Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

LIVEFRMNYC

macrumors G3
Oct 27, 2009
8,877
10,987
1) Display has awful color shifts - there is simply no "perfect" viewing angle. The center is warmer than the top and bottom. The display is also incapable of displaying a white background, the best it gets is a vague light yellow.

This statement alone tells me your just trolling.

2) Responsiveness. Still a year behind the 4S, probably 2 years behind the 5. Jelly bean can't come soon enough.

More trolling.

3) Stability. Play Store crashed multiple times. Flipboard is unresponsive on launch. Even Gmail has crashed a few times already.

Playstore never crashed on me. Flipboard is one of the most responsive apps. I know cause I press launch it often by mistake when I confuse it's icon with FreeiD YouTube player. It always loads up lighting fast and ready to be flipped right away.



4) Autobrightness is a joke - needed to pay for a $2.99 app for a function that should have been perfected on the phone.

Yes, Autobrightness on the GS3 does suck. But I keep my brightness at full most of the time anyways. the battery still lasts me a day.

5) Audio quality - Hiss hiss hiss on quiet songs. Wow, you don't notice these quality issues you give up on these things until you're not using an iPHone anymore.

Let me guess, you pirated low bitrate music. ;)

Music quality is good on the GS3.

I won't get into app disparity, build quality or anything, but by itself, the GS3 is just so far behind software and hardware wise, it's really sad. Being returned, and back to considering another iPHone 5.

Have fun with your 5.
 

Wrathwitch

macrumors 65816
Dec 4, 2009
1,303
55
Think id take It back and get another since i cant agree with any of that

Take it back, it's broken. Non of the above is in line with my experiences with the phone.

Doesn't apply to mine.

OP if you would have had similar issues with an iPhone would you think it's because the phone sucks or would you think that it's a defective device?

you either got a duff phone or are trolling, I got my S3 on Saturday and had none of these problems.

Both the S3 and iPhone 5 are top of the range phones with different personalities (its like choosing between Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers or Ronaldo and Messi), Can we not just leave it at that?

1) Disagree. Display is great. You seem to be nitpicking or have a faulty display.

2) Agree (kinda). I have an S3 with Jelly Bean and an iPhone 5. Jelly Bean is a massive improvement in terms of smoothness but the iPhone 5 is on another level. It just responds instantly to everything. No thinking time necessary, you touch and it responds immediately. There is a slight delay with Android that you don't really notice until you use an iPhone.

3) Don't have any of those problems. Apps only crash occasionally.

4) No problem with auto brightness (again on Jelly Bean). It jumps suddenly sometimes, but seems okay for the most part.

5) Again, no problems here. Not sure what you're talking about!

This just sounds like you got a bad device, this happens on iPhone too.

Do these posts not give you the hint that instead of being really dissatisfied with the phone and waxing on how terrible it is, that perhaps, just perhaps you got a defective phone?

Jesus, if you had these problems with the iPHone, you would be rushing to the Apple Store instead of complaining about it on a forum. Try the same thing with the S3

:rolleyes:
 

mzjin

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Oct 28, 2011
412
0
Do these posts not give you the hint that instead of being really dissatisfied with the phone and waxing on how terrible it is, that perhaps, just perhaps you got a defective phone?

Jesus, if you had these problems with the iPHone, you would be rushing to the Apple Store instead of complaining about it on a forum. Try the same thing with the S3

:rolleyes:

After comparing mine with the store display models, mine is not at all defective.

1) If you can't see the brightness shift and viewing angle inferiority of the S3, you are blind. As a bat. Sorry, we can't all have great vision.

2) Smoothness... wow you guys really are trolling. Ice Cream sandwhich is like 3GS level. Flipboard is like lag patrol. iPhone 4 is way faster than this thing, forget 4S. The 5 feels like a Quad Core laptop with an SSD in comparison, and is on a completely different level altogether.

3) The Audio has a base level HISS. This has nothing to do with GS3's audio quality, just noise filtering. If you plug headphones into an iPhone you get NO backgground hiss. GS3? Background HISS.

Listen to Classical music like I do? YEs, you can hear it in the quiet movements.
 

Dolorian

macrumors 65816
Apr 25, 2007
1,086
0
Auto brightness can easily be turned off in the notifications. There is a slider for the brightness there and a checkbox for auto brightness. If you don't have it, perform a software update then it should come up.
 

mzjin

macrumors 6502
Original poster
Oct 28, 2011
412
0
Auto brightness can easily be turned off in the notifications. There is a slider for the brightness there and a checkbox for auto brightness. If you don't have it, perform a software update then it should come up.

The point is that Autobrightness... should WORK. It should not be at lowest brightness in almost all circumstances. It should max out your brightness when you're in the sun. It should only be at the lowest brightness level when you're in pitch black darkness.

I had to use LUX to get Autobrightness working like an iPhone does. $2.99 App that Google's developers couldn't get right.
 

Mrg02d

macrumors 65816
Jan 27, 2012
1,102
2
What I find funny is iDevice people deciding that tiny flaws in an android device make it "trash" but go out of their way to defend an iDevice. They also GROSSLY over exaggerate problems with android. You yuppies forget many of us also have iDevice to compare to so we KNOW WHAT THE HELL we are talking about!

