Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
This is actually completely nonsensical.
Use a macbook without ssd. Use the exact same macbook with ssd.
Notice a difference? ;)

Ssds can not properly replace a memory shortage since obviously ram is worlds faster, but they will make your entire system more responsive either way. You specs geeks can turn it as you like, that's the real world user experience.
 
Use a macbook without ssd. Use the exact same macbook with ssd.
Notice a difference? ;)

Ssds can not properly replace a memory shortage since obviously ram is worlds faster, but they will make your entire system more responsive either way. You specs geeks can turn it as you like, that's the real world user experience.

Yes, I have never upgraded a large number of my computers from a HDD to SSDs in my time, nor have I noticed the difference.... I have also never created a RAM Drive, so I had no idea that memory is faster than an SSD :rolleyes:

Let's look again at what you said:

It's the other way around. An ssd makes everything faster if you have enough memory.

This is complete nonsense.

A spec geek? Yes, I have completely no idea what I am talking about, nor have I ever replaced a hard drive with a SSD and then tested the results extensively in the real world. Oh wait, no, that isn't true.

https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/1293809/

Please don't try to tell me about what a SSD can do, because you have no idea what you're talking about. I don't mean that in a patronising way, but it's just a fact that you have proven with this thread.
 
That is a link to an old, but true thread. I agree with you, but I have no idea why you think what I wrote is nonsensical.

It's because of the way you have worded it, especially using the words "make everything faster" and the bit that follows the "if".

"It's the other way around. An ssd makes everything faster if you have enough memory."

An SSD will not make "everything" faster and the things that it will make faster do not always depend on how much memory you have.

An SSD will not make a CPU or GPU intensive task faster, regardless of whether you have enough RAM, or not.

An SSD will make all file operations faster, regardless of whether you have enough RAM.

Even if you don't have a lot of RAM, an SSD will make your system faster, in comparison to the same system with a HDD, because swapping in and out of memory to the disk will be faster, even though the fastest PCIe "flash" drives are still at least 10 times slower than the typical memory we have in our Macs.

...and so forth and so forth.

Do you see now? :)
 
It's because of the way you have worded it, especially using the words "make everything faster" and the bit that follows the "if".

"It's the other way around. An ssd makes everything faster if you have enough memory."

An SSD will not make "everything" faster and the things that it will make faster do not always depend on how much memory you have.

An SSD will not make a CPU or GPU intensive task faster, regardless of whether you have enough RAM, or not.

An SSD will make all file operations faster, regardless of whether you have enough RAM.

Even if you don't have a lot of RAM, an SSD will make your system faster, in comparison to the same system with a HDD, because swapping in and out of memory to the disk will be faster, even though the fastest PCIe "flash" drives are still at least 10 times slower than the typical memory we have in our Macs.

...and so forth and so forth.

Do you see now? :)
You explained it better. I worded it really basic and bad. I apologize for calling you a spec geek.
 
You explained it better. I worded it really basic and bad. I apologize for calling you a spec geek.

No worries and thank you for the apology. I apologise too for my rather strongly worded reply. I think that I kind of got the gist of what you were trying to say in your initial post, but it was dangerously general and that leaves to confusion amongst users around these parts. :)
 
No worries and thank you for the apology. I apologise too for my rather strongly worded reply. I think that I kind of got the gist of what you were trying to say in your initial post, but it was dangerously general and that leaves to confusion amongst users around these parts. :)
I don't mind a strong reply if there is a point to it. You rightfully told me off. :)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.