's it. In this sense Notability way is slower (having to export to PDF and then share manually and you have to do it whenever something new is added).

Both have their perks and I use both apps for different purposes. OneNote is great for typing meeting minutes. You can have the template, you can use tags and add TO DOs and you can with one action share with others for the whole life cycle of the notebook. Notability is about handwritten notes that I do not need to share for example with all of my team and that I can share only once the need arises.
 

phrehdd

Contributor
Oct 25, 2008
4,508
1,463
You can for sure. I mean I use Notes but for random things where I need to jot down something quickly temporarily and then delete it.

For long term notes I prefer Notability and GoodNotes. They are not super expensive given what they offer you.

Oh I forgot to mention something actually. So for me OCR is an important feature. One of the reasons I went digital was to organize my handwritten notes better and to be able to find/access them better. Both GoodNotes and Notability have OCR, but for Notability you have to pay additionally (outside of the price you pay for installing the app). With GoodNotes OCR comes from the get go.

I am also looking for a school notes app and your cost reference for OCR got me curious. With Notability you pay once and that is it (plus an addition for OCR also a one time payment). With Goodnotes I read that every version update there is a cost. If the latter is true It may be cheaper to get the Notability + OCR app with no update costs. Would this be correct??
 

secretk

macrumors 65816
Oct 19, 2018
1,494
1,229
I am also looking for a school notes app and your cost reference for OCR got me curious. With Notability you pay once and that is it (plus an addition for OCR also a one time payment). With Goodnotes I read that every version update there is a cost. If the latter is true It may be cheaper to get the Notability + OCR app with no update costs. Would this be correct??

For the time I have been using GoodNotes there have been two versions - 4 and 5. I was able to upgrade to 5th version for free (from 4th). I might have been left with the wrong impression but the way I understood it within a certain period of time you can upgrade from older to newer version for free. After that I assume you have to pay additionally. Mind you, I was informed about the new version by pure luck (either this forum or something else) and I am not sure that I would have been able to upgrade for free if I had not stumbled upon on this.

I do not know Notability's politics when it comes to new versions. I assume that it is like you said - you pay once and then you get to use it and upgrade it.

This is definitely a factor and it needs to be checked. You mare really a great point!
 

shapesinaframe

macrumors 6502
Jan 14, 2020
255
334
i use Notes for most of my typed note taking, but if i am doing anything with the pencil I prefer to use OneNote, it lets you keep expanding the canvas, and you can edit your scribbles later on whereas Notes has a fixed size canvas and bakes anything drawn with the pencil after closing the note taking session.
 

D3ggy

macrumors 6502a
Mar 26, 2019
517
450
I quite like Noteshelf. I have been using that for some time now and have tried the others but always seem to come back to it.
 

servenvolley

macrumors member
Jan 3, 2017
87
51
South Carolina
Somebody on this forum recently suggested Nebo and I downloaded it a few days ago and I have to say that I am enjoying it. I have left-handed-chicken-scratch for handwriting and I drag my hand across the iPad when I write and the Nebo software picks it up flawlessly and changes it to type.
 

tarsins

macrumors 65816
Sep 15, 2009
1,197
859
Wales
Apple Notes should be fine unless you need to access the notes on a Windows machine in which case OneNote is excellent.
 

shapesinaframe

macrumors 6502
Jan 14, 2020
255
334
Apple Notes should be fine unless you need to access the notes on a Windows machine in which case OneNote is excellent.
I like what they did with Sticky Notes within OneNote - except they are a complete mess when you try to use them with Apple Notes.
 

BigDO

macrumors 65816
Dec 9, 2012
1,355
2,124
I use OneNote, works perfectly, integrates well into the rest of O365 workflows, makes sharing and collaborating very easy. Can’t fault it.
 

RealSkyDiver

macrumors 6502a
Jun 15, 2010
570
167
Which app comes closest to having composition books? I think GoodNote has an option where you can have different notebooks with customizable covers.
 

kenshiro

macrumors newbie
Aug 22, 2019
5
1
Jakarta Capital Region
I use Goodnotes for serious note taking, it sync on my mac which is very convenient. But more & more I also love to use Concept, especially for taking notes during meeting & such, because it has infinity canvas.
 
  • Like
Reactions: emembee

phrehdd

Contributor
Oct 25, 2008
4,508
1,463
As iPad software remains a great value...I opted to start checking out Goodnotes. I saw things in both this app and Notability that I liked. My courses are all on line and I tend to like to compartmentalize areas of study within a course and often later use quizlets or flashcards to help retain and enforce concepts and information. I may later try a couple of the other named software here. I admit I wish that they would allow a 5 day trial or something of that sort before a purchase but again, none of these really break the bank.
 

Hunter5117

macrumors 6502a
Mar 17, 2010
569
401
Personally I use Notes for all my day to day notes, and Notion as a long term project planning and task manager. I have tried Notability but with the iPadOS 14 updates, Notes does everything I need. Notion is a very interesting app, with a lot of powerful functionality. It does not use the pencil for much other than just point and click is my biggest complaint about it.
 

emembee

macrumors 6502
Oct 31, 2013
328
97
Surrey,UK
Although more for artists , I do like Concepts but it is stylus or pencil only. Infinite canvas but lined paper too with excellent colours make it easy to look nice with drawings too. Annual sub but worth it. Downside is no iCloud sync yet else satisfying to use and PDF Export works well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: azpekt and kenshiro

Allan in T.Dot

macrumors regular
Jul 14, 2010
206
37
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
I'm not pushing Paperlike (because apparently it sucks from the reviews I've read/seen) but they have a good chart that compares both your apps:

.

I've also read some issues with Notability where folks have lost ALL their notes. PAINFUL. For me, I'll probably be getting Goodnotes.

Hello! I wanted to get your advice and see what the best note taking app was to be used with the iPad Pro and the 2ng gen Apple Pencil. It will mainly be used for work. I found a couple apps, let me know your thoughts!

Notability
GoodNotes
 

BigMcGuire

Cancelled
Jan 10, 2012
9,832
14,032
Which note app lets you have 2 notes pages side by side ?

Notability can do it - what I like about notability is, the split notes is in app, so I can take things from one note to another if I cut, etc.

GoodNotes' split view is nice too (harder to take something from one note to another tho, if you do that sort of thing).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hunter5117

neutrino23

macrumors 68000
Feb 14, 2003
1,881
391
SF Bay area
I’ve used it some. Their conversion engine is amazing. I mostly use it for creating mathematical text for insertion in other documents. I don’t need to take a lot of notes so I do my scribbling in Concepts. If I was back in school I would probably give this a hard look because it does work so well with handwriting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ericwn
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.