I've always had an android phone and have had my iPad 3 since day one. I'm familiar with iOS as well as android. The garbage you apple people post is appalling.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Jagardn

macrumors 6502a
Apr 18, 2011
668
2
If you're going to make up rubbish about the Galaxy S3 then at least make it sound realistic.

1)the Play store has never crashed, ever

2)the audio on the S3 is exceptional

Yup, I guess that means because I am having none of the problems being reported on the forums with my iPhone, no one else's problems exist.
 

WRXHokie

macrumors regular
Sep 12, 2005
247
166
Gotha, FL
What I find funny is iDevice people deciding that tiny flaws in an android device make it "trash" but go out of their way to defend an iDevice. They also GROSSLY over exaggerate problems with android. You yuppies forget many of us also have iDevice to compare to so we KNOW WHAT THE HELL we are talking about!

I've always had an android phone and have had my iPad 3 since day one. I'm familiar with iOS as well as android. The garbage you apple people post is appalling.

Almost 100% of the people on this forum came from an iDevice and switched to an android. So yes, this guy is trolling. And trolling hard. Anyone that says the iPhone 4 and the 3GS are similar in speed really is trolling hard. I just came from a 4, and the difference is measured in light years. The things he picked out to criticize are the ones that would get the biggest response from the board. I hope the admins do what right here and ban this dude.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Southernboyj

macrumors 68000
Mar 8, 2012
1,694
69
Mobile, AL
After comparing mine with the store display models, mine is not at all defective.

1) If you can't see the brightness shift and viewing angle inferiority of the S3, you are blind. As a bat. Sorry, we can't all have great vision.

2) Smoothness... wow you guys really are trolling. Ice Cream sandwhich is like 3GS level. Flipboard is like lag patrol. iPhone 4 is way faster than this thing, forget 4S. The 5 feels like a Quad Core laptop with an SSD in comparison, and is on a completely different level altogether.

3) The Audio has a base level HISS. This has nothing to do with GS3's audio quality, just noise filtering. If you plug headphones into an iPhone you get NO backgground hiss. GS3? Background HISS.


Listen to Classical music like I do? YEs, you can hear it in the quiet movements.


Return your Beats by Dre and get some real headphones. I love the Galaxy S3 for music, it's equalizer is far superior to Apple's. Not saying the iPhone 5 is bad. I love it, just Galaxy S3 music player > iPhone music player.

Not to mention I can adjust the equalizer in the app. Instead of having to go Home -> Settins -> iPod -> EQ.
 

Dunbar

macrumors 6502a
Jun 25, 2010
557
114
Los Angeles, CA
If you want to see a device with some REAL screen issues I'll show you my iPad 3. It has some serious flashlighting on one side that is very noticeable when scrolling. You want to see something impressive, load up a dark HD video on your S3 and be amazed at the black levels.
 

Dontazemebro

macrumors 68020
Jul 23, 2010
2,173
0
I dunno, somewhere in West Texas
Thing is he does make some valid points and this is coming from a long time android user since its inception.

1 . There is a hiss. It's ever so subtle but if you play a song that has breaks in between without any instruments, you can hear it.

2. The SG3 screen is garbage under sunlight. You literally have to put it at its brightest setting just so it's visible. compare a one X at 50% brightness under sunlight with a GS3 and you'll see exactly what I mean.

3. The only real choppiness in Android is in the browser and I really wouldn't call it choppiness. It's more like a jerk. Don't scroll, but flick the screen a little ways and you'll notice how it kinda jerks while moving. Thing is, this is just how android works.

Now slamming an entire OS/phone based on minor flaws is trollish but his claims are not altogether baseless.
 

tshrimp

macrumors 6502
Mar 30, 2012
421
3,443
Let's see where to start...

Positives? Big screen. 4G LTE free tethering apps. Way better Google Voice integration. 4G talk + data at the same time (comes in handy when you're waiting on for customer support or something).

Everything else? Some bad, some REALLY bad:

1) Display has awful color shifts - there is simply no "perfect" viewing angle. The center is warmer than the top and bottom. The display is also incapable of displaying a white background, the best it gets is a vague light yellow.

2) Responsiveness. Still a year behind the 4S, probably 2 years behind the 5. Jelly bean can't come soon enough.

3) Stability. Play Store crashed multiple times. Flipboard is unresponsive on launch. Even Gmail has crashed a few times already.

4) Autobrightness is a joke - needed to pay for a $2.99 app for a function that should have been perfected on the phone.

5) Audio quality - Hiss hiss hiss on quiet songs. Wow, you don't notice these quality issues you give up on these things until you're not using an iPHone anymore.

I won't get into app disparity, build quality or anything, but by itself, the GS3 is just so far behind software and hardware wise, it's really sad. Being returned, and back to considering another iPHone 5.

I would return it. It should not be this way, and you may have a defective unit. Good luck.
 

