Did Apple’s analytics cause them to remove MagSafe for no reason and then bring it back? Not everything Apple does makes sense, but at least they’re moving in the right direction again.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Does someone find the "new ports" the same useless as me ?
- Thread starter Micka88
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Yes, it does (seriously). Just now I raised the Macbook a bit (to see if I forgot some paper under it) and mag safe disconnected immediately.
I see, it is prohibited to move with the laptop on the table, if you do it, it is error. Good to know ...
The legacy ports dont bother me, at the same time they are of no use to me. Mag Sage is take it or leave it, and I will say I've already run into a moment where I missed the fourth usb-c port. It's a bit funny to me that of all the ports they decided to bring back, they omitted the USB-A port. Of all the old ports, that's the one I would have requested.
Just took my 14" on its first travel use case and found the abundance of ports extremely useful - I used all USB-C ports to charge my stuff and even could have used a 4th!
I have to be honest - I felt the same when I saw and touched the new machines.
The shaping of it is like an aluminum "bathtub" or something.
Functional for sure -- just went from 100 to about a 20 on the "sexy" scale.
Yeah it's very weird to me in person. Was very jaunting after using my M1 Air for so long. The screen looks amazing, but I really do not like the aesthetic of everything else. And that notch is worse than I thought it would be.
Seems to me like Apple made some reasonable compromises on port selection to serve a variety of creative professionals. Not ever going to completely please everyone. Loss of one USBC and gaining MagSafe, SD, and HDMI to answer all the folks bemoaning their loss seems pretty reasonable. Even if the ports aren’t top spec— super useful to connect to a projector or something in a pinch without dongles. Glad to see Apple is actually listening to folks and prioritizing function over form for once. I think the new laptops look great. Really do seem like a little bit of an homage to the old TiBook.
Last edited:
This is the ideal unibody. You may not like it, but this is what peak performance looks like.
It was a joke. I'm not sure what you are expecting me to say?
Yea the billion SD cards out there will all go away tomorrow.
Explain how it’s faster to search for a cable, connect to your camera, connect it to your computer than it is to just pop out an SD card and insert it?
As with the notch on the iPhone, some people see it as extra screen space while others view it as less.
My guess is that Apple had hoped that they could push users towards adopting usb-C for everything.
Take this setup for example. Samsung has started bundling usb c to c cables with their T5 drives for a few years now. And best of all, you can plug these cables into any port you want, because they are all usb c on one end.
It’s all very clean and streamlined if you can get the right accessories for it, but admittedly, not everyone may be committed enough to go to that extent.
Cable is always around and needs just one second to connect. And it is much faster than opening the port in the camera, removing the card, putting the card in the computer port, removing from the port and putting back to the camera (not speaking of a potential card damage when doing this). When you have 2 SD cards in the camera, for sure the photos/videos you need will be in the other one (while when connecting via cable you see both).
And as I can see, some softwares have difficulties reading and importing directly from the card port (like Capture One - I tried, it was almost impossible, connecting to the camera - it was done immediately)
This can be done also with the new models.
Generally speaking you do not have 1 TB4/USB-C less, you have the same number of usable ports since 1 was used for charging anyway.
But with the new one now you can have this AND a HDMI projector attached AND still have the SD CARD slot free to be usable....See? more ports are always better...
Only in 1 scenario you will have 1 USB-C more, when you connect a USB-C monitor that also charge the laptop....but in this case you will probably have the laptop connected to a TB4/TB3 dock anyway....
You are right, but I am also reminded of the iphone which lost its headphone jack a few years ago. In hindsight, here’s where I think Apple was trying to go with the 2016 MBP design.
They wanted a thin and light form factor, all the better to appeal to the mass consumer. This is perhaps where their design team erred - you have a product that professionals rely on for their work, but are being forced to make sacrifices for another segment of users.
The compromises included the butterfly keyboard, the prone-to-breaking display cable, lesser battery and worse thermals. Which were further compounded by Intel evidently not being able to meet their promised roadmap.
My guess is that the move to all usb-c was also in part to enable this thinner form factor. Looking at the side of the MBP, there was clearly no space for a HDMI port, and having 2 ports on each side made for a cleaner symmetrical look.
I also believe that going all-in on USB-C was also intended to force the hand of manufacturers and consumers everywhere. Yes, in the short run, users may be inconvenienced when they find they don’t have a desired adaptor on hand, but perhaps the ideal was that in the long run, everyone is using USB-C for everything, from power to data to display.
That’s perhaps the future of computing that Apple was trying to drive - a thin and light package that can tether to an ultra-powerful rig (eg: a 5k display with attached e-GPU, multiple external drives and Ethernet) when needed.
It’s classic “short term pain for long term gain”. It sounded good on paper, but I guess this is one area where Apple tried to push users in one direction, and they ended up pushing back.