Honestly, the AppleCare gives me so much peace of mind that I just laughed it off. Plus I have a second Apple Watch to wear in the meantime, Series 1 Space Grey. I'm about to live chat AppleCare and ask for an express replacement. Problem is it's Friday right now and I don't know if they deliver on weekends, I'm supposed to fly out to Jersey on Tuesday for a week. Might have to wait til I get back to California for them to send the replacement.
UnFortunately they don't do express replacements on weekends. Usually because it takes 24 hours for them to ship the product, followed by Sunday being a day where most carriers don't deliver. That's from my understanding.