Dunbar

macrumors 6502a
Jun 25, 2010
557
114
Los Angeles, CA
3. The only real choppiness in Android is in the browser and I really wouldn't call it choppiness. It's more like a jerk. Don't scroll, but flick the screen a little ways and you'll notice how it kinda jerks while moving. Thing is, this is just how android works.

Have never noticed that on the stock browser on S3. Chrome has choppy scrolling on Android and iOS.
 

cwwilson

macrumors 68000
Jan 27, 2009
1,924
1,536
Oklahoma City, OK
Let's see where to start...

Positives? Big screen. 4G LTE free tethering apps. Way better Google Voice integration. 4G talk + data at the same time (comes in handy when you're waiting on for customer support or something).

Everything else? Some bad, some REALLY bad:

1) Display has awful color shifts - there is simply no "perfect" viewing angle. The center is warmer than the top and bottom. The display is also incapable of displaying a white background, the best it gets is a vague light yellow.

2) Responsiveness. Still a year behind the 4S, probably 2 years behind the 5. Jelly bean can't come soon enough.

3) Stability. Play Store crashed multiple times. Flipboard is unresponsive on launch. Even Gmail has crashed a few times already.

4) Autobrightness is a joke - needed to pay for a $2.99 app for a function that should have been perfected on the phone.

5) Audio quality - Hiss hiss hiss on quiet songs. Wow, you don't notice these quality issues you give up on these things until you're not using an iPHone anymore.

I won't get into app disparity, build quality or anything, but by itself, the GS3 is just so far behind software and hardware wise, it's really sad. Being returned, and back to considering another iPHone 5.


Yeah i'm not believing any of that. But good luck with your iPhone.
 

djarpit

macrumors regular
Jun 9, 2009
160
0
Let's see where to start...

Positives? Big screen. 4G LTE free tethering apps. Way better Google Voice integration. 4G talk + data at the same time (comes in handy when you're waiting on for customer support or something).

Everything else? Some bad, some REALLY bad:

1) Display has awful color shifts - there is simply no "perfect" viewing angle. The center is warmer than the top and bottom. The display is also incapable of displaying a white background, the best it gets is a vague light yellow.

2) Responsiveness. Still a year behind the 4S, probably 2 years behind the 5. Jelly bean can't come soon enough.

3) Stability. Play Store crashed multiple times. Flipboard is unresponsive on launch. Even Gmail has crashed a few times already.

4) Autobrightness is a joke - needed to pay for a $2.99 app for a function that should have been perfected on the phone.

5) Audio quality - Hiss hiss hiss on quiet songs. Wow, you don't notice these quality issues you give up on these things until you're not using an iPHone anymore.

I won't get into app disparity, build quality or anything, but by itself, the GS3 is just so far behind software and hardware wise, it's really sad. Being returned, and back to considering another iPHone 5.


1. Love my display. just increase brightness and youll be good
2. Jelly Bean is your answer here. and it not samsung its the touch wiz that slows it down. Jelly Bean is fast as hell
3. never happened to me
4. you dont have to. there is a builtin auto brightness in jelly bean and even ICS
5. No problem here I use headphones/bluetooth and no issues whatsoever
 

oBMTo

macrumors 6502
Oct 12, 2010
271
0
Where's Day 2 of "I don't really have an S3, but let's make a troll thread"?
 

b24pgg

macrumors 65816
Jan 28, 2009
1,108
0
CA
A great analogy for OPs post is a comparison of a sedan to a Ferrari, and then complaining that the Ferrari is worse because it has less space in the backseat.
 

jazzkids

macrumors member
Feb 3, 2004
79
0
Providence, RI
Think id take It back and get another since i cant agree with any of that

Agreed, take it back. I switched over from an iPhone and I love it! I'm happy to not be tied down to Apple's ecosystem. Since I use maps often, I would be seriously bummed with the new map problem in the IP5
 

BoxerGT2.5

macrumors 68020
Jun 4, 2008
2,114
14,154
Android is just less stable and less tuned for specific hardware. Then you throw another layer of manufacturer/carrier skin and apps on top, and you're bound to have much buggy, unresponsive software. Android being generic is also why it is less polished than iOS, it needs to run on a wide range of devices and specs.

Personally I think it's one of the most glaring flaws in Android, and one that they really can't remedy without stepping on their "open" principle. Being "open" isn't all that advantageous to being "closed," in my opinion.


How about a closed system with a joke of a maps app and no way for the user to select what he or she would like to use as a default? Right about now open sounds pretty good.
 

zbarvian

macrumors 68010
Jul 23, 2011
2,004
2
How about a closed system with a joke of a maps app and no way for the user to select what he or she would like to use as a default? Right about now open sounds pretty good.

There's no right answer here, to each his own.
 

BoxerGT2.5

macrumors 68020
Jun 4, 2008
2,114
14,154
There's no right answer here, to each his own.


Don't get me wrong, I love the phone (iPhone 5). But I don't trust it. I travel a lot and maps is something I use very often. Having it integrated with my device makes my life easier. When I click on an address from an email or contact, I want to know the info I get is accurate. Copy and pasting addresses to a 3rd party app is not my idea of fun.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.