OP, you need a few more options:
4: Stay with existing iPhone
5: Stay with existing non iOS device
I stopped using an iPhone earlier this year and am now using an HTC One. I have my sights on a few other devices, none of which are from Apple.
This post pretty much sums up my feelings about ever returning to an iPhone.
I sold my iPhone 4S a few months ago and bought an HTC One.
Here's what Apple needs to do to make me consider switching back:
- Open up iOS and allow widgits, 3rd party keyboards, theming, etc.
- Allow users to select default apps. I don't want URLs from emails to open in Safari. I don't want location links to open in Apple Maps.
- Offer a file system.
- Offer a larger screen.
I don't know what Apple would have to do to get me to leave the iPhone but it would have to be pretty darn drastic. I'm pretty much ingrained into the Apple ecosystem at this point.
This argument really doesn't hold water any longer. Boomhower, I'd bet my home has far more Apple device (Macs, iPhones, iPads, iPod, Apple TV, Airport devices, etc) and is firmly planted in the Apple ecosystem yet I have no problem continuing to interact with any/all of them via my Android devices. Yes, you may have to repurchase some apps but my guess is if you can afford to drop $199-399 on a new phone, rebuying a few apps shouldn't break the bank. You'll also find that many apps that cost money on iOS are free on Android.