Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
OP I’m 100% with you. Both me and my wife get so annoyed with the keyboards on our phones. I have a 15 pro. I think it’s software related. Some update like 6-8 months ago ruined it and it’s just typo after typo. I type out a sentence and it’s just constant blue underlined that get auto corrected. It’s brutal

Windows phones had the best keyboards ever. I can pull out my old Lumia and can still, after like a decade, type 10 times easier on that than I can on this.
 
I also noticed this. I had a lot of iPhones starting with gen. 1. Typing even on iPhone 1 was much much much better, I could text incredibly fast without making any mistakes. At one point it seems to have gotten worse, and now on my iPhone 15 pro I am making mistakes all the time. I never used auto correction or any other feature, just plain typing. There's something with the finger detection algorithm that is off now. Or the size of the phone, maybe a smaller keyboard was somehow better, I don't know.
 
I also noticed this. I had a lot of iPhones starting with gen. 1. Typing even on iPhone 1 was much much much better, I could text incredibly fast without making any mistakes. At one point it seems to have gotten worse, and now on my iPhone 15 pro I am making mistakes all the time. I never used auto correction or any other feature, just plain typing. There's something with the finger detection algorithm that is off now. Or the size of the phone, maybe a smaller keyboard was somehow better, I don't know.
Just exactly what I mean. Glad to read it
 
  • Like
Reactions: IJustWannaTalk
I think the observation about bezels and weight on later phones is spot on - I've definitely found typing is harder on the newer phones for me and it seems to be mostly around typing near the edge of the keyboard where you don't hit the letter spot on and it selects the wrong one.
 
It's one of those things that is hard to quantify because we type on these devices all the time, but I have to agree with the OP as well. The last phone I recall having a good experience (meaning I could just type away, make few typos, and have most of them corrected adequately) was the iPhone 6. Subjectively, it went down hill from there for me.
 
It’s because of the weight distribution. On the iPhone 8, which I agree is easier to type on, because of the giant bezel and comparative lightness and smaller size, the keyboard sits much higher than on modern phones. But modern phones are also much larger and heavier so you’re really stretching out your hand to try and prevent the phone from slipping out of your grip. Remember, iPhone 8 is basically smaller, lighter, and shorter, and yet the keyboard sits higher. The original iPhones and iPads all had giant bezels. This was not an accident.
This has been my primary assumption. For most of us, the literally bigger stretch causes our thumbs to contact the display/screen at a different angle now, more like 45-degrees or less rather than closer to 90-degrees. This could throw off where we believe our thumbs are (first) making contact versus where they actually are. Additionally, any ‘roll’ as you lift a thumb/finger — which you probably wouldn't even realize/notice — will further problematically change the final touch target.

There’s also the swipey keyboard that messes with everything. I have to turn that one off on each new phone.
I wonder when Apple added the swipe to type feature, consequently made tap to type far worse? I don’t use swipe to type.. anyone recall when that feature was added?
iOS 13 (i.e., iPhone 11)


This would align with the timeframe, iPhone models some are claiming.
 
I started with 7 and have always had to treat any input field (keyboard, link, button, etc.) as placing my bit fat finger over it completely… Instead of a refined precise tap at the tip of my finger like a real keyboard would react to.

iOS has always seemed to predict what you’re trying to type by taking the average of your entire finger, instead of the tip of the finger.

It really does seem to take the actual first touch point and not the intended touch point that a real keyboard with dimension would register. (Which ends up being the big fat middle of the finger.)

So while it is accurate, it’s not intuitive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MacCheetah3
I really think it is bio-mechanical. That’s not to say it’s anyone’s fault, but on the iPhone 6 and earlier, I had to type with deliberate slowness so as to not hit adjacent keys and cut down my error rate. Going to the 8 Plus, then the 14, and typing became easier, and much faster, for me. So it’s easy for me to believe that people who could type comfortably on those small screens would have their typing action thrown off by the bigger screens.

Maybe, as several have already suggested, or alluded to, maybe Apple needs to update their algorithm for calculating the placement of the finger. Although that would probably make it much harder for me to type…
 
  • Like
Reactions: IJustWannaTalk
I know this is diverging from the issue experienced, but I can't figure out why mostly people still type, when the swipe keyboard has become effortless to use (for me).

By the way, have you tried if the smaller, one handed keyboard types better than the standard one?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bungaree.Chubbins
I can't typ on iPhones above 12. Typing this on iMac, because on my 14 Pro it couldn't be done.

Don't know how to describe but typing on 14Pro is just ****ed. Can't typ a normal sentence without mistakes. Autocorrect is on but has to correct just everything.

but then, I used my moms phone (12) and everything went smooth and not a single problem at all. Used an iPhone 8 to test. 10 times better. Held the phone next to each other, there is more space between letters it looks.

You should take an old iPhone and type on it, it's just unbelievable. I cant be the only one. Wanted to switch to Samsung just because of this.....
Just reset the dictionary in your keyboard settings. I had a similar issue where autocorrect kept messing up my text.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.